Ravi Oraon v. The State of Jharkhand & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1212; [2025] 11 S.C.R. 226
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 9 Oct 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11748/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 226 : 2025 INSC 1212 Ravi Oraon v.
The State of Jharkhand & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 11748 of 2025)
09 October 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and K.V. Viswanathan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Despite fresh appointment of the appellants, the basic question that survives is whether the termination of services of the appellants, on the ground that their graduation certificates were not valid and they had not secured at least 40% marks in the intermediate examination taken by them, was proper; nature and extent of grant of relief, if any, should the basic question be decided in favour of the appellants; claim of the other appellant (since deceased) in the changed circumstances.
Headnotes† Jharkhand Primary School Teacher Appointment Rules, 2012 – Show cause notices were issued to the appellants-teachers alleging that they did not fulfil the eligibility criterion of having secured a minimum of 45% marks in their intermediate examination (Class XII) and that their graduation certificates were not valid – Appellants replied that being members of the ST category, they were required to secure only 40% marks which they did and were thus, eligibile – However, the respondents terminated the appellants’ services by computing their marks after excluding the marks secured in the vocational subject and stated that they had secured less than 40% marks and that their certificates of graduation were also not proper – Termination orders set aside by Single Judge – Division Bench allowed the appeals filed by the respondents – Interference with:
Held: 1.1 The degrees awarded to the appellants prior to 26.02.2015 have been treated to be valid by the Government of Jharkhand by way of a policy decision – Further, termination orders are unsustainable and vitiated for violation of principles of natural justice, set aside – Appellants successfully defended the charge against them but the respondents found them guilty of a different charge in respect whereof they were not put to notice – In such a case, * Author [2025] 11 S.C.R. 227Ravi Oraon v. The State of Jharkhand & Ors. the finding of guilt which is at variance with the original charge without proper opportunity to respond offends due process and renders any order or action unsustainable. [Paras 10, 32, 33, 38] 1.2 Appellants, in their replies to the show cause notices categorically demonstrated that they were not required to secure 45% marks in their intermediate examination – They were required to secure more than 40% marks in the intermediate examination, which they did secure – However, the respondents terminated the appellants’ services by computing their marks after excluding the marks secured in the vocational subject without affording the appellants notice or an opportunity to contest such exclusion –The allegation that the appellants had failed to secure 40% marks (after exclusion of marks secured in the vocational subject) in the intermediate examination did not even figure as an allegation in the show cause notices – Therefore, findings were returned by the respondents which were at variance with the allegations levelled in the show cause notices. [Paras 32, 36] 1.3 Appellants having successfully defended the allegations, the respondents were precluded in law from proceeding with such notices – In the absence of fresh show cause notices specifically requiring the appellants to explain why the marks secured in the vocational subject should not be taken into account for determining their overall percentage, the appellants were denied a fair and reasonable opportunity of hearing – Moreover, the procedure in r.21 is only to be used for the purpose of preparation of merit list and r.4 does not provide for exclusion of marks secured in the vocational subject – Judgments of the Division Bench set aside. [Paras 32, 38] 1.4 Appellants to be treated to have been in continuous service from the date(s) of their original appointment, as if their services were never terminated – Entitled to service benefits like arrears of pay in full and seniority counted from the dates of initial appointment – However, for the purpose of meeting the experience criterion for promotion, the period not spent on duty will not be counted. [Para 39] 1.5 The other appellant (since deceased) shall be deemed to have died-in-harness and if there be a scheme for compassionate employment, his heirs may apply thereunder. [Para 40] Jharkhand Primary School Teacher Appointment Rules, 2012 – rr.4, 21 – Whether r.21 will bar/override the method provided in the marksheet:
228 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: 1.1 No reason as to why the method of calculation of the percentage, as provided on the reverse of the marksheet of the appellants, should not be applied for the purpose of calculation of their marks – Marks secured in the vocational subject is a way for a candidate to improve his/her overall percentage of marks – A vocational subject, though optional, would place an additional burden on an examinee which he/she shoulders in the fervent hope of improving his/her overall percentage – In the absence of a bar or an alternate method provided by any law, the method provided on the marksheet has to be followed – Therefore, the onus of proof shifted to the respondents to show that calculation as per the marksheet is not warranted. [Paras 23, 24] 1.2 The heading of r.21 makes it clear that the procedure in this rule applies only at the time of preparing the “Merit List” – r.21 is no way concerned with providing a mechanism for deciding whether a candidate is eligible or not – That consideration falls within the exclusive domain of r.4, which provides for an eligibility criteria for the purpose of appearing in the Teacher Eligibility Test. [Para 26] 1.3 A combined reading of both the rules, therefore, is that the eligibility of a candidate for appearing in the Teacher Eligibility Test is to be decided in accordance with r.4 and Merit list (for the purposes of appointment) is to be prepared in accordance with r.21 – Thus, the respondents erred in applying r.21 for the purpose of deciding whether the appellants fulfilled the eligibility criteria – Division Bench also committed the same error. [Para 28] 1.4 In accordance with r.4, which does not provide for exclusion of marks secured in the vocational subject, and r.21 not being applicable for determining the eligibility of a candidate, the only method for calculation of the marks is the one which is provided on the reverse side of the marksheet of the appellants, according to which the appellants have secured more that 40% marks – Therefore, the appellants were eligible to appear in the Teacher Eligibility Test Examination. [Para 29] Case Law Cited Escorts Farms Ltd. v. Commissioner, Kumaon Division, Nainital, V.P. & Others [2004] 2 SCR 543 : (2004) 4 SCC 281 – held inapplicable.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 229Ravi Oraon v. The State of Jharkhand & Ors. Vijoy Kumar v. State of Jharkhand W.P.(C) No. 3115 of 2015 – referred to.
List of Acts Jharkhand Primary School Teacher Appointment Rules, 2012; Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Termination; Intermediate Trained Teacher (Classes I to V); Teacher Eligibility Test Examination; Eligibility criterion; Minimum 45% marks in intermediate examination (Class XII); Minimum qualifying marks; Vocational subject; Exclusion of marks secured in vocational subject; Method for calculation of marks; Show cause notices; Original charge; Different charge; No fresh show cause notice; Graduation certificates valid; 40% marks in intermediate examination; Rules 4, 21 of the Jharkhand Primary School Teacher Appointment Rules, 2012; Hindi Vidyapeeth; Termination arbitrary, illegal; Method provided in the marksheet; Reverse side of the marksheet; Compulsory subjects; Termination order unsustainable; Violation of principles of natural justice.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11748 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 03.08.2021 of the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi in LPA No. 83 of 2019 With Civil Appeal Nos. 11749 and 11750 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Binod Singh, Ms. Sangeeta Singh.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Syed Uruj Abbas, A.A.G., Rajiv Shankar Dvivedi, Shantanu Sagar, Anil Kumar, Gunjesh Ranjan, Niket Nalin, Manoneet Dwivedi, Abhishek Kumar Gupta, Jayesh Gaurav, Ms. Diksha Ojha, Ishwar Chandra Roy, Farrukh Rasheed.
230 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
The A ppeAls
1. The lead appeal1 challenges the judgment and order dated 3 rd August, 2021 passed by the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi in L.P.A. No. 83 of 2019, whereby the High Court allowed the intra-court appeal filed by the respondents. Relying upon the said judgment, the High Court later allowed two other intra-court appeals of the respondents, viz. L.P.A. No. 332 of 2021 and L.P.A. No. 331 of 2021, by two separate judgments of the same date, i.e., 20th December, 2022. These latter judgments are under challenge in the connected appeals 2 before us. FAcTs
2. Facts, relevant for the disposal of the present appeals, are these: a. Certain posts of Intermediate Trained Teacher (Classes I to V) were advertised on 10th August, 2015 3 by the District Education Superintendent, Dhanbad (respondent no. 4) 4 . The appellants applied for the post and acquitted themselves successfully in the recruitment process. After completion of the joining formalities, the appellants started discharging their duties from December, 2015 as teachers.
b. On 27 th September, 2016, show cause notices were issued to the appellants alleging that they did not fulfil the eligibility criterion of having secured a minimum of 45% marks in their intermediate examination (Class XII). Questions were also raised on the validity of their certificates of graduation.
c. In October 2016, through separate replies to the show cause notices, the appellants contended that being members of the 1 Civil Appeal No. 11748 of 2025 2 Civil Appeal Nos. 11749 and 11750 of 2025 3 Advertisement No. 10/2015 4 Department [2025] 11 S.C.R. 231Ravi Oraon v. The State of Jharkhand & Ors. Scheduled Tribe category, they were required to secure only 40% marks in the intermediate examination and not 45%. In other words, they were entitled to a relaxation of 5% marks in terms of the advertisement. It was further asserted that Ravi, Premlal and Surendra had secured 42.55%, 40.22%, and 41.33% marks, respectively, in the intermediate examination and, thus, were eligible for participation in the recruitment process. With respect to the issue concerning their graduation certificates, the appellants clarified that no graduation certificate was required for appointment on posts of teachers in Classes I–V, and that the same had been furnished by them only for the sake of completeness.
d. On 7 th October, 2016, by separate office orders, the services of the appellants were terminated on the ground that they had secured less than 40% marks in the intermediate examination and that their certificates of graduation were not proper. According to the calculation made by the Department, Ravi, Premlal, and Surendra had secured 38.56%, 39.78%, and 39% marks, respectively in the intermediate examination. In arriving at this calculation, the Department excluded the additional marks secured by the appellants in the vocational subject. We shall examine the validity of this method of calculation a little later. e. Appellants challenged the termination orders dated 7 th October, 2016, before the High Court by filing separate writ petitions 5 . A Single Judge of the High Court allowed these petitions in the years 2018 and 2022 and, consequently, the impugned termination orders were set aside.
f. Aggrieved thereby, the respondents preferred intra-court appeals. As noted before, a Division Bench of the High Court allowed these appeals and dismissed the challenge laid by the appellants to the orders terminating their services.
g. Crestfallen by such determination, the appellants have invoked this Court’s appellate jurisdiction.
5 W.P. (S) Nos. 6607, 6704 and 6608 of 2016 232 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports J udgmenTs oF The single J udge
3. The writ petition filed by Ravi was allowed vide judgment and order dated 16th August, 2018 whereas the remaining two writ petitions presented by Premlal and Surendra were allowed vide a common judgment and order dated 10 th November, 2022. A summary of the judgments reads thus:
a. W.P. (S) No. 6607 of 2016 of Ravi: The Single Judge noted that the respondent (department), for ascertaining the minimum qualification of the candidate, erroneously relied on Rule 21 of the Jharkhand Primary School Teacher Appointment Rules, 20126 , which laid down the procedure for preparing the ‘meritlist’ of candidates and did not provide for ascertaining ‘minimum qualification’. It was further held that Ravi’s services could not have been terminated merely on a show-cause notice without a departmental enquiry. Noting that Ravi had secured more than 40% (383/900) marks in his intermediate examination, the Court quashed the order of termination of service.
b. W.P. (S) Nos. 6704 & 6608 of 2016 of Premlal and Surendra, respectively: The Single Judge allowed the writ petitions upon finding that Premlal and Surendra had secured more than 40% marks in the intermediate examination taken by them. A submission was made by the counsel for the Council that in calculating the percentage of marks secured by Premlal and Surendra, the Department had considered only the marks secured in the main subjects and excluded the marks in the vocational subject. Had the marks secured in the vocational subject been included, both Premlal and Surendra would stand to score above 40%. In view of the submission made on behalf of the Council, the writ petitions were allowed and the termination orders quashed.
impugned J udgmenTs And orders oF The division B ench
4. We propose to summarise the judgment and order impugned in the lead appeal as the other judgments and orders, impugned in the connected appeals, were passed relying upon the former. 6 2012 Rules [2025] 11 S.C.R. 233Ravi Oraon v. The State of Jharkhand & Ors. a. In the impugned judgment the Division Bench reasoned that the marks secured by Ravi in the vocational subject could not have been included for preparing the “merit list”. Although a regulation printed on the reverse side of the marksheet provided that the bonus marks (over and above the pass marks) secured in the vocational subject will be added to the sum total of marks secured in the main subjects, the Division Bench held that such regulation would not apply for the purpose of calculation of marks under the present recruitment. In support thereof, the Division Bench assigned three reasons which are reproduced below: First, the Regulation, as mentioned in the mark-sheet does not govern the matter of recruitment rather it only governs the process of examination and nothing more. Secondly, when the rules have been framed in the year 2012 the recruitment process will proceed as per the statutory provision as framed in the year 2012. Thirdly, the Regulation only speaks about addition of marks obtained in the vocational subject for the preparation of result and nothing else.
b. Appellants argued that once the Department had accepted their reply to the show cause notice – wherein they explained that they were required to secure only 40% marks in the intermediate examination being members of the reserved category – the Department was obliged to issue a fresh show cause notice before terminating their services on the ground that they had not secured 40% marks. The Division Bench, placing reliance on paragraph 64 of the decision of this Court in Escorts Farms Ltd. v. Commissioner, Kumaon Division, Nainital, V.P. & others7 , rejected this argument after noting that the offending act of the Department did not violate the principle of natural justice as there was “no requirement to follow the principle of natural justice when the fact is not in dispute”. Since, Rule 21 of the 2012 Rules precludes the addition of marks secured in the vocational subjects, the Division Bench noted that even if fresh show cause notices were issued, the appellants could not have rebutted the requirement of the said rule.
7 (2004) 4 SCC 281
234 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports c. The Division Bench noted that the Single Judge had held that since Ravi was allowed to participate in the Teacher Eligibility Test under Rule 4 (considering him to have secured 40% marks), he would be deemed to have secured 40% marks for the purpose of appointment as well. Disagreeing with this reasoning, the Division Bench observed that Rule 4 and Rule 21 operate in different contexts. Chapter 2 of the Rules deals with participation in the Teacher Eligibility Test, while Chapter 3 prescribes the process for recruitment as a teacher. Both chapters serve distinct purposes: Chapter 2 establishes eligibility to appear in the Test, whereas Chapter 3 governs the actual recruitment process. It was further noted that the Teacher Eligibility Test is only an eligibility criterion for consideration for appointment on the post of teacher. Allowing a candidate to appear in the Test, even without meeting the 40% marks requirement under Rule 4, does not confer any right to claim appointment. Thus, the Division Bench found the termination of the appellants to be proper.
developmenTs since The pArTies were involved in liTigATion
5. Before proceeding to examine the merits of the rival contentions, it is necessary to note certain developments after the parties started litigating.
6. First, the controversy as to whether the degrees awarded by Hindi Vidyapeeth, Deoghar 8 were valid was set to rest by a judgment and order of the High Court dated 10 th May, 2022 in Vijoy Kumar v. State of Jharkhand9 . It was declared therein that the various degrees 10 awarded by the Vidyapeeth prior to 26 th February, 2015 would be valid. Vide a letter 11 issued by the Secretary to the Government of Jharkhand, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms & Rajbhasha, the Government upon considering the opinion of the Advocate General notified its decision inter alia to the effect that the degrees awarded by the Vidyapeeth prior to 26 th February, 2015 would be valid for appointment and promotion and those awarded 8 Vidyapeeth 9 W.P.(C) No.3115 of 2015 and batch matters 10 Praveshika, Sahitya Bhushan and Sahitya Alankar 11 No.-15/Policy Ni.-07-03/2022 Ka.-3475 dated 15 th June, 2023 [2025] 11 S.C.R. 235Ravi Oraon v. The State of Jharkhand & Ors. thereafter would not be valid. It was also sought to be informed that the policy decisions taken by the Government, mentioned in such letter, would be effective from 26 th February, 2015.
7. Secondly, consequent upon the aforesaid development, it has been brought to our notice that the appellants – Ravi and Premlal – have been freshly appointed as teachers on 17th January, 2025. As a result of such fresh appointment, however, they stand to lose the benefit of their past services.
8. Laslty, it has also been brought to our notice that the appellant – Surendra – breathed his last on 5 th August, 2024, i.e., prior to fresh appointment of the other appellants – Ravi and Premlal. He could not thus be extended the benefit of fresh appointment. Be that as it may, if the other appellants – Ravi and Premlal – succeed in persuading us to hold in their favour, the heirs of the appellant – Surendra – would be entitled to similar but limited relief other than reinstatement in service.
QuesTions
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.