Legislative Council U.P. Lucknow & Ors. v. Sushil Kumar & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1241; [2025] 10 S.C.R. 631
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari
- Decided
- 16 Oct 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11842/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 631 : 2025 INSC 1241 Legislative Council U.P. Lucknow & Ors.
v.
Sushil Kumar & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 11842 of 2025)
16 October 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari* and Vijay Bishnoi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(1) Whether the Division Bench of the High Court while entertaining Special Appeal Defective No.485/2023 against the order of Single Judge along with Writ-A No.140/2022 was justified to direct the office to register a separate case as suo moto PIL and to hold a preliminary enquiry through CBI asking for a report within the specified time; (2) Whether the facts and circumstances of the case warrant a CBI enquiry in line with the established guidelines of this Court.
Headnotes† Constitution of India – Art.226 – Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946 – CBI inquiry – The dispute was set into motion when challenge was laid to the selection process of various posts under the Secretariat of Legislative Council – The prime grievance was of unfairness, arbitrariness and collusiveness in the selection process – The Division Bench of the High Court gave directions to CBI for conducting the preliminary enquiry and to submit a report – The office was also directed to register the case as suo moto Public Interest Litigation – Correctness:
Held: An order directing an investigation to be carried out by CBI should be treated as a measure of last resort, justified only when the Constitutional Court is convinced that the integrity of the process has been compromised – Such compelling circumstances may typically arise when the materials brought in notice of the court prima facie point towards systemic failure, the involvement of high-ranking State officials or politically influential persons, or when the local police’s conduct itself creates a reasonable doubt in the minds of the citizenry regarding their ability to conduct a neutral probe – In the * Author 632 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports instant case, admittedly, neither of the parties in the special appeal nor in the writ petitions prayed for an inquiry by setting up the CBI into motion – The directions of High Court that are impugned in the present appeals were issued on basis of some ‘doubt’, ‘assumption’ and ‘inexplicable details’ qua master data of external agency – However, the impugned order fails to specifically point out these ‘doubts’ and ‘inexplicable details’ that led the High Court to pass such directions – In this context, this Court is of the opinion that the prima facie threshold that is required for passing a direction of CBI investigation has not been satisfied – Thus, the impugned orders dated 18.09.2023 passed in Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023 and order dated 03.10.2023 passed in Civil Miscellaneous Review Application No.117 of 2023 in Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023 by the High Court stand set-aside – This Court also set aside the direction passed in the impugned order dated 18.09.2023 to register the said case separately as suo motu PIL, leaving it to the discretion of Hon’ble the Chief Justice of the High Court to register the said petition in the form as specified in the rules of the High Court. [Paras 22, 23, 24, 25] Constitution of India – Art.226 – Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946 – CBI inquiry – Whether directions for CBI enquiry can be ordered by the High Courts or this Court in a routine manner:
Held: It is well settled that directions for CBI enquiry should not be ordered by the High Courts or this Court in a routine manner – The jurisprudence, as developed by this Court through judgements, qua the direction of an investigation by the CBI is well-settled – It imposes a significant self-restraint on the exercise of this extraordinary constitutional power u/Art.32 or Art.226 of the Constitution of India – The exercise of inherent powers to direct CBI to investigate must be exercised sparingly, cautiously, and only in exceptional situations – This Court has consistently cautioned that a CBI investigation should not be directed as a matter of routine or merely because a party casts certain aspersions or harbors a subjective lack of confidence in the State police – It goes without saying that for invoking this power, the concerned Court must be satisfied that the material placed prima facie discloses commission of offences and necessitates a CBI investigation to ensure the fundamental right to a fair and impartial investigation, or where the complexity, scale, or national ramification of such allegations demands expertise of central agency. [Para 21] [2025] 10 S.C.R. 633Legislative Council U.P. Lucknow & Ors. v. Sushil Kumar & Ors. Case Law Cited State of W.B. v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights [2010] 2 SCR 979 : (2010) 3 SCC 571 – followed.
Secretary, Minor Irrigation & Rural Engg. Services UP v. Sahgoo Ram (2002) 5 SCC 521; Shree Shree Ram Janki Ji Asthan Tapovam Mandir v. State of Jharkhand, 2019 INSC 609 : [2019] 8 SCR 137; Manik Bhattacharya v. Ramesh Malik (2022) 17 SCC 781 – relied on.
Sachin Kumar & Ors v. Delhi Subordinate Service Selection Board (DSSSB) & Ors. [2021] 2 SCR 1073 : (2021) 4 SCC 631 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946. List of Keywords Recruitment; Process of selection of various posts; Arbitrary process of selection; Unfairness in selection process; Collusiveness in the selection process; CBI inquiry; Direction to CBI to investigate; Doubt; Assumptions; Article 226 of Constitution; Exceptional situation; High-ranking State officials; Politically influential persons; Justice delivery system.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11842 of From the Judgment and Order dated 18.09.2023 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench in SAD No. 485 of 2023.
With Civil Appeal No(s). 11843, 11844-11845, and 11846 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
V. Giri, Sr. Adv., Adarsh Upadhyay, Satwik Misra, Shashank Pachauri, Nihar Dharmadhikari, Ms. Pallavi Kumari, Ms. Ruchira Goel.
634 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Advs. for the Respondents:
Ramesh Babu M. R., Mahesh Thakur, Ranvijay Singh Chandel, Vibhav Chaturvedi, Narveer Yadav, Akshay Kumar, Ms. Shruti Sharma, Sahil Bhalaik, Tushar Giri, Siddharth Anil Khanna, Ritik Arora, Shivam Mishra, Rajiv Yadav, Ratnesh Sharma, Ujjwal Kumar, Ms. Ruchira Goel, Mahesh Thakur, Ranvijay Singh Chandel, Vibhav Chaturvedi, Narveer Yadav, Akshay Kumar.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.K. Maheshwari, J.
1. In this batch of appeals, the common order dated 18.09.2023 passed in Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023 and Writ-A No. 140 of 2022 along with order dated 03.10.2023 passed in Civil Miscellaneous Review Application No. 117 of 2023 in Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023 by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench, have been assailed. For the sake of convenience, the parties in the instant appeals are outlined below as thus:
Civil Appeal(s)
Parties Impugned order C.A. No.
11842/2025 Legislative Council, U.P. and Others Vs.
Sushil Kumar & Ors.
Special Appeal Defective No. 485/2023 C.A. No.
11843/2025 Legislative Council, U.P. and Others Vs.
Sushil Kumar & Ors.
Civil Miscellaneous Review Application No. 117 of 2023 in Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023 C.A. No.
11844- 11845/2025 State of Uttar Pradesh and Another Vs. Sushil Kumar and Others Special Appeal Defective No. 485/2023
AND
Civil Miscellaneous Review Application No. 117 of 2023 in Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023 [2025] 10 S.C.R. 635Legislative Council U.P. Lucknow & Ors. v. Sushil Kumar & Ors. C.A. No.
11846/2025 State of U.P. Through Addl. Chief Secretary (Legislative Assembly)
and Others Vs. Vipin Kumar Singh and Others Writ-A No. 140/2022 Since the issues and facts involved in these appeals are common, hence they are being decided by a common order.
2. For the sake of brevity, facts of C.A. No. 11842/2025 are being adverted to. As borne from records, the controversy was set into motion when Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 (original writ petitioners) filed writ petition 1 challenging the process of selection of various posts under the Secretariat of Legislative Council, Uttar Pradesh as notified vide ‘Advertisement No. 1/2020’ dated 17.09.2020 and supplementary advertisement dated 27.09.2020, inter-alia, contending that the said process of selection was unfair, unjust, arbitrary, unreasonable and collusive. The petitioners prayed for the following reliefs: i) to issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari quashing the entire process of selection pursuant to Advertisement No. 1/2020 dated 17.9.2020 and Supplementary Advertisement dated 27.9.2020 issued by opposite party No. 1 as contained in Annexure No. 1 to the writ petition.
ii) to issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Mandamus commanding the opposite parties not to proceed with the selection pursuant to Advertisement No. 1/2020 dated 17.9.2020 and Supplementary Advertisement dated 27.9.2020 issued by opposite party no. 1 as contained in Annexure No. 1 to the writ petition.
iii) to issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Mandamus commanding the opposite parties to hold fresh process of selection in accordance with the scheme of U.P. Legislative Council Secretariat Service 1 Writ-A No. 36/2021.
636 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports (Recruitment and conditions of Services) Rules, 1976 as amended vide 4th Amendment Rules 2019.
iv) to issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Mandamus commanding the opposite parties to allow the petitioners to continue to work on their respective posts as per Scheme of Government Order dated 22.5.1998 contained in Annexure No. 3 to the writ petition and further be pleased to consider them for regular appointment.
v) Issue any other order or direction which this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper under the facts and circumstances of the case in favour of the petitioner in the interest of justice.
(vi) Allow the writ petition with costs.”
3. During the pendency of the writ petition, counter affidavit was filed and the learned Single Judge relying upon the judgment of this Court in ‘Sachin Kumar & Ors vs. Delhi Subordinate Service Selection Board (DSSSB) & Ors.’ 2, vide order dated 12.04.2023 issued the following directions – "27. In view thereof, to maintain the public confidence in the recruitment process in the Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council in respect of Class-III posts, the recruitment should be in the hands of the specialized statutory recruitment body, and not in the hands of a selection committee or a private agency. Therefore, it is directed that in future all Class-III posts in Assembly and Council are to be filled up by the selection made by the Uttar Pradesh Subordinate Services Selection Commission. In this respect, necessary amendment in the recruitment rules are to be carried out within a period of three months from today.
28. The petitioners, who have been given appointment on contractual basis should be allowed to work on contractual basis and paid remuneration accordingly,
2 (2021) 4 SCC 631
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 637Legislative Council U.P. Lucknow & Ors. v. Sushil Kumar & Ors. subject to their performing duties of the posts, if the posts are vacant on which they have been working, till regularly selected candidates come from Uttar Pradesh Subordinate Services Selection Commission and join the posts.”
4. Being aggrieved by the said directions, review petition3 was filed, which was disposed-of vide order dated 15.05.2023 maintaining the order of the learned Single Judge. Aggrieved, special appeal 4 was preferred by Respondent Nos. 1 to 3. It is relevant to note, while the aforesaid special appeal was pending, Writ-A No. 140/2022 was filed by other set of writ-petitioners, inter-alia seeking relief in nature of certiorari for quashing entire selection and appointment made on the post of Assistant Review Officer in Uttar Pradesh Legislative Assembly Secretariat in pursuance to Advertisement No. 1/2020 and also a high-level enquiry into alleged manipulation and favoritism in selection and appointment. Vide order dated 21.08.2023 passed in special appeal, the matter was directed to be taken up with Writ-A No. 140/2022. The relevant portion of the order dated 21.08.2023 is reproduced below as thus:
“ xxx xxx xxx Put up on 24.08.2023 along with Writ-A No. 140/2022, Vipin Kumar v. State of U.P. through Additional Chief Secretary (Legislative Assembly) and others.
The relevant records shall be produced by Sri Gaurav Mehrotra, learned Counsel for Legislative Council on the next date of listing.
xxx xxx xxx ”
5. In furtherance thereto, the High Court by the common impugned order, referred the matter to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) for conducting a preliminary enquiry and to submit a report to the Court within the time so specified and directed the office to register the case as suo-motu P.I.L. The relevant portion of the order is reproduced as thus: - 3 Civil Misc. Review Application No. 53 of 2023.
4 Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023 638 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “(10) Since this Court is vested with the jurisdiction of P.I.L., therefore the Court further proceeds to take suo motu notice in public interest on the aforesaid questions for necessary directions and the case be listed as suo motu P.I.L. in the matter of recruitment of Staff in Vidhan Parishad and Vidhan Sabha, Secretariat, U.P. in the light of grievance raised in the Special Appeal and Writ-A No. 140 of 2022, Vipin Kumar v. State of U.P. through Additional Chief Secretary (Legislative Assembly) and others connected thereto.
ORDER
(11) Having regard to the facts evident from the record and keeping in view the aforesaid questions of public importance, we are of the opinion that the matter be referred to Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)
for conducting a preliminary enquiry to submit the report to this Court within a period of six weeks from the date of this order along with photocopies of the relevant record.
(12) Office is directed to register the case separately as suo motu P.I.L. whose title is as under:
“Suo Motu in the matter of Recruitment of staff in Vidhan Parishad Sabha and Vidhan Sabha, Secretariat, U.P.”
(13) Let a copy of this order alongwith the instructions placed before this Court be registered as part of P.I.L.
(14) The original record supplied to the Court shall be kept in the sealed cover.
(15) Photocopy of the original record shall be transmitted to the C.B.I. by the Senior Registrar of this Court in a sealed cover to facilitate the preliminary enquiry in the matter.
(16) Dr. L.P. Mishra, Advocate is appointed as amicus curiae to assist the Court in the matter of suo motu P.I.L.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 639Legislative Council U.P. Lucknow & Ors. v. Sushil Kumar & Ors.
(17) Let the Special Appeal and P.I.L. be listed before the appropriate Bench in the first week of November, 2023.”
6. On filing review5 against the above directions, the same was dismissed on 03.10.2023 maintaining the order impugned. Hence, the present appeals as indicated above in para 1.
7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties at length. Mr. V. Giri, learned senior counsel representing the State and Mr. Sharan Thakur, learned senior counsel for the Legislative Council, submits that by the impugned judgment, the Division Bench by clubbing the Special Appeal with the Writ Petition wherein constitutionality of the Uttar Pradesh Legislative Assembly Recruitment Rules was challenged and by converting the said Special Appeal into a Public Interest Litigation, the Division Bench exceeded from its jurisdiction to decide the Special Appeal. It is further urged that without affording the appellant an opportunity referring the matter to CBI for enquiry, violates principles of natural justice. He further submitted that there are no averments in the writ petition or in the special appeal warranting referral of matter to the CBI insofar as the allegations specified therein are concerned. Therefore, direction as issued by the High Court is not in accordance with law. Reliance in this regard has been placed on the judgments of this Court in the cases of Secretary, Minor Irrigation & Rural Engg. Services UP vs. Sahgoo Ram 6; Shree Shree Ram Janki, Asthan Tapovam Mandir vs. State of Jharkhand7.
8. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 (petitioners before the High Court) submits that they have not asked for any relief directing CBI enquiry in the matter. Without there being such prayers, the High Court suo-motu has passed the order. It is urged, they are working since last about ten years on contractual basis and their prayer is only to the extent to regularize them in the Uttar Pradesh Legislative Assembly. It is also contended that they have not made any allegation of manipulation or malpractice in the examination and neither pleaded for CBI investigation. In such circumstances, appropriate orders may be passed.
5 Civil Miscellaneous Review Application No. 117 of 2023 in Special Appeal Defective No. 485 of 2023.
6 (2002) 5 SCC 521
7 (2019) 6 SCC 25
640 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
9. Having considered the submissions and the controversy involved, it is first necessary to examine the circumstances in which a CBI inquiry can be directed. This Court has addressed this issue in a series of judgments, as outlined below from some of the cases.
10. In Secretary, Minor Irrigation & Rural Engg. Services UP (supra), this Court had the occasion to deal with a direction of High Court whereby CBI was directed to hold an inquiry into the allegations made against the then Minister for Minor Irrigation and Rural Engineering Services in government of Uttar Pradesh. While setting aside the impugned order therein, following was observed– “5. While none can dispute the power of the High Court under Article 226 to direct an inquiry by CBI, the said power can be exercised only in cases where there is sufficient material to come to a prima facie conclusion that there is a need for such inquiry. It is not sufficient to have such material in the pleadings. On the contrary, there is a need for the High Court on consideration of such pleadings to come to the conclusion that the material before it is sufficient to direct such an inquiry by CBI. This is a requirement which is clearly deducible from the judgment of this Court in the case of Common Cause [(1999) 6 SCC 667]. This Court in the said judgment at paragraph 174 of the Report has held thus: (SCC p. 750, para 174)
“174. The other direction, namely, the direction to CBI to investigate ‘any other offence’ is wholly erroneous and cannot be sustained. Obviously, direction for investigation can be given only if an offence is, prima facie, found to have been committed or a person’s involvement is prima facie established, but a direction to CBI to investigate whether any person has committed an offence or not cannot be legally given. Such a direction would be contrary to the concept and philosophy of ‘life’ and ‘liberty’ guaranteed to a person under Article 21 of the Constitution.
This direction is in complete negation of various decisions of this Court in which the concept of ‘life’ has been explained in a manner which has infused ‘life’ into the letters of Article 21.”
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 641Legislative Council U.P. Lucknow & Ors. v. Sushil Kumar & Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.