Rajul Manoj Shah Alias Rajeshwari Rasiklal Sheth v. Kiranbhai Shakrabhai Patel & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1109; [2025] 10 S.C.R. 152
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Joymalya Bagchi
- Decided
- 12 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11781/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 152 : 2025 INSC 1109 Rajul Manoj Shah Alias Rajeshwari Rasiklal Sheth v.
Kiranbhai Shakrabhai Patel & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 11781 of 2025)
12 September 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha* and Joymalya Bagchi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court was correct in reversing the order passed by the Civil Court dismissing the interlocutory application filed by respondent no.1 for amending the written statement and for filing a counter claim in a suit for declaration and injunction filed by the appellant; and legality of institution of a counter claim against a co-defendant.
Headnotes Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Order VIII, Rule 6A – Counterclaim by defendant – Suit for declaration filed by the appellant against her sister-in-law-defendant no.1 seeking declaration that she has no right to transfer or deal with the suit property without her consent and to declare that the agreement to sell in favour of respondent No.1, as null and void – Death of defendant no.1 – Thereafter, Nazir of the Civil Courtrespondent No.2 was substituted and appointed as defendant no.1 – On 26.07.2021, respondent no.1 filed application seeking amendment of the written statement to file counter claim thereby praying for direction to respondent No.2 to accept remaining consideration and execute sale deed in respect of the said agreement to sell executed by defendant no.1 and to partition the suit property – Trial court dismissed the application by holding that a counter claim not maintainable against the co-defendant – However, the High Court allowed the application of the respondent no.1 and permitted him to file counter claim – Correctness:
Held: High Court erred in reversing the judgment of the trial court by permitting defendant no.2 to file a counter-claim against defendant * Author [2025] 10 S.C.R. 153Rajul Manoj Shah Alias Rajeshwari Rasiklal Sheth v. Kiranbhai Shakrabhai Patel & Anr.
no.1 and not against the appellant – Relief of specific performance as sought to be raised by defendant no.2 cannot be set up by way of a counter-claim since the same is not directed against the appellant, but is instead directed solely against the co-defendant – Defendant no.2 disentitled to raise prayer of specific performance by way of counter-claim – Further, defendant no.2 however submits that he has not only claimed the relief of specific performance, but has also sought partition of suit property to separate the share he is entitled to under the agreement – Defendant no.2 must first establish a right of claim over the property, which is absent till he succeeds against the estate of defendant no.1 and only thereafter that the question of setting up a counter claim against appellant may arise – Issues were framed on 12.02.2019 and the application for counter claim was filed almost two years thereafter, in 2021 – Defendant no.2 is seeking specific performance of an agreement dated 21.10.2011, which provided execution of the sale deed within twelve months – Defendant no.2 did not take any action – In any event, the next course of action to seek execution of the sale deed arose immediately after January 2012 when the appellant instituted a suit seeking annulment of so-called agreement to sell – Defendant no.2 did nothing – Only after the death of his vendor in October 2013 and after framing of the issues in February 2019 that the defendant no.2 decided to file the application, only after nine years of the filing of the suit, which was two years after framing of the issues. [Paras 22, 23, 25, 27] Case Law Cited Rohit Singh & Ors. v. State of Bihar [2006] Supp. 7 SCR 278 : (2006) 12 SCC 734; Ashok Kumar Kalra v. Wing CDR. Surendra Agnihotri [2019] 17 SCR 214 : (2020) 2 SCC 394 – relied on. Munishamappa v. M. Rama Reddy, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1701; Damodhar Narayan Sawale v. Tejrao Bajirao Mhaske [2023] 6 SCR 175 : (2023) 19 SCC 175; Satyender v. Saroj [2022] 13 SCR 342 : (2022) 17 SCC 154; Jag Mohan Chawla v. Dera Radha Swami Satsang [1996] Supp. 2 SCR 509 : (1996) 4 SCC 699; Kishore Kumar Khaitan & Anr. v. Praveen Kumar Singh [2006] 2 SCR 176 : AIR 2006 SC 1474 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
154 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Counter claim; Execution of the sale deed; Suit for declaration; Agreement to sell; Amend written statement; Specific performance; Right of claim.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11781 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 16.01.2023 of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in SCA No. 12701 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ritin Rai, Sr. Adv., Shamik Shirishbhai Sanjanwala, Kunal Vyas, Aditya Tripathi.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Pradhuman Gohil, Mrs. Taruna Singh Gohil, Alapati Sahithya Krishna, Rushabh N. Kapadia, Ms. Hetvi Ketan Patel, Ms. Taniya Bansal, Malak Manish Bhatt.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. Present appeal is against the judgment and order of the High Court of Gujarat1 against the order passed by the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad dismissing the interlocutory application 2 filed by respondent no.1/ defendant no.2 for amending the written statement and for filing a counter claim in a suit for declaration and injunction filed by the appellant.
3. Facts: Short facts leading to the filing of the appeal are that the appellant, in 2012, instituted an original suit alleging that the property 1 In Special Civil Application No. 12701 of 2021 dated 16.01.2023. 2 Exhibit-107/108 dated 05.08.2021 in O.S. No.167 of 2012. [2025] 10 S.C.R. 155Rajul Manoj Shah Alias Rajeshwari Rasiklal Sheth v. Kiranbhai Shakrabhai Patel & Anr.
in question, a bungalow in a cooperative housing society situated near Stadium Char Rasta in Ahmedabad, belongs to her father and upon his demise, the said property came to be owned by her and by her brother jointly. However, upon the demise of her brother, the property was jointly owned by the appellant and her sister-in-law/ defendant no. 1. In January, 2012, when the appellant came to know that her sister-in-law has agreed to sell a portion of the undivided share of the joint family property in favour of respondent no.1 / defendant No.2, the appellant filed the suit for a declaration that her sister-in-law, defendant no.1 has no right to transfer or deal with the property without her consent and to declare the agreement to sell dated 21.10.2011 in favour of defendant no.2, as null and void.
4. On 12.10.2013, the original defendant no. 1 passed away pending disposal of the suit. Thereafter, on 23.07.2017, the appellant filed an application before the Trial Court declaring the factum of defendant no.1’s death and praying for her deletion from array of parties. Trial Court vide order dated 24.10.2019 allowed appellant’s application for deletion of defendant no.1. Meanwhile, on 10.10.2019, defendant no. 2 moved an application before the Trial Court praying for substitution of the original defendant no. 1 with a court appointed officer under Order XXII Rule 4A of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 3 which came to be dismissed vide order dated 15.11.2019.
5. Aggrieved against the orders dated 24.10.2019 and 15.11.2019, defendant no. 2 moved a Special Civil Application before the High Court. On 10.02.2020, the High Court passed an order based on consent of both the parties, thereby quashing orders dated 24.10.2019 and 15.11.2019. Consequently, High Court substituted and appointed the court official – Nazir of the City Civil Court – respondent no. 2 as defendant no.1. Thereafter, the appellant also filed an amended plaint on 04.03.2020.
6. Proceedings leading to the filing of the present appeal commenced when defendant no. 2, on 26.07.2021 moved an application seeking to amend the written statement by adding a counter-claim, praying for, a) to direct the Nazir/respondent no.2 to accept remaining consideration and execute a sale deed for the undivided share in furtherance of the agreement to sell dated 21.10.2011, and b) to partition the suit property as per Partition Act, 1893. 3 Hereinafter, CPC.
156 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. The Trial Court by its order dated 05.08.2021 dismissed the application by holding that defendant no. 2 has filed the application after a long time and that, it is abuse of the process to file such application after issues were framed, way back on 12.02.2019. Trial Court also observed that the defendant cannot seek specific performance of the agreement of sale dated 21.10.2011 against deceased defendant no. 1, as represented by a court officer, that too in a suit filed by the plaintiff. Following the decisions of this Court, the Trial Court held that a counter claim is not maintainable against the co-defendant. Respondent No. 1, defendant no. 2 challenged this order in Special Civil Application under Articles 226/227 and the High Court, by the order impugned before us allowed the petition.
8. The High Court allowed the application of defendant no. 2 and permitted him to file his counter-claim. The relevant portion of the order impugned is as follows;
“13.13. In view of this Court, considering the aforesaid facts, the prayers as prayed for by the petitioner herein are required to be granted and the prayers as prayed for in application below Exh. 107 /108 could have been prayed for by the petitioner herein, only after the Nazir of the City Civil Court as administrator of the property in question would have been appointed. The Nazir came to be appointed only by order dated 10.02.2020 by this Court in Special Civil Application No. 21979 of 2019 and soon thereafter, the applications below Exh.107/108 came to be filed by the petitioner herein. The cause of action can be said to have arisen after the Issues came to be framed, and therefore, in the facts of the present case, the petitioner could not have been non-suited on the ground of delay.
13. 14. The trial Court has also come to the conclusion that the petitioner herein has chosen to file counterclaim against the co-defendant and the same is held to be not maintainable. It appears that the reliefs have not been sought for by the petitioner herein against the codefendant, the same have been sought for against the Nazir - court official of the City Civil Court, as also against the respondent no.2 - original plaintiff. The counter-claim is maintainable, in view of the fact that the same is filed after the administrator- Nazir came to be appointed by [2025] 10 S.C.R. 157Rajul Manoj Shah Alias Rajeshwari Rasiklal Sheth v. Kiranbhai Shakrabhai Patel & Anr.
this Court vide order dated 10.02.2020, for the prayers as referred above.
14. This Court by exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, is inclined to allow the said applications below Exh. 107 /108 preferred by the petitioner herein by quashing and setting aside the order dated 05.08.2021 passed below Exh.107/108 in Civil Suit No. 167 of 2012 by the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad.
15. In view of this Court, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the present petition are required to be allowed and the same is allowed, accordingly, keeping it open for the respondent herein to lead the evidence on the ground of limitation and the same be decided by the Court below in accordance with law. It is also kept open for the respective parties to take all the contentions before the Court below, when the matter is taken-up for hearing and other issues that may be germane for adjudication of the dispute in question including the issue of limitation. The present petition stands allowed, accordingly.”
(emphasis supplied)
9. Aggrieved, the appellant approached this Court by filing the present civil appeal. We have heard Mr. Ritin Rai, learned senior counsel assisted by others, on behalf of the appellant. We have also heard Mr. Pradhuman Gohil, learned counsel and others on behalf of the respondent.
10. The two submissions made by Mr. Ritin Rai, learned senior counsel are simple and straightforward. The first submission is that a counter claim cannot be entertained after the issues are formulated in the suit. For this purpose, he relied on the decision of this Court in Ashok Kumar Kalra v. Wing CDR. Surendra Agnihotri4 . The second submission, as accepted by the Trial Court as well, is that a counter claim cannot be made against a co-defendant and for this purpose the decision of this Court in Rohit Singh & Ors. v. State of Bihar 5 is relied on.
4 (2020) 2 SCC 394.
5 (2006) 12 SCC 734. Hereinafter, “Rohit Singh”.
158 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
11. Mr. Pradhuman Gohil, learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent no. 1/defendant no. 2, articulated his arguments very well and interpreted Order VIII Rule 6A of CPC innovatively and also relied on certain portions of the 27th Law Commission Report.
12. Analysis: Before we take up the issue relating to legality and propriety of entertaining an application for counter claim 9 years after filing of the suit, particularly when issues were framed 3 years before the said application and also the issue relating to the legality of institution of a counter claim against a co-defendant, we will touch upon the jurisdiction that the High Court was exercising.
13. The appellant did in fact raise the plea of the High Court entertaining a petition under Article 227 against the order passed by the Trial Court but the same was rejected by supplying the following reasoning after extracting the portion of the decision of this Court in Kishore Kumar Khaitan & Anr. v. Praveen Kumar Singh 6 by observing that; “13. 10. Considering the aforesaid ratio as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, as referred above, while this Court is conscious of the restriction while exercising the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, looking to the facts of the present case, interference is called for, in view of the fact that cause of action for seeking amendment and counter-claim could be said to have arisen, after the issues came to be framed by the trial Court on 12.02.2019. Undisputedly, the aforesaid prayers as prayed for by the petitioner herein, invoking Order-8 Rule-6(A) 1 and Order-6 Rule-17 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 seeking amendment in plaint and for counter-claim by the present petitioner, would normally be not granted, after the commencement of trial and considering the fact that, it would result in prolonging the suit proceedings, however, the same depends upon facts and circumstances of the case. The provisions of Order-6 Rule-17 and Order-8 Rule-6(A)1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, also provide that same be allowed, if the same are germane for determining the real controversy between the parties. In facts of the present case, it cannot
6 AIR 2006 SC 1474
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 159Rajul Manoj Shah Alias Rajeshwari Rasiklal Sheth v. Kiranbhai Shakrabhai Patel & Anr.
be said that the petitioner· herein has placed on record the facts, which are new to the suit proceedings, and therefore, prayers as prayed for by the petitioner herein are required to be considered and required to be granted.”
(emphasis supplied)
14. The above-referred para does not indicate how the jurisdictional error has arisen for consideration. In any event of the matter, the relevant portion of facts, as found by the trial court while rejecting the application for counter claim, which we are of the opinion are correct in law as well as on fact, are extracted as hereinbelow for ready reference;
“8. ……… Upon considering the aforesaid provision of C.P.C.
Order-8, Rules-6, when cause arises for counter claim for the defendant, then counter-claim can be lodged by the defendant against the plaintiff. In the present case, as per the details of the counter-claim submitted by the defendant no.2, he has demanded counter-claim against defendant no. 1 and he has not prayed for any relief against the plaintiff. If the suit is filed by the plaintiff, the defendant cannot file counter-claim against the defendant in the said suit.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.