Rajkaran Singh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 621; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 516
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hima Kohli, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 22 Aug 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9721/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 516 : 2024 INSC 621 Rajkaran Singh & Ors.
v.
Union of India & Ors.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 9721 of 2024)
22 August 2024 [Hima Kohli and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the appellants despite being classified as temporary employees of a scheme managed by contributory pooling of funds, can claim entitlement to pensionary benefits in accordance with the 6th Central Pay Commission (CPC).
Headnotes† Service Law – Revised Pay Scale Rules, 2008 – Constitution of India – Article 12, 14, 16 – “authority” under Article 12 – Claim for pensionary benefits under the 6th CPC, by the appellants- Saving Scheme Deposits (SSD) employees appointed as Junior Accountant, Accountant, UDC, LDC on running pay scales to manage the Compulsory SSD Fund of the Special Frontier Force (SFF) – Denied – Duties of the appellants, if were similar to those of regular employees in the Accounts Section of SFF HQ Estt.No.22 and thus, were they entitled to the pensionary benefits under the 6 th CPC and denial thereof was unjustified:
Held: Yes – Appellants’ employment bears substantial hallmarks of regular government service, despite their formal classification as temporary employees – Appellants were admittedly appointed on a regular pay scale indicating a formalised employeeemployer relationship akin to permanent government employee – Appellants’ career paths were managed like permanent employees indicating a level of governmental oversight and control consistent with regular government service – Provisions of leave and other benefits, including grant of Assured Career Progression reinforces the similarity between the appellants’ employment conditions and those of regular government employees – Their charter of duties involving the maintenance * Author [2024] 8 S.C.R. 517Rajkaran Singh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. of accounts for the SSD Fund is an assignment of public importance closely related to governmental functions – Applying the principles laid down in Ajay Hasia case which established various tests to determine whether an entity can be considered an instrumentality or agency of the Government and thus an “authority” under Article 12 of the Constitution of India to the present case, the appellants meet the characteristics of regular government servants – Appellants served SFF HQ Estt. No. 22 for over three decades – While the duration of service alone may not be determinative, it is a significant factor when considered in conjunction with the other aspects of their employment – Such long-term service suggests a level of permanence and integration into the governmental structure that belies their classification as temporary employees – Appellants performed duties similar to those of regular employees in the Accounts Section of SFF HQ Estt. No.22 and served the government for decades in a manner indistinguishable from regular employees – Administrative orders and Board proceedings also consistently treated the appellants as equivalent to regular government employees – Denial of pensionary benefits solely on the basis of their temporary status not justifiable and is arbitrary and violates the fundamental rights guaranteed by Articles 14 and 16 – Impugned judgment of the High Court unsustainable, set aside – Appellants entitled to the benefits of the 6th CPC including the pensionary benefits under the Revised Pay Scale Rules, 2008 in the same terms as afforded to their peers in the Accounts Section of SFF HQ Estt. No. 22. [Paras 27-29, 32-36] Constitution of India – Article 12 – “authority” under – An entity, when is an instrumentality/agency of the Government – Tests laid down in Ajay Hasia and Others v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi and Others – Assessment of nature of employee-employer relationships – Discussed.
Case Law Cited Ajay Hasia and Others v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi and Others [1981] 2 SCR 79 : (1981) 1 SCC 722; Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology and Others [2002] 3 SCR 100 : (2002) 5 SCC 111; Vinod Kumar and Others v. Union of India [2024] 1 SCR 1230 : (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1533 – relied on.
518 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports State of Karnataka & Ors. v. M.L. Kesari & Ors. [2010] 9 SCR 543 : (2010) 9 SCC 247; Surinder Singh and Another v. Engineer-in-Chief, C.P.W.D. and Another (1986) 1 SCC 639; State of Punjab & Ors. v. Jagjit Singh & Ors. [2016] 7 SCR 350 : (2017) 1 SCC 148; Union of India v. Dineshan K.K. [2008] 1 SCR 100 : (2008) 1 SCC 586; Randhir Singh v. Union of India & Ors. [1982] 3 SCR 298 : (1982) 1 SCC 618 – referred to.
List of Acts Revised Pay Scale Rules, 2008; Constitution of India; Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972.
List of Keywords Special Frontier Force (SFF); Compulsory Saving Scheme Deposits (SSD) Fund; Maintenance of accounts for SSD Fund; Temporary employees; Temporary status; Classified as temporary employees; Formal classification as temporary employees; Regular employees; Duties similar to regular employees; Instrumentality or agency of the Government, “Authority” under Article 12 of the Constitution of India; Employee-employer relationships; Pensionary benefits; Pensionary benefits denied; Regular government servants; Regular government employees; 4 th , 5 th , 6 th Central Pay Commissions; Revised Pay Scale Rules.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9721 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 25.04.2017 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in WP No. 3543 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Ms. Neha Rathi, Kamal Kishore, Ms. Kajal Giri, Sanyam Jain, Kislay Panday, Hariom Yaduvanshi, Ms. S. Harini, Avi Dhankar, Ms. Gyanvi Roy, Arjun Yaduvanshi, Dr. Monika Gusain, Advs. for the Appellants.
K M Nataraj, A.S.G., Vatsal Joshi, B K Satija, Sharath Nambiar, Divyanshu Kumar Srivastava, Siddharth Venkatesh Thakur, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Respondents.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 519Rajkaran Singh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. The present appeal by special leave, is preferred on behalf of the appellants, assailing the judgment dated 25 th April, 2017 passed by the High Court of Delhi in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 3543 of 2017, dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellants and upholding the judgment dated 4th October, 2016 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter being referred to as the ‘Tribunal’) in Original Application Nos. 60 of 2013 and 459 of 2013. The Tribunal had rejected the appellants’ claim for benefits of the replacement scales of the Revised Pay Rules, 2008 (hereinafter referred to as ‘RP Rules’) in accordance with the 6 th Pay Commission Report, with effect from 1 st January, 2006.
Brief facts: -
4. The facts in a nutshell, are that the appellants (Appellant No. 1 to Appellant No. 6) were appointed to manage the Compulsory Saving Scheme Deposits (hereinafter referred to as SSD) Fund of the Special Frontier Force (hereinafter referred to as SFF) in various positions such as Junior Accountant, Accountant, Upper Division Clerk (UDC), and Lower Division Clerk (LDC), on running pay scales. The SSD Fund is a welfare initiative funded through the personal contributions of the SFF troops from their salaries. Upon having been engaged as above, the appellants also received Traveling Allowance (TA), Dearness Allowance (DA), House Rent Allowance (HRA), Special Security Allowance (SSA), Gratuity, Bonus, Winter Allowance, and High-Altitude Allowance, etc. along with salary as per the 4th and 5th Central Pay Commissions (‘CPC’).
5. On 1 st January, 2006, the Union of India implemented the 6 th Central Pay Commission and made the same applicable to all government employees of the SFF. However, these benefits were not extended to the appellants i.e. SSD employees and instead, an ad-hoc amount of Rs. 3,000/- per month was given to each of them. For 520 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the sake of brevity, the details of the appellants with reference to their appointments, retirement, length of service, and their salaries in accordance with the different CPC are illustrated in a tabular form below: - Name of the Appellant Appointment Date Post Date of Retirement Service rendered Salary paid initially Salary paid after Rajkaran Singh (‘A1’)
1st January, Lower Division Clerk 31st August 37 years and 8 months Rs.
220- As per the 5th CPC & Rs.
3,000/- instead of 6th CPC Jagat Ram Joshi (‘A2’)
25th April, 1975 Lower Division Clerk 28th February 37 years and 10 months Rs.
220- As per the 5th CPC & Rs.
3,000/- instead of 6th CPC Vishu Dutt Tripathi (‘A3’)
2nd May, 1978 Lower Division Clerk 31st July 35 years and 3 months Rs.
260- As per the 5th CPC & Rs.
3,000/- instead of 6th CPC HK Naithani (‘A4’)
27th November,1982 Lower Division Clerk 31st August 35 years and 9 months Rs.
260- As per the 5th CPC & Rs.
3,000/- instead of 6th CPC Shiv Kumar (‘A5’)
25th May, 2005 Junior Accountant 18th February
(VRS)
8 years and 9 months Rs.
5000- As per the 5th CPC & Rs.
3,000/- instead of 6th CPC Surat Singh (‘A6’)
16th July, 1977 Lower Division Clerk 1st January
(VRS)
31 years and 5 months Rs.
260- As per the 5th CPC & Rs.
3,000/- instead of 6th CPC
6. Upon attaining the age of superannuation i.e., 60 years, the appellants claimed pensionary benefits under the 6 th Central Pay Commission (‘CPC’). On 28 th July, 2011, appellant No. 1 (Rajkaran Singh) filed a representation to the respondent No. 1 seeking pensionary benefits under the 6th CPC, however, the same was rejected vide order dated 15 th October, 2012, on the ground that he was not a government employee and had not been appointed by following any Recruitment Rules, and therefore, the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972(hereinafter being referred to as ‘CCS Rules’), would not apply to him. The other appellants (appellant No. 2-appellant No. 6) also filed similar representations to the respondents which met a similar fate on the same reasoning.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 521Rajkaran Singh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
7. Aggrieved by the rejection of their claim for pensionary benefits under the 6th CPC, the appellants filed Original Applications before the Tribunal, laying a challenge to the non-implementation of the benefits of the 6th CPC and also raising a grievance about the lack of General Provident Fund (GPF) provisions in the SSD Fund, despite they having been appointed to posts created under the authorisation of the Cabinet Secretariat and after following the due process of law in making the appointments.
8. The Tribunal, vide order dated 4th October, 2016 dismissed the Original Applications and rejected the appellants’ claims holding that they were not employed in government service. The Tribunal referred to Rule 2 of the CCS Rules, and held that the appellants were not entitled to the benefits under the CCS Rules as their salaries were neither paid from the Consolidated Fund of India, the Contingent Fund or the Public Accounts Funds, nor were their services governed by statutory obligations i.e. no recruitment rules were applicable to them. The Tribunal further held that the appellants were not recruited under an advertisement issued where people at large were given the opportunity of appearing; there was no question of any obligation cast under the Factories Act for running the SSD Fund, as it was not covered under the definition of a factory; and the services performed were not statutory in nature because the SSD Fund is a voluntary contribution made by the SFF employees. The Tribunal found that the SSD Fund was financed by voluntary contributions from SFF employees and hence the services rendered therein did not qualify as government service.
9. The appellants challenged the Tribunal’s order by filing a writ petition before the Delhi High Court which came to be rejected and the Tribunal’s order was affirmed, taking note of the fact that the appellants were appointed for the purpose of maintaining the SSD Fund, a welfare scheme run through personal contributions made by the troops of SFF. The High Court held that while the troops of SFF, undoubtedly, are government servants, however, that by itself would not clothe the appellants with the status of government servants. The impugned order dated 25 th April, 2017 passed by the High Court is subjected to challenge in this appeal by special leave. Submissions on behalf of the appellants: -
10. Ms. Neha Rathi, learned counsel representing the appellants, vehemently and fervently contended that the appellants had served 522 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the department for more than three decades to maintain the accounts of the SSD Fund and therefore, not granting them pensionary and other service benefits in accordance with the 6th CPC on a surmise, that their employment was temporary/non-governmental in nature, tantamounts to grossly arbitrary action, violative of the fundamental rights of the appellants as guaranteed under the Constitution of India.
11. Learned Counsel submitted that the appellants satisfy all the characteristics of regular government servants, considering the fact that they were appointed in a regular pay scale and received increments and promotions at par with those being admitted to other government employees, along with leave and other benefits and emoluments. Additionally, they were granted the benefits of Assured Career Progression (ACP).
12. Learned counsel further contended that the nature of the work assigned to the appellants was similar to the work of the regular employees of the Accounts Section of SFF HQ Estt. No.22. Moreover, permanent employees of the SFF Accounts are also working with the SSD Staff for maintaining the SSD Fund, performing the same duties. Learned counsel submitted that following the transfer of the SSD Funds Accounts to HQ SFF w.e.f. 1st April 2003, the SSD Funds are being managed by the Deputy Director (AG) at HQ SFF, under the overall control of the Inspector General of SFF. Consequently, the appellants’ services have been brought within the jurisdiction of HQ SFF and fall under the aegis of the Inspector General of SFF. It was further contended that for all other purposes, the appellants have been treated at par with regular employees of the Accounts Section, which places them at same level with government employees. Therefore, the appellants are entitled to receive the same benefits as the regular employees of the Accounts Section and also to receive the pensionary as well as consequential benefits flowing from the 6th CPC.
13. Learned counsel also submitted that the denial of pensionary benefits to the SSD Fund staff, while granting the same to the SFF personnel and other SFF Accounts staff, constitutes an arbitrary and discriminatory decision, violating Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The pensionary benefits were extended to SFF personnel from 1 st January, 2009 and to other SFF Accounts staff employed through the same procedure at SSF HQ Estt. No. 22, under the Commandant’s authority, from the onset of their employment (initially temporary [2024] 8 S.C.R. 523Rajkaran Singh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. for six months). Despite being part of the same establishment and governed by the same Commandant, the appellants working at the SSD Fund were unjustly excluded from these benefits. This differential treatment lacks a reasonable basis and is discriminatory. Learned counsel highlighted the comparative statement of benefits and allowances granted to SSD Fund and SFF permanent employees as per the following table:
Particulars SSD Staff SFF Permanent employees Basic Pay Yes Yes Dearness allowance Yes Yes TA/DA (on deputation) Yes Yes House Rent Allowance Yes Yes Transport Allowance Yes Yes Children Education Allowance No Yes High Altitude Allowance Yes Yes Winter Allowance Yes Yes Ration Allowance Yes Yes Special Security Allowance Yes Yes Gratuity Yes Yes Leave Encashment (Not paid at the time of retirement after 6th
CPC)
No Yes Yearly Bonus Yes Yes Yearly increments Yes Yes LTC Yes Yes ACR (till 6th CPC) Yes Yes Maintenance of Service Book (till 6th
CPC)
Yes Yes ACP for higher pay scale Yes Yes Promotions Yes Yes Member of SSD Provident Fund Yes Yes Member of Group Insurance Policy Yes Yes CGHS facility (at New Delhi) No Yes Medical facility at Military Hospital Yes Yes 524 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
14. Learned counsel further contended that the responsibility to devise a suitable scheme for the regularisation of employees who have served for more than ten years lies with the respondents i.e., the State. She submitted that the respondent had rejected the appellants’ representation on a purely arbitrary ground that they were not appointed through a rigorous selection process and that the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 did not apply to them. She urged that the appointment of the appellants was conducted under due process of selection, following the rules of the Cabinet Secretariat, and cannot be deemed irregular or illegal simply for the lack of statutory recruitment and service rules. Learned counsel in this regard placed reliance upon the decision of this Court in the case of the State of Karnataka & Ors. v. M.L. Kesari & Ors.1
15. Learned counsel further submitted that the case of the appellants is squarely covered by the principle of “equal pay for equal work” and that the right of equal wages conferred upon temporary employees flows, inter alia, from Article 39 of the Constitution of India. This principle of “equal pay for equal work” expounded through various decisions of this Court constitutes the law, which is binding upon all the Courts in India and consequently upon the respondents. It also extends to temporary employees performing the same duties and responsibilities as regular employees. Learned counsel in this regard placed reliance upon the decisions of this Court in the cases of Surinder Singh and Another v. Engineer-in-Chief, C.P.W.D. and Another, 2 State of Punjab & Ors. v. Jagjit Singh & Ors.,3 Union of India v. Dineshan K.K.,4 and Randhir Singh v. Union of India & Ors.5 On these grounds, learned counsel for the appellants implored the Court to accept the appeal, set aside the impugned judgments and direct the respondents to release in favour of the appellants, the benefits of the replacement scales set out in the RP Rules issued in pursuance of the 6th CPC report with effect from 1st January, 2006. 1 [2010] 9 SCR 543 : (2010) 9 SCC 247
2 (1986) 1 SCC 639
3 [2016] 7 SCR 350 : (2017) 1 SCC 148 4 [2008] 1 SCR 100 : (2008) 1 SCC 586 5 [1982] 3 SCR 298 : (1982) 1 SCC 618 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 525Rajkaran Singh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. Submissions on behalf of the Respondents: -
16. Mr. K.M. Nataraj, learned ASG, representing the respondents, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant. He submitted that the SSD Fund is a welfare scheme, introduced with effect from 1 st October 1964, for force personnel on the analogy of the Armed Force Personnel Provident Fund to cater to their welfare measures. It is a contributory fund subscribed by force personnel for their better future and no government funds are involved in the SSD Fund, thereby, establishing a clear alienation from the Central government. The government has no control what to talk of deep and pervasive control over the affairs of the fund.
17. Learned ASG further submitted that the appellants were hired on a temporary basis to manage the SSD Fund, which is generated from the difference between the interest earned on the invested amount and the annual interest paid to subscribers. The recruitment, selection, and promotion process for SSD Fund employees (i.e. appellants) did not adhere to the procedures applicable to regular Central government employees. Since the appellants were hired temporarily, they were not subjected to probation or given confirmation letters as permanent employees and unlike Central government employees, there was no provision for the annual evaluation of their performance. The terms of engagement of these employees explicitly outlined their temporary status and the associated conditions, including the potential for termination without prior notice. This aligns with the fundamental nature of their employment, which does not confer upon them, the status or entitlements typically associated with regular government employees.
18. Learned ASG also submitted that the appellants’ salaries, which were finally increased by Rs. 3,000/- per month in September 2009, are paid from the SSD Fund, which is contributed by SFF personnel and involves no government money. Furthermore, following the 4 th and 5 th CPC, the Government examined and extended limited benefits thereof to the SSD Fund employees (i.e., appellants), but with specific reference to maintain the fund’s objectives. These conditions include not comparing their pay scales to those recommended by the 4 th CPC in future references and considering pay increments or Dearness Allowance instalments on an ad hoc basis, when 526 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports necessary. He urged that the Commandant, SFF HQ Estt. No. 22, holds discretionary authority over the SSD Fund in accordance with the Cabinet Secretariat Order No. EA/EF-EST-13/75 dated 11th October, 1976. This order underscores the fact that the fixation of pay for these employees is not mandated to adhere to scales applicable to Central government employees.
19. Learned ASG further submitted that the claim of benefits accorded under the 6 th CPC and RP Rules relied upon by the appellants is totally unfounded. These benefits are expressly designed for and applicable exclusively to Central government employees and do not extend to individuals engaged in roles akin to those overseeing contributory schemes like the SSD Fund. While certain benefits were extended to the fund employees post the 5th CPC, the feasibility of aligning their compensation with the 6 th CPC was constrained by the financial limitations of the SSD Fund. Any enhancements in pay, allowances, or promotions were dispensed judiciously as welfare measures, guided by the operational imperatives and financial health of the SSD Fund.
20. Learned counsel further submitted that the appellants’ entitlements, including any financial assistance and promotions, were provided in consideration of their service and the prevailing socio-economic conditions, and do not establish a precedent for future claims. The respondents maintain that these distinctions are essential to uphold the integrity and sustainability of the SSD Fund, which operates independently of governmental appropriations and is solely reliant on contributions from subscribing SFF personnel.
On these grounds, the learned Additional Solicitor General implored the Court to dismiss the appeal and affirm the impugned judgments. Discussion and Conclusion: -
21. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at a bar and have perused the impugned judgments. With the assistance of learned counsel for the parties, we have thoroughly examined the material available on record.
22. The core issue presented for adjudication by the Court is whether the appellants herein, despite being classified as temporary employees of a scheme managed by contributory pooling of funds, can claim entitlement to pensionary benefits in accordance with the 6 th CPC. [2024] 8 S.C.R. 527Rajkaran Singh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
23. To address this issue, we must first consider the legal framework established by this Court in various landmark decisions, particularly in Ajay Hasia and Others v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi and Others6 and Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology and Others.7 While Ajay Hasia (supra) and Pradeep Kumar Biswas (supra) primarily dealt with determining whether a corporation could be considered an instrumentality of the state, the principles laid down therein provide valuable guidance in assessing the nature of employee-employer relationships. The relevant paragraphs of Ajay Hasia (supra) are reproduced below: - “7. …..If a corporation is found to be a mere agency or surrogate of the Government, “in fact owned by the Government, in truth controlled by the Government and in effect an incarnation of the Government”, the court, must not allow the enforcement of fundamental rights to be frustrated by taking the view that it is not the Government and therefore not subject to the constitutional limitations. We are clearly of the view that where a corporation is an instrumentality or agency of the Government, it must be held to be an “authority” within the meaning of Article 12 and hence subject to the same basic obligation to obey the Fundamental rights as the Government.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.