Rajesh Kumar v. Anand Kumar & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 444; [2024] 5 S.C.R. 612
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 17 May 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7840/2023
- Sections
- 12, 138
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 5 S.C.R. 612 : 2024 INSC 444 Rajesh Kumar v.
Anand Kumar & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 7840 of 2023)
17 May 2024 [Pankaj Mithal and Prashant Kumar Mishra,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to deposition of power of attorney holder in a suit for specific performance, in place and instead of the plaintiff-principal wherein the plaintiff is required to aver and prove his readiness and willingness to perform the terms of the contract; and the effect of filing a suit for specific performance after a long delay, on the last date of limitation.
Headnotes† Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s. 12 – Specific performance of part of contract – Deposition of a power of attorney holder, when can be read in evidence – On facts, the appellant entered into an agreement to sell with power of attorney holder for purchase of land for a sale consideration – Appellant paid earnest money on the date of agreement to sell and the balance amount was to be paid on the date of registration of the sale deed – Time for execution of the sale deed extended – However, the power of attorney holder executed the sale deed of the suit land in favour of respondents even though they were aware of the earlier sale agreement and its extensions – Sale deed executed behind the back of the appellant – Subsequently, on coming to know of the same, the appellant sent notice – Thereafter, suit filed and the trial court decreed in favour of the appellant – However, set aside by the High Court – Correctness:
Held: In view of s. 12, in a suit for specific performance wherein the plaintiff is required to aver and prove that he has performed or has always been ready and willing to perform the essential terms of the contract, a power of attorney holder is not entitled to depose in place and instead of the plaintiff (principal) – If the power of attorney holder has rendered some ‘acts’ in pursuance of power of attorney, he may depose for the principal in respect [2024] 5 S.C.R. 613Rajesh Kumar v. Anand Kumar & Ors.
of such acts, but he cannot depose for the principal for the act done by the principal and not by him – Similarly, he cannot depose for the principal in respect of the matter of which only the principal can have personal knowledge and in respect of which the principal is entitled to be cross-examined – It is necessary for the plaintiff to step into the witness box and depose that he was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract and subject himself to cross-examination on that issue – Plaintiff cannot examine in his place, his attorney holder who did not have personal knowledge either of the transaction or of his readiness and willingness – On facts, the plaintiff failed to appear in the witness box and subject himself to cross-examination, he has not been able to prove the pre-requisites of s. 12 and more so, when the original agreement contained a definite time for registration of sale deed which was later on extended but the suit was filed on the last date of limitation calculated on the basis of the last extended time – Instead, the power of attorney holder got himself examined – It is not a case where the suit itself was filed by power of attorney holder – He appeared subsequently only for recording his evidence as the special power of attorney holder of the plaintiff – Plaintiff entered into an agreement with only one of the co-owners and thereafter sought extensions for execution of the sale deed but did not prefer any suit though he was aware of the sale deed executed in favour of respondents – Suit was preferred, on the last date of limitation, after a long delay – Thus, the appellant not entitled for specific performance – Judgment and decree passed by the High Court upheld. [Paras 6, 8, 12, 13, 18, 19] Case Law Cited Shanmughasundaram & Ors. v. Diravia Nadar (dead) by Lrs. & Anr. [2005] 2 SCR 649 : AIR (2005) SC 1836; Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani & Anr. v. Indusind Bank Ltd. & Ors. [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 681 : (2005) 2 SCC 217; Man Kaur v. Hartar Singh Sangha [2010] 12 SCR 515 : 2010 (10) SCC 512; A.C. Narayanan v. State of Maharashtra & Anr. [2013] 11 SCR 80 : (2014) 11 SCC 790; K.S. Vidyanadam v. Vairavan [1997] 1 SCR 993 : (1997) 3 SCC 1; Azhar Sultana v. B. Rajamani & Ors. [2009] 2 SCR 537 : (2009) 17 SCC 27; Saradamani Kandappan v. S. Rajalakshmi & Ors. [2011] 8 SCR 874 : (2011) 12 SCC 18; Atma Ram v. Charanjit Singh [2020] 3 SCR 697 : (2020) 3 SCC 311 – referred to. 614 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Specific Relief Act, 1963.
List of Keywords Specific Relief; Specific performance; Deposition of power of attorney holder; Agreement to sell; Sale consideration; Earnest money; Ready and willing to perform the contract; Term ‘readiness and willingness’; Tendering in evidence; Limitation.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 7840 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 01.09.2016 of the High Court of M.P at Jabalpur in FA No. 340 of 2003 Appearances for Parties Dhruv Agrawal, Sr. Adv., M/s. Aura & Co., Yashish Chandra, Nishit Agrawal, Harsh Bansal, Kushagra Pandey, Ms. Vanya Agrawal, Ms. Kanishka Mittal, Advs. for the Appellant.
Gagan Gupta, Sr. Adv., Vineet Chaudhary, Santosh Chaudhary, Hemang Chaudhary, Saurabh Gupta, Rahul Gupta, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.
The appellant/plaintiff has called in question the judgment rendered by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh dated 01.09.2016 in First Appeal No. 340 of 2003 allowing the appeal preferred by the respondent nos. 1 to 3/defendant nos. 12 to 14 thereby setting aside the judgment and decree dated 25.04.2003 passed by the Trial Court in Civil Suit No. 38-A of 2000.
2. The facts of the case briefly stated, are that the appellant/plaintiff entered into an agreement to sell with respondent no. 4 (acting as Power of Attorney holder of respondents/defendant nos. 2 to 11) for purchase of land admeasuring 145.60 acres bearing Khasra No. 214 to 233 (except Khasra No. 225) and Khasra Nos. 67/1 to 212 situated at village Khirsau, Tehsil Sihora, District Jabalpur, M.P for [2024] 5 S.C.R. 615Rajesh K u m a r v . A n a n d K u m a r & O r s . sale consideration at the rate of Rs. 3,000/- per acre, totalling Rs. 4,41,000/-. The appellant/plaintiff paid earnest money of Rs. 41,000/on the date of agreement to sell and the balance amount was to be paid on the date of registration of the sale deed which was to be done within six months from the date of agreement.
2.1 On 22.05.1996, the appellant/plaintiff paid an additional amount of Rs. 20,000/- for which an endorsement was made on the backside of the agreement. Further amount of Rs. 40,000/- was paid on 30.06.1996 which too was endorsed on the backside of the agreement. On 26.12.1996, another agreement was executed between the appellant/plaintiff and the Power of Attorney Holder extending the execution of the sale deed till 31.03.1997, remaining terms being the same. The date was further extended to 31.05.1997 vide entry made in the subsequent agreement dated 26.12.1996. Another entry was made on 23.04.1997 mentioning that the agreement to sell shall come to an end on 31.05.1997.
2.2 However, the respondent/defendant no. 1 being the Power of Attorney Holder of respondents/defendant nos. 2 to 11 executed the sale deed of the suit land on 14.05.1997 in favour of respondent nos. 1 to 3/defendant nos. 12 to 14 even though the said respondents were aware of the earlier sale agreement and its extensions. The sale deed dated 14.05.1997 was executed behind the back of the appellant/plaintiff which came to his notice subsequently on which a legal notice was sent on 30.05.1997 calling upon the respondents/defendant nos. 1 to 11 to be present in the Registrar’s office at Sihora on 31.05.1997 to carry out the formalities for execution of the sale deed. Despite receipt of this notice, the respondents/defendant nos. 1 to 11 did not attend the Registrar Office. On 31.05.1997, the appellant/plaintiff was informed by the sub-Registrar that the suit land has been sold in favour of respondent nos. 1 to 3/defendant nos. 12 to 14.
2.3 According to the appellant/plaintiff, he is in possession of the suit land, therefore, he objected to the application dated 20.08.1997 moved by the respondents/defendant nos. 12 to 14 for mutation of their names. The Gram Panchayat assured the appellant/ plaintiff in its meeting dated 06.12.1997 that defendant nos. 616 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 12 to 14 will execute a sale deed in favour of the appellant/ plaintiff, therefore, legal action was not initiated. The present suit was filed on 19.06.2000.
2.4 The respondents/defendants in joint written statement averred that the suit land is in possession of the respondent nos. 1 to 3/defendant nos. 12 to 14 being the bona fide purchasers for value paid vide registered sale deed dated 14.05.1997. It was pleaded that the respondents/defendants were not aware of any agreement to sell between the appellant/plaintiff and respondent nos. 1 to 11 and that the suit is barred by limitation. It was also pleaded that time was the essence of the contract and the sale deed was to be executed within six months from the date of the agreement and that the appellant/plaintiff did not have sufficient funds with him for payment of the sale consideration and the advance amount of Rs. 40,000/- was also returned to the appellant/plaintiff through one Subhash Chandra Bansal. The respondents/defendant nos. 2A to 2F filed their separate joint written statement stating that their late father Raghvendra Kumar Bakshi has never executed or agreed to execute the sale agreement. Similar was the plea in the written statement filed by the respondent/defendant no. 5.
2.5 The Trial Court decreed the suit upon finding that the agreement to sell has been executed between the appellant/plaintiff and defendant no. 1 as a Power of Attorney Holder of defendant nos. 2 to 11. Non-examination of the appellant/plaintiff as a witness was held not having any adverse impact on plaintiff’s case. The Trial Court also found that the time allowed for execution of sale deed was extended twice and he had also paid earnest money, therefore, the appellant/plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part of the contract and the suit is not barred by limitation. Since the extended time for registration of sale deed was till 31.05.1997 and the suit was to be filed on or before 30.05.2000. However, on the said date, the Court was closed for summer vacation which ended on 18.06.2000 and the suit was filed on 19.06.2000. Therefore, the suit was within limitation, having been filed on the last date of limitation.
2.6 In appeal preferred by the respondent nos. 1 to 3/defendant nos. 12 to 14, the High Court has passed the impugned judgment [2024] 5 S.C.R. 617Rajesh Kumar v. Anand Kumar & Ors.
allowing the appeal to set aside the judgment and decree of the Trial Court consequently dismissing the appellant/plaintiff’s suit. Hence this appeal.
3. Mr. Dhruv Agrawal, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that the High Court has committed serious error of law and fact by setting aside the well reasoned judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court. According to him, the execution of sale agreement by defendant no. 1 as a Power of Attorney Holder of Defendant Nos. 2 to 11 having been duly proved and the appellant/ plaintiff having paid the earnest money and filing the suit within time, the First Appellate Court ought not to have set aside the judgment of the Trial Court. It is further submitted that the High Court is not correct in holding that the defendant nos. 2 to 11 had not signed the agreement because defendant no. 1 was their Power of Attorney Holder. The High Court has also erred in holding that Power of Attorney Holder cannot depose in a civil suit on behalf of the plaintiff. According to him, non-appearance of the appellant/ plaintiff as a witness would not have any adverse impact in a suit of this nature and that the readiness and willingness can be proved by the Attorney Holder.
4. Per contra, Mr. Gagan Gupta, learned senior counsel for the respondents/defendants would submit that the agreement dated 26.09.1995 is void ab initio because it was not executed by all the owners of the suit land. It was then argued that in a suit for specific performance non-appearance of plaintiff as a witness is fatal to his case because it is he who has to plead and prove the readiness and willingness. He would submit that the High Court has rightly set aside the judgment and decree of the Trial Court which is based on perverse finding and incorrect application of settled legal principles.
5. The High Court has non-suited the appellant/plaintiff on two counts. Firstly, that defendant no. 1 is not the sole owner of the property which was the coparcenary property and the other coparceners did not sign the initial agreement and secondly, that the appellant/ plaintiff having failed to appear in the witness box, the testimony of his Power of Attorney Holder cannot be read as statement of the plaintiff in a civil suit of this nature.
6. Admittedly, the initial agreement dated 26.09.1995 was executed by Defendant no. 1-Gajay Bahadur Bakshi. It is the case of the appellant/ 618 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports plaintiff that Gajay Bahadur Bakshi was the Power of Attorney Holder of Defendant nos. 2 to 11, the other co-owners/coparceners of the suit property. However, the agreement itself no where states that Gajay Bahadur Bakshi has executed the agreement as Attorney Holder of Defendant nos. 2 to 11. On the contrary, it is mentioned in the agreement that Gajay Bahadur Bakshi would be responsible for getting the sale deed executed and registered by all the co-owners or co-khatedars at the time of registration. Neither the names of all the co-owners/ coparceners/co-khatedars are mentioned in the agreement, thus, the High Court is right in finding that all the co-owners have not signed the agreement. The subsequent endorsement of receipt of additional amount of Rs. 40,000/- is also not signed by all the co-parceners. The same is the condition with the 3rd agreement dated 26.12.1996 and the extension endorsement dated 27.03.1997 and 23.04.1997. Significantly, the so-called power of attorney pleaded in the plaint through which the defendant nos. 2 to 11 authorised defendant no. 1 to execute the agreement, have not been produced and proved in the Trial Court. Thus, neither in the agreement nor in course of trial the power of attorney is proved by tendering the same in evidence. Hence, in the absence of evidence, the High Court rightly held that the agreement is not signed by all the co-owners.
7. In the matter of Shanmughasundaram & Ors. Vs. Diravia Nadar (dead) by Lrs. & Anr.1, this Court has held that in the event all the co-sharers of the property have not executed the sale agreement, a suit for specific performance cannot be decreed. The following is held in paras 29,30 & 31:
“29. The facts in present case are distinguishable. Admittedly, the property has been jointly inherited by two brothers and three sisters. As heirs under the Hindu Succession Act, they inherited the property as co-owners. In the absence of partition between them, the two brothers together had undivided share in the property, and they could not have agreed for sale of the entire property. They were competent to execute agreement to the extent only of their undivided share in the property. In the event of sale of such undivided share, the vendee would be required to file a suit for partition 1 [2005] 2 SCR 649 : AIR 2005 SC 1836 [2024] 5 S.C.R. 619Rajesh Kumar v. Anand Kumar & Ors.
to work out his right in the property. The left out three sisters as co-owners having undivided share in the whole property, the two brothers are incompetent to abide by the award.
30. Learned counsel makes a reference to Section 12 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 and submits that the arbitration agreement and consequent award should be allowed to be enforced to the extent of share of two brothers leaving the vendee to work out his right, if necessary, in case the sisters object to the sale, by a suit in accordance with Section 12 of the Specific Relief Act.
31. Section 12 of the Specific Relief Act, in our considered opinion, would be of no assistance in the situation obtaining here. In the absence of sisters being parties to the agreement, the vendee can at best obtain undivided interest of two brothers in the property. Section 12 of the Specific Relief Act cannot be invoked by the vendee to obtain sale of undivided share of the two brothers with a right to force partition on the sisters who were not parties to the agreement of sale. Such a relief under Section 12 cannot be obtained by a vendee, on purchase of an undivided share of the property of some of the co-owners, against other co-owners who were not parties to the sale agreement.”
8. Undisputedly, in the present case, the plaintiff failed to appear in the witness box. Instead, his Power of Attorney Holder – Parmod Khare has got himself examined as PW-1. This witness was examined on 05.09.2002 and the power of attorney was executed on 26.08.2002. It is not a case where the suit itself was filed by a Power of Attorney Holder. He appeared subsequently only for recording his evidence as the Special Power of Attorney Holder of the plaintiff. The legal position as to when the deposition of a Power of Attorney Holder can be read in evidence has been dealt with by this Court in several decisions.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.