All India Judges Association v. Union of India & Ors
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 26; [2024] 1 S.C.R. 327
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice Manoj Misra
- Decided
- 4 Jan 2024
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 643/2015
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 1 S.C.R. 327 : 2024 INSC 26 All India Judges Association v.
Union of India & Ors (Writ Petition (Civil) No 643 of 2015)
04 January 2024 [Dr. Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud,* CJI, J. B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Allowances granted to judicial officers and retired judicial officers by the Second National Judicial Pay Commission (SNJPC). Headnotes Judiciary – District Judiciary – Recommendations by Second National Judicial Pay Commission (SNJPC) regarding various allowances for judicial officers and retired judicial officers – 21 allowances considered by SNJPC in its report:
Held: As regards House Building Advance (HBA), recommendation of SNJPC that HBA be available to judicial officers also for the purchase of a ready built house from private individuals subject to such safeguards as may be prescribed by the State Govt. in consultation with their respective High Courts – Modification accepted – Payment of Children Education Allowance as recommended, approved – Recommendation for discontinuation of City Compensatory Allowance and no recovery to be made, accepted – Recommendations w.r.t Concurrent Charges Allowance; payment of conveyance/transport allowance; Earned Leave Encashment; Electricity and Water Charges; Hill Area/Tough Location Allowance; Home Orderly/Domestic Help Allowance; Newspaper and Magazine Allowances; Risk Allowance; Robe Allowance; Special Pay for Administrative Work; Telephone Facility; Transfer Grant accepted –As regards Higher Qualification Allowance, the restrictive condition imposed by SNJPC in regard to non-extension of advance increments at the ACP stage, not accepted – Subject to this clarification, recommendations accepted – Further, out of the five components of house rent related allowances, two components-Furniture and Air Conditioner Allowance and Maintenance introduced for the first time – All the 328 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports components suggested are accepted – As regards, Leave Travel Concession/Home Travel Concession, recommendations are on a continuum and accepted, except for foreign travel to SAARC countries which shall be deleted – Substantive recommendations made w.r.t Medical Allowance/Facilities, accepted – As regards sumptuary allowance, recommendation for increase of 2.25 times based on the yardstick of annual inflation and increase of points in the consumer price index, accepted – Committee for Service Conditions of the District Judiciary (CSCDJ) be constituted in each High Court for overseeing the implementation of the recommendations of the SNJPC as approved – Composition, functions of the Committee and the issues to be considered, enumerated – States and Union Territories to act in terms of the directions expeditiously – Disbursements on account of arrears of salary, pension and allowances due and payable to judicial officers, retired judicial officers and family pensioners be computed and paid on or before 29.02.2024 – CSCDJs to monitor compliance and submit report on or before 07.04.2024. [Paras 20, 24, 27, 29, 32, 34, 37, 40, 43, 44, 46, 48, 50, 55, 65, 67, 69, 71, 74, 77, 79, 81, 83-87] Judiciary – District Judiciary – Allowances for judicial officers, retired judicial officers – Objections raised that revision of rates/new allowances will result in an increased financial burden and expenditure; the rules governing the payment of allowances prescribed by each State for their own administrative establishment must be followed; and the benefits which are provided to judicial officers must be equivalent to those provided to other Government officers: Held: Submissions urged on behalf of the States have been considered in several previous judgments of this Court – Judicial service is an integral and significant component of the functions of the State and contributes to the constitutional obligation to sustain the rule of law – State is duty bound to ensure that the conditions of service, both during the tenure of office and after retirement, are commensurate with the need to maintain dignified working conditions for serving judicial officers and in the post-retirement emoluments made available to former members of the judicial service – Members of the district judiciary are the first point of engagement for citizens who are confronted with the need for dispute resolution – The conditions in which judicial officers across [2024] 1 S.C.R. 329All India Judges Association v. Union of India & Ors the country are required to work are arduous – The work of a judicial officer is not confined merely to the working hours rendered in the course of judicial duties in the court – That apart, members of the district judiciary have wide ranging administrative functions which take place beyond working hours, especially on week-ends – Further, there is a need to maintain uniformity in the service conditions of judicial officers across the country – Thus, the plea that rules of each State must govern pay and allowances, lacks substance – Judges are not comparable with the administrative executive – They discharge sovereign state functions and just like the Council of Ministers or the political executive and their service is different from the secretarial staff or the administrative executive which carries out the decisions of the political executive, judges are distinct from judicial staff, and are thus comparable with the political executive and legislature – Wholly inappropriate to equate judicial service with the service of other officers of the State – The functions, duties, restrictions and restraints operating during and after service are entirely distinct for members of the judicial service – Plea of equivalence rejected yet again. [Paras 13, 17 and 18] Case Law Cited All India Judges Association v Union of India [2002] 2 SCR 712 : (2002) 4 SCC 247; All India Judges Association v Union of India (2010) 14 SCC 720; All India Judges Association v. Union of India (II) [1993] 1 Suppl. SCR 749 : (1993) 4 SCC 288; State of Maharashtra v Tejwant Singh Sandhu SLP(C) 1041 of 2020; Bharat Kumar Shantilal Thakkar v State of Gujarat & Anr. [2014] 4 SCR 1147 : (2014) 15 SCC 305 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords District Judiciary; Second National Judicial Pay Commission; Allowances granted to judicial officers and retired judicial officers; Children Education Allowance; City Compensatory Allowance; Concurrent Charges Allowance; Conveyance/transport allowance; Earned Leave Encashment; Electricity and Water Charges; Hill Area/Tough Location Allowance; Home Orderly/Domestic Help Allowance; Newspaper and Magazine Allowances; Risk Allowance; 330 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Robe Allowance; Special Pay for Administrative Work; Telephone Facility; Transfer Grant; Higher Qualification Allowance; House Rent Allowances; Furniture and Air Conditioner Allowance; Maintenance; Leave Travel Concession/Home Travel Concession; Medical Allowance/Facilities; Sumptuary Allowance, Committee for Service Conditions of the District Judiciary; Article 142.
Case Arising From CIVIL ORIGINAL/INHERENT/EXTRA-ORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (Civil) No.643 of 2015.
(UNDER ARTICLE 32 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA)
With SLP (C) Nos.6471-6473 of 2020, 29232 of 2018 and Contempt Petition (C) Nos.711 of 2022, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 848 and 1338 of 2023 in Writ Petition (C) No.643 of 2015.
Appearances for Parties K.Parameshwar (Amicus Curiae), Ms. Kanti, Ms. Arti Gupta, MV Mukunda, Chinmay Kalgaonkar, Advs.
K M Nataraj, A.S.G., Shailesh Madiyal, B.K. Satija, Dr. Hemant Gupta, Barun Kumar Sinha, Saurabh Mishra, Amit Anand Tiwari, A.A.Gs., K N Balgopal, Gurminder Singh, Adv. Gen./Sr. Advs., Lenin Singh Hijam, Adv. Gen, Kuldeep Parihar, D.A.G., Gourab Banerjee, Dr. Manish Singhvi, Wasim Quadri, Jaideep Gupta, Huzefa Ahmadi, Sunil Kumar, V. Giri, Sudhir Kumar Saxena, Sanjay Parikh, Sr. Advs., Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, Vyom Raghuvanshi, Dhruv Sharma, VP Singh, Venkata Supreeth, Gopal Jha, Umesh Kumar Yadav, Deepak Prakash, V. N. Raghupathy, Manendra Pal Gupta, Varun Varma, Md. Apzal Ansari, Milind Kumar, Dr. Reeta Vasishta, Mohd Akhil, Mrs. Swarupama Chaturvedi, Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Ms. Sonali Jain, Chitvan Sinhal, Kartikaya Aggrawal, Abhishek Kumar Pandey, Raman Yadav, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Pashupathi Nath Razdan, Rushab Aggarwal, Sharath Nambiar, Astik Gupta, Vaibhav Sabharwal, Japnish Singh Bhatia, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Anmol Chandan, Vatsal Joshi, Annirudh Sharma-II, Ishaan Sharma, Kanu Agarawal, Bhuvan Kapoor, Ms. Indira Bhakar, Mukesh Kumar Verma, Piyush Beriwal, Varun Chugh, Ms. Mrinal Elkar Mazumdar, Sarthak Karol, Harish Pandey, Apoorv Kurup, Shashwat Parihar, Mrs. [2024] 1 S.C.R. 331All India J u d g e s A s s o c i ation v . U n i o n o f India & O r s Priyadarshini Priya, Rajesh Singh Chauhan, Mahesh Thakur, Mrs. Geetanjali Bedi, Shivamm Sharrma, Ms. Preetika Dwivedi, Abhisek Mohanty, Gagan Gupta, Sudhanshu S. Choudhari, Ms. Rucha A. Pande, Manish M. Veeraragavan, Ms. Gautami Yadav, Ms. Pranjal Chapalgaonkar, Sandeep Sudhakar Deshmukh, Kunal Chatterji, Ms. Maitrayee Banerjee, Rohit Bansal, Ms. Kshitij Singh, Ms. Nidhi Mittal, Ms. Aparna Arun, Ms. Anchal, Akhil Hasija, Ms. Gauri Goburdhun, Ms. Kavita Jha, Rajeev Kumar Jha, Aditeya Bali, P. I. Jose, Anupam Mishra, James P. Thomas, Maibam Nabaghanashyam Singh, Amit Sharma, Sanjai Kumar Pathak, Arvind Kumar Tripathi, Mrs. Shashi Pathak, Nikhil Goel, Ms. Pragati Neekhra, Aditya Bhanu Neekhra, Aniket Patel, Anupam Raina, Sunando Raha, Nikhil Palli, Nishant Kumar, Krishnanand Pandeya, Dev Pratap Shahi, Raghavendra S. Srivatsa, T. G. Narayanan Nair, A. Radhakrishnan, Arjun Garg, Aakash Nandolia, Ms. Sagun Srivastava, Niranjan Sahu, Umakant Misra, Debabrata Dash, Abhijit Pattnaik, Ms. Apoorva Sharma, Ashok Mathur, Mukul Kumar, Ms. Enakshi Mukhopadhyay Siddhanta, Sovon Siddhanta, Saravanan A., J. Vasanthan, K.G. Kannan, Mukesh K. Giri, Mandaar Mukesh Giri, Santosh Krishnan, Ms. Deepshikha Sansanwal, Anil Shrivastav, Shuvodeep Roy, Kabir Shankar Bose, Saurabh Tripathi, Manish Kumar, Mahesh Kumar, Sumeer Sodhi, Nikhilesh Kumar, Ms. Jyoti Kumari, Ms. Devika Khanna, Mrs. V D Khanna, VMZ Chambers, Abhay Anil Anturkar, Dhruv Tank, Aniruddha Awalgaonkar, Ms. Surbhi Kapoor, Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Samar Vijay Singh, Ms. Payal Gupta, Shivang Jain, Ms. Nitikaa Guptha, Ms. Monica Anand Kumar, Ms. Sabarni Som, Ravi Bakshi, Sandeep Rana, Ms. M. Venmani, S. Gowthaman, Ms. Saima Firoze, Abhisar Thakral, Rajiv Shankar Dvivedi, Anando Mukherjee, Shwetank Singh, Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar, Abraham Mathew, Rebin Vincent Gralan, Sunny Choudhary, Sandeep Sharma, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Raavi Sharma, Ms. Yamini Singh, Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, Karun Shrama, Ms. Rajkumari Divyasana, R. Rajaselvan, Avijit Mani Tripathi, Nirnimesh Dube, Ms. K. Enatoli Sema, Ms. Limayinla Jamir, Amit Kumar Singh, Ms. Chubalemla Chang, Prang Newmai, Shibashish Misra, Karan Sharma, Ajay Pal, Mohit Siwach, Sameer Abhyankar, Ms. Nishi Sangtani, Ms. Vani Vandana Chhetri, Ms. Zinnea Mehta, Naman Jain, Sabarish Subramanian, Ms. Devyani Gupta, Vishnu Unnikrishnan, C Kranthi Kumar, Naman Dwivedi, Danish Saifi, Ms. V Keerthana, Ms. Tanvi 332 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Anand, Rajiv Kumar Choudhry, Sanjay Kumar Tyagi, Sudarshan Singh Rawat, Ashutosh Kumar Sharma, Ms. Saakshi Singh Rawat, S Sunil, Sunny Sachin Rawat, Parijat Sinha, Ms. Madhumita Bhattacharjee, Chirag M. Shroff, Aravindh S., Abbas, Ahantham Henry, Ahantham Rahen Singh, Mohan Singh, Kumar Mihir, Mrs. Anjani Aiyagari, T. V. Ratnam, Ankur Kashyap, Joydip Roy, Gopal Jha, Umesh Kumar Yadav, Shreyash Bhardwaj, Karthik S.D., Uday B. Dube, Deepak Prakash, Pawan Kr. Dabas, Kamal Singh Bisht, Raneev Dahiya, Nachiketa Vajpayee, Ms. Divyangna Malik, Ms. Merlyn J. Rachel, Ms. Vishnu Priya, Vardaan Kapoor, Rahul Lakhera, Rahul Suresh, Aviral Saxena, Piyush Thanvi, Mohammed Imran, Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Harshit Goel, Sujay Jain, K.V. Vibu Prasad, Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, Ritwick Parikh, Karun Sharma, Ms. Rajkumari Divyasana, R. Rajaselvan, Gopal Jha, Umesh Kumar Yadav, Sravan Kumar Karanam, Santhosh Kumar Puppala, Ms. Shireesh Tyagi, Ms. Pranali Tayade Advs. for the appearing parties. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI Contents* Objections by the Union Government and State Governments: ........................................................................... 6 Allowances recommended by the SNJPC .................................. 13 1 House Building Advance (HBA) .......................................... 13 2 Children Education Allowance (CEA) .................................. 15 3 City Compensatory Allowance (CCA) ................................. 16 4 Concurrent Charges Allowance ........................................... 17 5 Conveyance/Transport Allowance (TP) ............................... 18 6 Dearness Allowance ............................................................ 20 7 Earned Leave Encashment ................................................. 20 8 Electricity and Water Charges ............................................. 21 9 Higher Qualification Allowance ............................................ 22 10 Hill Area/Tough Location Allowance .................................... 24 * Ed. Note : Pagination is as per the original judgment. [2024] 1 S.C.R. 333All India J u d g e s A s s o c i ation v . U n i o n o f India & O r s 11 Home Orderly/Domestic Help Allowance ............................ 25 12 House Rent Allowance and Residential Quarters ............... 26 13 Leave Travel Concession(LTC)/Home Travel Concession (HTC) ................................................................ 31 14 Medical Allowance/Medical Facilities .................................. 33 Fixed Allowance ................................................................... 36 Medical Facilities and Reimbursement ............................... 36 15 Newspaper and Magazine Allowances ............................... 39 16 Risk Allowance .................................................................... 40 17 Robe Allowance ................................................................... 40 18 Special Pay for Administrative Work ................................... 41 19 Sumptuary Allowance .......................................................... 42 20 Telephone Facility ................................................................ 44 21 Transfer Grant ..................................................................... 46 Institutionalization ........................................................................ 47
1. By its orders dated 27 July 2022, 5 April 2023 and 19 May 2023, this Court has accepted the recommendations of the Second National Judicial Pay Commission1, chaired by Justice P V Reddy, former Judge of this Court of India on the revision of pay and pension for judicial officers.
2. The abovementioned orders have delineated inter alia the history of the constitution of the SNJPC, and the principles underlying judicial pay, allowances and pensions. The contents of the earlier orders shall not be repeated here. This judgment pertains to the allowances which have been granted to judicial officers and retired judicial officers by the SNJPC. At this stage, it would be necessary to note that save and except for three allowances, where there was a modification, the allowances recommended by the First National Judicial Pay Commission known as the Shetty Commission were affirmed by this Court in All India Judges Association v Union of India2. Thereafter, all allowances which were recommended by the 1 “SNJPC”
2 (2002) 4 SCC 247
334 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports subsequent pay commission, namely the Judicial Pay Commission3 called the Justice Padmanabhan Committee were accepted by this Court in its decision reported as All India Judges Association v Union of India4 .
3. Besides Mr K Parameshwar, Amicus Curiae, all the State governments and Union Territories have been given an opportunity to furnish their objections to the allowances, as proposed by the SNJPC. Objections have been filed on the record of this Court.
4. In the course of hearing, the following counsel have appeared on behalf of the States, or as the case may be, the Associations of Judges :
S. No. Name of the counsel Appearing for 1 Mr Gaurab Banerji, Sr. Adv. AIJA 2 Mr. Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Adv High Court at Calcutta 3 Mr Gopal Jha, Adv All India Retired Judges Association 4 Ms Gautami Yadav, Adv Maharashtra State Judges Association 5 Mr Sunny Choudhary Madhya Pradesh 6 Mr Mukesh Kumar Verma Andaman & Nicobar 7 MrJoydip Roy, Adv. All India Judges Association 8 Ms Madhumita Bhattacharjee West Bengal 9 Mr Sanjay Kumar Tyagi Uttar Pradesh 10 Mr Shuvodeep Roy Assam and Tripura 11 Mr. Ravi Shanker Jha Bihar 12 Mr. Amit Anand Tiwari, AAG Tamil Nadu 13 Mr. Sabarish Subramanian, Adv Tamil Nadu 14 Mr. Karan Sharma, Adv. Punjab 15 Dr Manish Singhvi, Sr, Adv Rajasthan 16 Mr V N Raghupathy, Adv Karnataka 17 Deepanwita Priyanka, Adv Gujarat 18 Mr. Sriharsha Pichara, Adv Telangana 3 “JPC”
4 (2010) 14 SCC 720
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 335All India Judges Association v. Union of India & Ors 19 Mr Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar Manipur 20 Ms K Enatoli Sema Nagaland 21 Ravi Bakshi, Adv Himachal Pradesh 22 Mr Alim Anvar, Adv. Kerala 23 Mr Amit Kumar, AAG Meghalaya 24 Mr Ashutosh Kumar Sharma, Adv Uttarakhand 25 Mr Deepak Prakash, Adv Kerala Judicial Officers Association.
5. In addition, we have had the benefit of considering intervention applications by the State of Maharashtra.
6. The Amicus Curiae has tendered a note summarizing the position. The SNJPC considered a total of twenty-one allowances in its report. These allowances are tabulated below:
1. House Building Advance 12. House Rent Allowance a. Residential Quarters b. HRA c. Furniture & Air Conditioner Allowance d. Maintenance e. Guest House
2. Children Education Allowance 13. Leave Travel Concession/ Home Travel Concession
3. City Compensatory Allowance 14. 14. Medical Allowance
4. Concurrent Charge allowance 15. Newspaper and Magazine Allowance
5. Conveyance/Transport Allowance 16. Risk Allowance
6. Dearness Allowance 17. Robe Allowance
7. Earned leave encashment 18. Special Pay for Administrative Work
8. Electricity and water charges 19. Sumptuary Allowance
9. Higher Qualification 20. Telephone Facility
10. Hill area/ Tough Location Allowance
21. Transfer Grant
11. Home orderly/Domestic Help Allowance 336 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
7. Among the allowances which have been recommended by the SNJPC, two new allowances are proposed while two additional components are introduced to an additional allowance, namely :
(i) Children Education Allowance (Serial No 2 in the tabulation);
(ii) A Furniture and Air conditioner allowance and maintenance as a part of the House Rent Allowance (Serial Nos 12C and 12D); and
(iii) Risk Allowance (Serial No 16 of the tabulation).
8. The SNJPC has recommended that the City Compensatory Allowance (Serial No 3 of the above tabulation) should be discontinued. In respect of the Robe Allowance (Serial No 17), the SNJPC recommended that such a demand would not be entertained by the next JPC. Twelve out of the twenty-one allowances form the subject matter of a recommendation either by the Sixth or, as the case may be, Seventh Central Pay Commission either on the same or on revised rates.
9. At the outset, it needs to be clarified that since the SNJPC has proposed a revision of the existing rates as applicable, the States/ Union Territories shall continue to pay the allowances at the rates which were applicable in respect of each allowance where the SNJPC has recommended that the revised rates shall come into effect later than 1 January 2016.
Objections by the Union Government and State Governments:
10. Before we deal with each individual allowance, it would be necessary to record that, broadly speaking, the objections which have been raised by the States, Union Territories and the Union Government can be classified into three categories :
(a) The revision of rates or, as the case may be, the new allowances will result in an increased financial burden and expenditure;
(b) The rules governing the payment of allowances prescribed by each State for their own administrative establishment must be followed; and
(c) the benefits which are provided to judicial officers must be equivalent to those provided to other Government officers.
11. The submissions urged on behalf of the States have been considered in several previous judgments of this Court, more specifically in relation to the recommendations of the SNJPC itself. On the aspect of the [2024] 1 S.C.R. 337All India J u d g e s A s s o c i ation v . U n i o n o f India & O r s increased financial burden and additional expenditure, this Court, in its judgment dated 5 April 2023, relied on the earlier decision in the All India Judges Associationv.Union of India (II)5 andheld that contentions regarding the financial implications of the directions are liable to be rejected when the directions stem from the obligation of the state. In other words, a plea of financial burden cannot be raised to resist mandatory duties of the state. Providing necessary service conditions for the effective discharge of judicial functions is one such duty. The observations in that regard are contained in paragraph 19 of the judgment dated 05 April 20236 .
12. The same objection was dealt with in the subsequent judgment of this Court dated 19 May 2023 at paragraph 26.7 The Court noted that the issue of financial burden has been examined in these very proceedings on at least three occasions and that this Court had earlier expressed the hope that it will not be re-agitated in view of All India Judges Association vs Union of India (II)8 .
13. Judicial service is an integral and significant component of the functions of the State and contributes to the constitutional obligation to sustain the rule of law. Judicial service is distinct in its characteristics and in terms of the responsibilities which are cast upon the officers of the District Judiciary to render objective dispensation of justice
5 (1993) 4 SCC 288.
6 19. The directions of this court applying a uniform multiplier and the corresponding financial implications cannot be considered as excessive in view of the information extracted above. In All India Judges Associationv. Union of India (II), this court has earlier held that additional financial burden cannot be a ground for review:
“16. The contention with regard to the financial burden likely to be imposed by the directions in question, is equally misconceived. Firstly, the courts do from time to time hand down decisions which have financial implications and the Government is obligated to loosen its purse recurrently pursuant to such decisions. Secondly, when the duties are obligatory, no grievance can be heard that they cast financial burden. Thirdly, compared to the other plan and non-plan expenditure, we find that the financial burden caused on account of the said directions is negligible. We should have thought that such plea was not raised to resist the discharge of the mandatory duties. The contention that the resources of all the States are not uniform has also to be rejected for the same reasons. The directions prescribe the minimum necessary service conditions and facilities for the proper administration of justice. We believe that the quality of justice administered and the caliber of the persons appointed to administer it are not of different grades in different States. Such contentions are illsuited to the issues involved in the present case.”
(emphasis supplied)
7 26. The submission of the States that there is a paucity of financial resources must be examined from this aspect of the matter. The States and the Union have repeatedly stated that the burden on the financial resources of the States/Union due to the Report of the SNJPC is significant and therefore the Report cannot be implemented. Without the doctrine of inherent powers, any de-funding of the Judiciary cannot be repelled.
8 (1993) 4 SCC 288.
338 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to citizens. The State is duty bound to ensure that the conditions of service, both during the tenure of office and after retirement, are commensurate with the need to maintain dignified working conditions for serving judicial officers and in the post-retirement emoluments made available to former members of the judicial service. Members of the district judiciary are the first point of engagement for citizens who are confronted with the need for dispute resolution. The conditions in which judicial officers across the country are required to work arearduous. The work of a judicial officer is not confined merely to the working hours rendered in the course of judicial duties in the court. Every judicial officer is required to work both before and after the court working hours. The judicial work of each day requires preparation before cases are called out. A judicial officer continues to work on cases which may have been dealt with in court, in terms of preparing the judgment and attending to other administrative aspects of the judicial record. That apart, members of the district judiciary have wide ranging administrative functions which take place beyond working hours, especially on week-ends including the discharge of numerous duties in relation to prison establishments, juvenile justice institutions, legal service camps and in general, work associated with the Legal Services Act 1987.
14. The work of a Judge cannot be assessed solely in terms of their duties during court working hours. The State is under an affirmative obligation to ensure dignified conditions of work for its judicial officers and it cannot raise the defense of an increase in financial burden or expenditure. Judicial officers spend the largest part of their working life in service of the institution. The nature of the office often renders the incumbent incapacitated in availing of opportunities for legal work which may otherwise be available to a member of the Bar. That furnishes an additional reason why post-retirement, it is necessary for the State to ensure that judicial officers are able to live in conditions of human dignity. It needs to be emphasized that providing for judges, both during their tenure and upon retirement, is correlated with the independence of the judiciary. Judicial independence, which is necessary to preserve the faith and confidence of common citizens in the rule of law, can be ensured and enhanced only so long as judges are able to lead their life with a sense of financial dignity. The conditions of service while a judge is in service must ensure a dignified existence. The post-retirement conditions of service have a crucial bearing on the dignity and independence of the office of a judge and how it is perceived by the society. If the service of [2024] 1 S.C.R. 339All India Judges Association v. Union of India & Ors the judiciary is to be a viable career option so as to attract talent, conditions of service, both for working and retired officers, must offer security and dignity.
15. As we shall indicate in the course of this judgment, the allowances which have been provided by the SNJPC are basic allowances, most of which rank on the same scale as what has been made available to officers discharging executive functions in the AllIndia Services. It is a matter of grave concern that though officers in the other services have availed of a revision of their conditions of service as far back as 01 January 2016, similar issues pertaining to judicial officers are still awaiting a final decision eight years thereafter. Judges have retired from service. The family pensioners of those who have passed away are awaiting resolution as well.
16. The second objection which has been raised on behalf of the States is that the rules of the particular State must be followed in each instance. This has again been dealt with in the judgment of this Court dated 19 May 2023. The relevant extract is footnoted below.9
17. This Court has categorically held that there is a need to maintain uniformity in the service conditions of judicial officers across the country. Thus, the plea that rules of each State must govern pay and allowances, lacks substance.
18. The third objection as to the equivalence between judicial officers and other Government officers has been elaborately analyzed in paragraph 1410 of the judgment dated 05 April 2023 and in 9 22. India has a unified judiciary under the scheme of the Constitution. A unified judiciary necessarily entails that the service conditions of judges of one state are equivalent to similar posts of judges of other states. The purpose of this constitutional scheme is to ensure that the judicial system is uniform, effective and efficient in its functioning. Efficient functioning necessarily requires judges of caliber and capacity to be provided with the right incentives and promotion opportunities to maintain the high level of functioning of the judiciary.
23 This Court in All India Judges Association (II) has noted the position of law and observed that uniform designations and hierarchy, with uniform service conditions are unavoidable necessary consequences. It was held:
“14. … Secondly, the judiciary in this country is a unified institution judicially though not administratively.Hence uniform designations and hierarchy, with uniform service conditions are unavoidable necessary consequences. ….” 10 14. In view of the above discussion, the issue is whether there is any compelling need to reduce the quantum of increase proposed by applying a lower multiplier so as to marginally reduce the gap between entry level IAS officers (in Junior and Senior time scales) and Judicial Officers at the first two levels (Civil Judge, Junior and Senior Divisions). Such an exercise is not warranted for more than one reason. Firstly, the initial starting pay must be such as to offer an incentive to talented youngsters to join judicial service. Secondly, the application of a multiplier/ factor less than 2.81 would result in a deviation from the principle adopted by SNJPC that the extent of increase of pay of judicial officers must be commensurate with 340 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports paragraphs 24, 2911 of the judgment dated 19 May 2023. Judges are the increase in the pay of High Court judges. This principle has been accepted by this Court by approving the recommendations of the SNJPC. Therefore, there is no valid reason to depart from the principle applied by JPC that the pay of judicial officers should be higher when compared to All India Service Officers of the corresponding rank. This principle has been approved by this Court in AIJA (2002).….. Thirdly, in All India Judges Association (II) v. Union of India, this court rejected the comparison of service conditions of the judiciary with that of the administrative executive: “7. It is not necessary to repeat here what has been stated in the judgment under review while dealing with the same contentions raised there. We cannot however, help observing that the failure to realize the distinction between the judicial service and the other services is at the bottom of the hostility displayed by the review petitioners to the directions given in the judgment. The judicial service is not service in the sense of ‘employment’. The Judges are not employees. As members of the judiciary, they exercise the sovereign judicial power of the State. They are holders of public offices in the same way as the members of the council of ministers and the members of the legislature. When it is said that in a democracy such as ours, the executive, the legislature and the judiciary constitute the three pillars of the State, what is intended to be conveyed is that the three essential functions of the State are entrusted to the three organs of the State and each one of them in turn represents the authority of the State. However, those who exercise the State power are the Ministers, the Legislators and the Judges, and not the members of their staff who implement or assist in implementing their decisions. The council of ministers or the political executive is different from the secretarial staff or the administrative executive which carries out the decisions of the political executive. Similarly, the Legislators are different from the legislative staff. So also the Judges from the judicial staff. The parity is between the political executive, the Legislators and the Judges and not between the Judges and the administrative executive. In some democracies like the USA, members of some State judiciaries are elected as much as the members of the legislature and the heads of the State. The Judges, at whatever level they may be, represent the State and its authority unlike the administrative executive or the members of the other services. The members of the other services, therefore, cannot be placed on a par with the members of the judiciary, either constitutionally or functionally.”
(emphasis supplied)
Fourthly, the argument that a uniform IoR would equate the district courts with constitutional courts is erroneous. A uniform multiplier is used for a uniform increment in pay and not for the purpose of uniform pay in itself. All Judges across the hierarchy of courts discharge the same essential function of adjudicating disputes impartially and independently. Thus, it would not be appropriate to apply graded IoR when SNJPC has chosen to uniformly apply the multiplier. 11 24. Separation of powers demands that the officers of the Judiciary be treated separately and distinct from the staff of the legislative and executive wings. It must be remembered the judges are not employees of the State but are holders of public office who wield sovereign judicial power. In that sense, they are only comparable to members of the legislature and ministers in the executive. Parity, thus, cannot be claimed between staff of the legislative wing and executive wing with officers of the judicial wing. This Court in All India Judges’ Assn. (II) v. Union of India, explained the distinction and held that those who exercise the State power are the Ministers, the Legislators and the Judges, and not the members of their staff who implement or assist in implementing their decisions. Thus, there cannot be any objection that judicial officers receive pay which is not at par with executive staff. In this context, it may also be remembered that Article 50 of the Constitution directs the State to take steps to separate the judiciary from the Executive.
29. This Court in its Review Order dated 05.04.2023 has explained this position in the following words: “7. It is not necessary to repeat here what has been stated in the judgment under review while dealing with the same contentions raised there. We cannot however, help observing that the failure to realize the distinction between the judicial service and the other services is at the bottom of the hostility displayed by the review petitioners to the directions given in the judgment. The judicial service is not service in the sense of ‘employment’. The Judges are not employees. As members of the judiciary, they exercise the sovereign judicial power of the State. They [2024] 1 S.C.R. 341All India J u d g e s A s s o c i ation v . U n i o n o f India & O r s not comparable with the administrative executive. They discharge sovereign state functions and just like the Council of Ministers or the political executive and their service is different from the secretarial staff or the administrative executive which carries out the decisions of the political executive, judges are distinct from judicial staff, and are thus comparable with the political executive and legislature. It would be wholly inappropriate to equate judicial service with the service of other officers of the State. The functions, duties, restrictions and restraints operating during and after service are entirely distinct for members of the judicial service. Consequently, the plea of equivalence has been consistently rejected in the judgments of this Court. We affirmatively do so again.
Allowances recommended by the SNJPC
19. We will now deal with each of the allowances as recommended by the SNJPC.
1. House Building Advance (HBA)
20. At the outset, it needs to be noted that the HBA forms a subject matter of the recommendations of the Seventh CPC, FNJPC, JPC and now the SNJPC. The SNJPC has recommended that :
(i) HBA shall be made available to judicial officers in terms of the House Building Advance Rules, 2017; and
(ii) HBA shall be available to judicial officers also for the purchase of a ready built house from private individuals subject to such are holders of public offices in the same way as the members of the council of ministers and the members of the legislature. When it is said that in a democracy such as ours, the executive, the legislature and the judiciary constitute the three pillars of the State, what is intended to be conveyed is that the three essential functions of the State are entrusted to the three organs of the State and each one of them in turn represents the authority of the State. However, those who exercise the State power are the Ministers, the Legislators and the Judges, and not the members of their staff who implement or assist in implementing their decisions. The council of ministers or the political executive is different from the secretarial staff or the administrative executive which carries out the decisions of the political executive. Similarly, the Legislators are different from the legislative staff. So also the Judges from the judicial staff. The parity is between the political executive, the Legislators and the Judges and not between the Judges and the administrative executive. In some democracies like the USA, members of some State judiciaries are elected as much as the members of the legislature and the heads of the State. The Judges, at whatever level they may be, represent the State and its authority unlike the administrative executive or the members of the other services. The members of the other services, therefore, cannot be placed on a par with the members of the judiciary, either constitutionally or functionally.” (emphasis supplied)
342 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports safeguards as may be prescribed by the State Government in consultation with their respective High Courts.
21. The Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, Government of India has issued an Office Memorandum12 dated 9 November 2017 providing for the payment of HBA. The recommendations of the SNJPC are based on the terms of this OM. However para 2(v) of the OM of the Union Government contains the following stipulation :
“5. Outright purchase of a new ready-built house flat from Housing Boards, Development Authorities and other statutory or semi-Government bodies and from registered builders i.e., registered private builders, architects house building societies, etc. but not from private individuals.”
22. The above clause in the OM indicates that the HBA can be availed of for the outright purchase of a new or ready built house or flat from public bodies as well as from registered private builders, architects and societies but not from private individuals. The SNJPC, in the course of its recommendations has observed as follows : “6. The Commission having given its consideration to the same is of the view that the HBA advance to the Judicial Officers shall be in terms of HBA Rules, 2017. However, the expression “but not from private individual” in Clause 2(v) needs to be suitably modified. It is quite possible that an individual may have purchased the house from the institutions/societies mentioned in the O.M. and if he subsequently intends to sell it and a Judicial Officer is inclined to purchase it. In such an event, the HBA may not be available to the Judicial Officer if Clause 2(v) is strictly construed. Further, quite often the Government servants/ officials as well as Judicial Officers would prefer to have ready built house and mere fact that the seller is a private individual should not be a good reason to deny the HBA on the terms set out in the Rules. It may be noted from O.M. that from registered private builders, architects, house building societies etc. purchase by a private individual is allowed. There is no good reason for exclusion of purchase 12 “OM”
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 343All India J u d g e s A s s o c i ation v . U n i o n o f India & O r s from private individuals. However, suitable safeguards to check any overestimation in the case of purchases from private individual can be evolved by the State Government in consultation with the High Court. “
23. The SNJPC has basically adopted the same financials as incorporated in the OM of the Union Government with the modification that the purchase from a private individual may also be permitted.
24. We are inclined to accept the modification particularly since the State Governments have been permitted to evolve suitable safeguards, to check any over estimation in case of a purchase from private individuals, in consultation with the High Court to ensure that there is not delay in implementation, we direct that the Committee constituted in terms of the directions issued in a later part of this judgment under the authority of every High Court shall sort out any difficulties which may arise in the implementation of the recommendations of the SNJPC as accepted by the present order.
25. We accordingly accept the recommendations of the SNJPC on the adoption of HBA.
2. Children Education Allowance (CEA)
26. The SNJPC has recommended the payment of the allowance with effect from academic year 2019-2020. The recommendation by the SNJPC on the payment of the CEA is in accordance with the recommendations of the Seventh CPC for Central Government employees which is in the following terms :
(a) Rs 2,250 per month as CEA and Rs 6,750 per month as hostel subsidy for two children up to Class 12;
(b) For children with special needs, the reimbursement would be at double the rate stated in (a);
(c) When the DA increases by 50%, the allowances and subsidy shall increase by 25%; and
(d) The rights of officers who are already receiving this benefit will not be adversely affected by the recommendation.
27. While arriving at the above rates for the CEA, the SNJPC has considered the fact that the judicial service has a pan India character. 344 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports In making the recommendation, the SNJPC has based the payment of the allowance of the CEA in terms of the OM dated 16 August 2017 of the Union Government in the Department of Personnel and Training. The payment of the allowance as recommended shall accordingly stand approved.
3. City Compensatory Allowance (CCA)
28. While recommending that the CCA be discontinued prospectively on the ground that it is not being paid to High Court or Supreme Court Judges after the Seventh CPC recommendations, the SNJPC has also directed that no recovery shall be effected on the amount already paid on account of the allowance.
29. We approve both the recommendation for discontinuation and the recommendation that no recovery shall be made.
4. Concurrent Charges Allowance
30. The SNJPC has observed that concurrent charge allowance is payable to officers who are required to hold full charge of the duties of equal or higher responsibilities in addition to the duties of their own post. The following recommendations were made by the FNJPC:
“a) The charge allowance be paid to the Judicial Officer when he is placed in charge of another Court continuously beyond the period of 10 working days and if he performs appreciable judicial work of that Court;
AND
b) The charge allowance be paid to such Judicial Officer at 10% of the minimum of the time scale of the additional post held.”
31. The SNJPC has made a similar recommendation for the payment of a like allowance where a judicial officer was placed in charge of another court continuously beyond a period of ten working days. The SNJPC was of the view that the Concurrent Charge Allowance with a ceiling @ 10% of the minimum of the scale of the additional post held beyond a period of ten working days is reasonable and does not require any upward revision. Moreover, it opined that with the [2024] 1 S.C.R. 345All India Judges Association v. Union of India & Ors revision of pay, the quantum of allowance at the rate of 10% is an adequate sum. The SNJPC observed that the actual amount payable within the ceiling of 10% depends upon the number of days worked, the quantum of judicial work turned out and the administrative work handled. Moreover, as was being done earlier, the High Courts would decide the amount payable having regard to the relevant factors. The SNJPC, however, recommended that the parameter of “appreciable judicial work” of the FNJPCis vague and involves a cumbersome process. That criterion has accordingly been dispensed with. The summary of the recommendations of SNJPC in that regard is set out below:
“1. The concurrent charge allowance to be available maximum at the rate of 10% of the minimum of the scale of the additional post held beyond a period of ten working days.
2. No upward revision in the percentage of the Concurrent Charge allowance.
3. High Court to decide the Concurrent Charge allowance to be available to the Officer within the ceiling of 10% on the basis of the number of days worked, the quantum of judicial work turned out and the administrative work handled.
4. The criterion laid down by FNJPC be dispensed with and there shall not be any insistence on the performance of ‘appreciable judicial work’ of the Court concerned. “
32. The recommendations made by the SNJPC is accordingly accepted.
5. Conveyance/Transport Allowance (TP)
33. As regards Conveyance/Transport Allowance, the SNJPC made the following recommendations:
(a) The pool car service for various judicial officers, as recommended by FNJPC, must be dispensed with. However, if the officers wish, they can forgo the transport allowance and continue with the pool car service for a period of one year or so;
(b) The transport allowance at the rate of Rs 10,000 per month be given to those judicial officers who own the car so as to 346 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports cover the cost of maintenance and driver’s salary and this will be increased to Rs 13,500 from 01.01.2021. The transport allowance would be payable at a reduced rate of Rs 4,000 per month in those States where there is an existing practice of allocating a driving-knowing office attendant/peon to the officer;
(c) In addition to the transport allowance, there should be a reimbursement of the cost of 100 litres of petrol/diesel in cities and 75 litres of petrol/diesel in other areas;
(d) After the recommendations of FNJPC, the following judicial functionaries were eligible for official vehicles, namely, Principal District Judge, Chief Judicial Magistrate/Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Principal Judge of City Civil Court and Principal Judge of Small Causes Court. In addition to these functionaries, three more judicial functionaries would be eligible for official vehicles, namely, Director of the Judicial Academy/Judicial Training Institute, Principal Judge of the Family Courts and Secretary of the District Legal Services Authority. The High Courts were permitted to prune down the list depending upon the financial capacity of the State;
(e) The quantum of petrol/diesel for official cars would be raised to the actual consumption for official purposes as certified by the concerned official and supported by a log book, which would be maintained. The judicial officers using official cars may be permitted to use them for private purposes to the extent of 300 kms per month;
(f) The judicial officers shall be permitted to exhibit a sticker at their option on the lower left side of the windscreen with inscription ‘Judge’ printed in moderately sized letters; and
(g) Soft loan facilities to the extent of Rs ten lakhs at nominal interest for the purchase of car shall be extended to the judicial officers.
34. The report of the SNJPC in regard to the payment of conveyance/ transport allowance is accepted. All concerned authorities shall take steps for the purpose of implementing the recommendations.
6. Dearness Allowance
35. By its order dated 19 May 2023, this Court has accepted the recommendation of the SNJPC on dearness allowance.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 347All India J u d g e s A s s o c i ation v . U n i o n o f India & O r s
7. Earned Leave Encashment
36. The SNJPC has recommended that the judicial officers be entitled to earned leave encashment in the following manner:
“9. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS
1. No enhancement in the maximum limit of 300 days leave encashment at the time of retirement.
2. A judicial officer shall be entitled to encash :
(a) 10 days earned leave while availing LTC subject to maximum 60 days – 10 at a time upto six occasions during the entire service.
(b) 30 days in a block of two years.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.