National Highway Authority of India v. G Athipathi and Others
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 943; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 520
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah
- Decided
- 9 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 14100/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 520 : 2024 INSC 943 National Highway Authority of India1 v.
G Athipathi and Others (Civil Appeal No. 14100 of 2024)
09 December 2024 [Sudhanshu Dhulia and Ahsanuddin Amanullah,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the criteria for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager in the appellant-authority; and whether the respondent has to be treated as a fresh entrant with the benefit of his past service on deputation or he has to be treated as a fresh appointee, from the date he was selected.
Headnotes† Service law – Promotion – Counting of deputation service period for promotion – Respondent repatriated to parent department after his deputation in appellant-authority for 6 years – Respondent re-joined the appellant on direct recruitment basis to the post of Manager (Technical) after a gap of 1 year – Thereafter, the appellant-Authority invited applications from the Managers for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager – Application of the respondent rejected due to minimum experience criteria of 4 years not being met – Challenge to – Tribunal directed the Authority to count the deputation service period for promotion and pursuant thereto, the respondent was appointed – High Court upheld the said order of tribunal – Correctness:
Held: Past services can be taken into consideration only when the Rules permit the same or where a special situation exists, which would entitle the employee to obtain such benefit of past service – Circular would not confer any legal right on the respondent for consideration for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) with effect from the date from which the tribunal directed the appellant-authority to promote 1 To be read as ‘National Highways Authority of India’. * Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 521National Highway Authority of India v. G Athipathi and O thers the respondent to the said post – Repatriation of the respondent back to his parent Department was on full time basis and unconnected with the appellant-authority – Respondent was a fresh and new recruit into the service of the appellant-authority directly to the post of the Manager (Technical), totally unrelated/ unconnected to his previous service with the appellant-authority, which transaction was complete and reached finality when the respondent was repatriated to his parent department – As he had been repatriated to his parent department more than a year prior to such permanent appointment, it cannot be termed ‘absorption’ which finds mention in the Clause 6 of the Circular – Respondent does not stand in the same queue in which other persons were, as they were working with the appellant-authority at the relevant time – Object of Clause 6 was to obliterate the difference between a person working on deputation and a person regularly working – Respondent was absent from the service of the appellant-authority not for any of the specific purposes, but on a permanent basis-being sent back to his parent department – In ‘fulfilling administrative formalities-submission/ acceptance of technical resignation/ retirement etc’ would not cover situation of respondent – Decision taken by the appellant-authority not to grant promotion to the respondent to be upheld – Respondent could not have been considered for promotion from the date of issuance of circular inviting applications to the posts of Deputy General Manager as per the direction of the tribunal since he had not completed four years on the post of the Manager (Technical) after having joined pursuant to direct recruitment on such post, on which service could only be reckoned from date of his appointment to the post – Impugned Order as also tribunal’s order cannot be sustained and set aside – Respondent to be considered for promotion in terms of the Recruitment Regulations and the Circular. [Paras 23-29] Case Law Cited National Highways Authority of India v. Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, 2016 SCC OnLine Del 2698; Indu Shekhar Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2006] Supp. 1 SCR 497 : (2006) 8 SCC 129 – referred to. List of Acts National Highways Authority of India (Recruitment, Seniority and Promotion) Regulations, 1996.
522 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Criteria for promotion; Post of Deputy General Manager; Benefit of past service on deputation; Fresh appointee; Promotion; Counting of deputation service period for promotion; Repatriation; Deputation; Direct recruitment; Post of Manager (Technical); Minimum experience criteria; Parent Department; Absorption; Minutes of the Executive Committee; Absent from service; Fulfilling administrative formalities; Permanent basis; Submission/acceptance of technical resignation/retirement.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No.14100 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 01.03.2023 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in WP No. 11060 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Santosh Kumar-I, Arjun Singh Bhati, Advs. for the Appellant. A. Lakshminarayanan, Adv. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J.
Leave granted.
2. Heard Mr. Santosh Kumar, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. A. Lakshminarayanan, learned counsel for the respondent no.1.
3. The present appeal arises from the Final Judgment and Order dated 01.03.2023 (hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned Order”), passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Madras (hereinafter referred to as the “High Court”) in W.P. No.11060 of 2021, whereby the appeal filed by the appellant was dismissed and the judgment dated 30.12.2020 rendered by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Chennai Bench (hereinafter referred to as the “CAT”) in O.A. No.310/01633/202W0 was upheld.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 523National Highway Authority of India v. G Athipathi and O thers
THE FACTUAL SETTING:
4. The respondent no.1 was initially working as an Assistant Engineer in the service of the Government of Tamil Nadu. The appellant, by an order dated 27.05.2008, appointed him on deputation basis as Manager (Technical) with effect from 21.05.2008, initially for a period of three years. He worked continuously for a period of six years till 13.06.2014, when he was repatriated to the parent department viz. the Highways & Minor Ports Department, Government of Tamil Nadu. In the meantime, an advertisement dated 15.03.2014 had been issued by the appellant inviting applications for recruitment to the post of Manager (Technical) on direct recruitment basis. The respondent no.1, on 11.04.2014, had applied for the said post after receiving approval from the parent department. Subsequent to his repatriation, he appeared in the written examination on 23.08.2014 and was selected as Manager (Technical) vide order dated 11.09.2014 by the appellant. On 26.08.2015, the respondent no.1 joined as Manager (Technical). The order of appointment of respondent no.1 was passed by the appellant on 02.09.2015 with effect from 26.08.2015.
5. The post of Manager (Technical) is the feeding cadre for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical). As per the Schedule appended to the National Highways Authority of India (Recruitment, Seniority and Promotion) Regulations, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as the “Recruitment Regulations”), promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) may be made from candidates holding the post of Manager (Technical) for a period of at least 4 years. As such, a Circular was issued by the appellant on 22.05.2017 (hereinafter referred to as the “Circular”) inviting applications from all eligible Managers (Technical) for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical). Clause 6 of the said Circular is extracted hereunder:
“6. It has also been decided to treat the deputation service (if any) rendered on the post of Manager (Technical) in NHAI as regular service for the purpose of promotion to the post of DGM (Technical). It has also been decided that the Manager (Technical), when found suitable for promotion, shall be promoted to the post of DGM (Technical) notionally with effect from the date they fulfil the eligibility criteria for the promotion, but not before the 524 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports date of absorption and the date of promotion of applicants in OA 3696/2014 and 3762/2014 i.e. dated 29.12.2014, subject to recommendations of the Selection Committee.
The actual promotion shall take effect from the date of assumption of charge against the post of DGM (Technical).”
6. The issue of considering deputation service as regular service for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) was deliberated on in a Meeting of the Executive Committee of the appellant held on 12.10.2017. The decision thereon, as recorded in the Minutes of Meeting dated 20.10.2017, is reproduced hereunder: “(c) As a strict one time measure and a special case, the deputation service (including period of absence from NHAI for fulfilling administrative formalities e.g. submission/ acceptance of technical resignation / retirement etc.) will be treated as regular service for the purpose of reckoning eligibility for the promotion to the post of DGM (Tech.), in respect of Managers (Tech.) who have subsequently been appointed in NHAI on Direct Recruitment basis as Manager (Tech.). This will also end prolonged litigation and ensure fairness and justice to the candidates who chose to face competition by going for direct recruitment.”
7. The respondent no.1 applied for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical). The Screening Committee of the appellant declared him ‘not eligible’. Accordingly, a promotion order dated 26.09.2017 was passed by the appellant in respect of thirty-nine Managers (Technical) to the posts of Deputy General Managers (Technical). Thereafter, the respondent no.1 sent Representations dated 18.06.2018, 22.11.2018 and 24.04.2019 to the appellant to consider his candidature. As no decision was taken on the same, he approached the CAT by way of O.A. No.310/00992/2019, which was disposed of vide order dated 26.07.2019. The CAT directed the appellant to consider the representations supra in light of the Circular and pass a speaking order within four months.
8. After considering the Representations of respondent no.1, the appellant vide order dated 05.11.2019 observed that his case may not be treated as similar to that of three other officers, since, those officers had appeared in the direct recruitment examination of Manager (Technical) while working in the appellant whereas respondent no.1 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 525National Highway Authority of India v. G Athipathi and O thers had taken the examination after his repatriation and was working in his parent department. Aggrieved, the respondent no.1 again approached the CAT by filing O.A. No.310/01633/2020 and praying: “To call for the records pertaining to the impugned Office Order No. 11041/242/2017-Adm.II (Pt) dated 05.11.2019 of the 4th Respondent and quash the same and direct the Respondents to count the applicant’s deputation service from 21.05.2008 to 13.06.2014 for promotion as Deputy General Manager (T) and to promote the applicant as Deputy General Manager as was done in respect of three similarly placed officers on and with effect from 27.10.2017 and as General Manager (T) with effect from 27.04.2018 along with all other services and monetary benefits including pay fixation, seniority, etc., and pass such further or other orders as the Hon’ble Tribunal may be deem fit proper under the facts and circumstances of the case and thus render justice.”
9. The CAT, after hearing parties and considering the material on record, vide order dated 30.12.2020 allowed the Original Application filed by the respondent no.1. It directed the appellant to count the respondent no.1’s deputation service period from 21.05.2008 to 13.06.2014 for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) and to promote him as Deputy General Manager (Technical) with effect from 27.10.2017 with all consequential benefits. The appellant was further directed to consider his case for promotion to the post of General Manager (Technical) as per rules. In compliance of the CAT’s order, respondent no.1 was promoted to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) on 07.06.2021. The appellant challenged the CAT order dated 30.12.2020 in the High Court through W.P. No. 11060 of 2021, which has been dismissed by the High Court vide the Impugned Order dated 01.03.2023.
SUBMISSIONS BY THE APPELLANT:
10. It was submitted by the learned counsel that the High Court failed to consider that as per the Schedule to the Recruitment Regulations, promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) inter alia, could be made by promoting candidates continuously holding the post of Manager (Technical) for a period of at least 526 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports four years. It was pointed out that the respondent no.1 joined the appellant on deputation basis and worked till 13.06.2014, when he was repatriated to his parent department. Thereafter, the respondent no.1 re-joined the appellant on direct recruitment basis to the post of Manager (Technical) on 26.08.2015 i.e., after a gap of 1 year and 2 months. It was argued that the service rendered by the respondent no.1 on deputation basis could not be considered due to this gap and in view of the same, he could be eligible for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) only after four years of service from the date of appointment on direct recruitment basis i.e., 26.08.2015. Thus, the respondent no.1 was ineligible for promotion as on 27.07.2017 i.e., the date from which the CAT has directed the appellant to promote the respondent no.1 to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical).
11. Learned counsel contended that the respondent no.1 and other candidates on deputation service on the post of Manager (Technical) cannot be considered equally for promotion to the post of Deputy General Manager (Technical) as, on the date of direct recruitment examination, i.e., 23.08.2014, the respondent no.1 was not incumbent as a Manager (Technical) as he was already repatriated to his parent department. Whereas, the three other candidates, with whom respondent no.1 claims parity, were continuing in the service of the appellant as on the date of the written examination for the post of Manager (Technical).
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.