Bherulal Bhimaji Oswal(D) By LRs. v. Madhusudan N. Kumbhare
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1035; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1875
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale
- Decided
- 18 Dec 2024
- Case number
- No. 14816/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1875 : 2024 INSC 1035 Bherulal Bhimaji Oswal(D) by Lrs.
v.
Madhusudan N. Kumbhare (Civil Appeal No(s). 14816-14817 of 2024)
19 December 2024 [Vikram Nath* and Prasanna B. Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(1) Whether the Respondent was guilty of medical negligence in the post-operative care of the Appellant; (2) Whether the Appellant's actions (changing his own bandage) contributed to the infection and absolved the Respondent of liability.
Headnotes† Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – Medical Negligence – Failed Cataract Surgery – Loss of Vision – Post-Operative Care – Expert Medical Opinion favouring the Appellant considered – No evidence available on record to shift the blame to Appellant: Held: The Appellant underwent cataract surgery performed by the Respondent – Post-surgery, the Appellant visited the Respondent five times within a week, reporting severe eye pain, oozing pus, headaches, and vision loss – Despite these complaints, the Respondent repeatedly re assured the Appellant that the surgery was successful and prescribed painkillers – Seeking further medical advice, the Appellant consulted two other doctors and was admitted to Wanawadi Military Hospital, where he was diagnosed with endophthalmitis (a severe eye infection) – Urgent surgery was performed to prevent potential brain damage, but the Appellant lost complete vision in his right eye – The Appellant filed a complaint before the District Consumer Forum, Pune, alleging medical negligence and seeking compensation – The District Forum dismissed the complaint due to lack of expert evidence – The State Consumer Commission of Maharashtra partly allowed the appeal, holding the Respondent guilty of medical negligence and awarding compensation of Rs. 3,50,000/- – The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) reversed the State * Author 1876 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Commission's decision, holding that the Appellant had changed his own bandage, leading to the infection, and thus, the Respondent was not negligent – That the Respondent failed to diagnose and treat the infection in the Appellant's eye despite multiple complaints of pain and vision loss – This Hon’ble Court rejected the NCDRC's finding that the Appellant's actions (changing his own bandage) caused the infection, noting that there was no evidence brought on record to support this claim – The Court restored the State Commission's judgment, directing the Respondent to pay the Appellant compensation of Rs. 350,000 within two months, with a 12% per annum interest rate applicable in case of default. [Paras 6, 8, 9, 15] Res-Ipsa-Loquitor – Loss of vision result of medical negligence in post-operative care – Corrective steps not undertaken causing loss of vision:
Held: The Appellant's severe post-operative symptoms and the Respondent's failure to diagnose or treat the infection indicated negligence – Held, that the negligence was evident from the facts and that the Respondent failed to detect the infection and clear the same in time despite several complaints by the Appellant – The infection was diagnosed by the three doctors at the Military Hospital, but it was too late by then and the Appellant had to undergo evisceration of his right eye leading to loss of vision – This was a blatant result of medical negligence by the respondent in postoperative care wherein corrective steps could have been taken, if the most reasonable and basic skills which were expected from the Respondent, were applied – Principle of Res Ipsa Loquitor applied. [Paras 18, 23] List of Acts Consumer Protection Act, 1986.
List of Keywords Medical Negligence; Eye surgery; Endophthalmitis; Cataract; Expert Medical Opinion.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s).
14816-14817 of 2024 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1877Bherulal Bhimaji Oswal(D) by Lrs. v. Madhusudan N. Kumbhare From the Judgment and Order dated 20.11.2018 of the National Consumers Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi in REVP Nos. 768 and 2443 of 2016 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ms. Pratiksha Sharma, Ramjeet Sharma, Ankit Acharya, Ms. Ritu Chaudhary.
Judgment/Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vikram Nath, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The instant appeals have been preferred against the judgment dated 20.11.2018 passed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission 1 in Revision Petition No. 768 of 2016 filed by the respondent herein along with Revision Petition No. 2443 of 2016 filed by the appellant herein, whereby NCDRC allowed the respondent’s revision petition, dismissed the appellant’s revision, set aside the order of the State Commission and consequently dismissed the complaint.
3. It would be relevant to state that during the pendency of this appeal, the complainant-appellant had died and the appeal is being prosecuted by his legal heirs who have been brought on record.
4. Brief facts of the matter are that the instant appellant is the original complainant/patient, a resident of Lonavala, who had developed cataract in his right eye and had approached the respondent i.e. the Opposite Party, 2 who is an eye surgeon, at his clinic in Pune on 11.01.1999. The respondent, after examination, advised an operation for removal of cataract in the right eye. The cataract operation was accordingly performed by the respondent at 8.00 pm on 19.01.1999 in Sushrut Hospital and the patient was discharged on the same night itself.
1 “NCDRC”, hereinafter 2 “OP”, hereinafter 1878 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5. The patient stayed in Pune overnight and on the very next day, i.e. on 20.01.1999, visited the respondent-doctor with complaint of severe pain in the operated eye and headache. The respondent changed the bandage of the operated eye, prescribed medicines along with eye drops and gave black glasses. The appellant was called back again on 23.01.1999 for checkup when the appellant, on his visit, complained to the respondent of intense pain in his operated eye. When the respondent-doctor removed the bandage and examined the right eye, the appellant could not even open his eye because of sticky fluid oozing out of his eye. The respondent-doctor replaced the bandages, assured the appellant that the operation was successful and prescribed certain pain killers and eye drops. At this stage, the appellant was also assured that his pain would subside and vision would be restored, and he was called for further checkup on 25.01.1999.
6. However, in the meanwhile, on 24.01.1999, the appellant was undergoing severe pain and headache and finally rushed to the respondent on 25.01.1999 wherein again certain medicines and painkiller tablets were prescribed by the respondent-doctor. As per the complainant, the condition of his eye worsened and the pain became unbearable, as a result of which he went to the respondent-doctor again on 26.01.1999 along with his wife and son. On the said date, the respondent again, after checking the eye, told the appellant that the eye was in good condition and called the appellant on the next day. On 27.01.1999, the respondent cleaned the appellant’s eye with cotton and when the appellant complained that he was unable to see anything, he was reassured by the respondent that his vision will be restored to normal in a few days. It was on the same day that the respondent, for the first time, advised the appellant to conduct the Blood Sugar Level test, which came out to be normal.
7. Even after taking the medicines prescribed by the respondent, the appellant continued to suffer from severe pain in the eye and headache which was getting progressively worse for his bearing. The complainant, on 27.01.1999 itself due to unbearable pain, contacted one Dr. Tasliwal, an eye surgeon from Yerawada, who further referred the appellant to another eye specialist named Dr. Chitra Khare. Dr. Khare checked the appellant’s eye and opinionated that the operated eye was completely damaged and if it is not removed in time, it may lead to further damage to the brain. Shocked on receiving such a medical opinion for the first time in previous couple of days, the [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1879Bherulal Bhimaji Oswal(D) by Lrs. v. Madhusudan N. Kumbhare appellant and his family hastened to seek a third medical opinion on the matter and contacted Dr. Nitin Prabhudesai, an eye specialist from Pune. After checking the appellant’s eye, Dr. Prabhudesai opined that there was a septic infection in the operated eye which has led to a complete damage and has to be removed.
8. Thereafter, the appellant, along with his relatives, ran from post to pillar for surgical removal of the infected eye and was finally admitted at the Military Hospital at Wanawadi on 29.01.1999 wherein he was diagnosed with endophthalmitis. Thereafter, an operation was performed for removal of partially extruded IOL through limbal section. As a result, doctors from military hospital succeeded in retaining the eyeball for cosmetic purposes but the appellant lost his complete vision from the right eye.
9. Aggrieved by the loss of vision, money spent on doctor visits and operation and the hardship caused in the entire series of unfortunate events, the appellant sent a legal notice, through his Counsel, to the Respondent for willful medical negligence and claimed compensation to the tune of Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten lakhs only). Subsequently, the appellant preferred Complaint No. 11 of 2000 before the District Consumer Forum, Pune inter alia contending medical negligence and praying for compensation of Rs. 3,50,000/- (Rupees Three lakh fifty thousand only) for loss of his vision along with special damages and interest on the amount.
10. The District Consumer Forum, vide order dated 19.10.2005, dismissed the appellant’s complaint mainly on the ground that the appellant has not filed any expert evidence or affidavit of Doctors of Military Hospital and has, thus, failed to prove that the respondent was negligent while performing the operation of the right eye.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.