Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar & Anr. v. Monika & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 911; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 954
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 29 Nov 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 10800/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 954 : 2024 INSC 911 Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar & Anr.
v.
Monika & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 10800 of 2024)
29 November 2024 [Dipankar Datta* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the correctness of the order passed by the Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court in treating the first respondent as qualified for consideration and consequent appointment; and whether the first respondent, in terms of the Advertisement, was eligible to be awarded half a mark (0.5) under the category of ‘experience’ vis-à-vis her engagement as outsourced manpower for the concerned time period, in light of the Rules and Circulars of the State as adopted by the University.
Headnotes† Service Law – Appointment – Selection process – Candidate, if eligible for marks under the category of experience vis-a-vis her engagement as outsourced manpower for the concerned time period – First respondent appointed under the Outsourcing Policy by service provider as clerk-cum-typist in the University, when no sanctioned post exists – Service provider awarded certificate of experience countersigned by the University – Thereafter, the University invited applications for direct recruitment to various Group-C (non-teaching) posts – First respondent applied and scored 75 marks in written test, falling short of selection – Claim of 0.5 marks for her experience for the service rendered when employed by service provider – Both the Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court held that the respondent was eligible for 0.5 marks for the service rendered – Interference:
Held: Refusal to award any mark for experience to the first respondent would go against the constitutional duty of ensuring equality and securing social justice for the deprived – Non-grant of mark for experience to the first respondent not proper and * Author [2024] 11 S.C.R. 955Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar & Anr. v. Monika & ors.
legal – It has not been shown that either the Recruitment Rules or the Advertisement specifically bars aspirants from securing marks for experience gained from contractual/outsourced employment – Primary concern is the nature of work performed by the candidate has any nexus with the purported work to be undertaken during the course of regular service – First respondent rendered service for a statutory body in excess of six months and thus, had valid claim for securing 0.5 mark for experience – It is not open for the University to now deny marks on the basis of a technical procedural deviation that the experience certificate was not issued by the University, but rather by the service provider – It is accepted that the certificate was per se not issued by the University, the fact that it was countersigned by the Head of the Department validates the first respondent’s claim that she had indeed gained certain experience which deserved to be given credit – First respondent, thus, cannot be denied the benefit of mark for experience merely because at the time of appointment as outsourced manpower, she was not appointed on a sanctioned post – It would occasion a failure of justice to exclude such individual – If said was the requirement, it had to be made explicitly clear in the Advertisement without any ambiguity so as not to generate false hopes in the minds of individuals aspiring for public employment – Any other view would be against both the principles of equality and nonarbitrariness enshrined in the Constitution as well as principles of natural justice – Tested on the touchstone of Arts. 14 and 16, the impugned decision of the University cannot sustain – Whenever a conflict arises between the powerful and the powerless, social justice commands the Courts to lean in favour of the weaker and poorer sections where the scales are evenly balanced – Thus, interference with the impugned judgment of the Division Bench not called for, though on different reasons – Constitution of India – Arts 14, 16. [Paras 20, 22, 25-30] Case Law Cited Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) [2006] 3 SCR 953 : (2006) 4 SCC 1 – distinguished.
Sachivalaya Dainik Vetan Bhogi Karamchari Union v. State of Rajasthan & Ors. (2017) 11 SCC 421; Dr. Kumar Bar Das v. Utkal University [1998] Supp. 3 SCR 315 : (1999) 1 SCC 453; Dr. (Major) Meeta Sahai v. State of Bihar [2019] 15 SCR 273 : (2019) 20 SCC 17; Union of India v. M. Bhaskar [1996] Supp. 2 956 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports SCR 358 : (1996) 4 SCC 416; P Kumaraswamy v. State Transport Appellate Tribunal, Madras [1976] 2 SCR 214 : (1976) 1 SCC 373 – referred to.
List of Acts Haryana and Punjab Agricultural Universities Act, 1970. List of Keywords Appointment; Eligible to be awarded marks of experience; Engagement as outsourced manpower; Outsourcing Policy by service provider; Sanctioned post; Service provider; Certificate of experience; Direct recruitment; Group-C (non-teaching) posts; Recruitment Rules; Advertisement; Contractual/outsourced employment; Mode of employment; Benefit of mark for experience; Security of service; Public employment; Principles of equality and non-arbitrariness; Principles of natural justice; Social justice; Constitutional duty; Non-grant of mark for experience.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 10800 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 06.12.2023 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in LPA No. 562 of 2022 Appearances for Parties Manu Mridul, Pratap Singh Rawat, Jitin Chaturvedi, Advs. for the Appellants.
Jayprakash Bansilal Somani, Nishant Verma, Rajnish Kumar, Manoj Kumar Chowdhary, Ms. Shisba Chawla, Ms. Ekta Verma, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
The A ppeAl
1. The present appeal assails the judgment and order dated 6 th December, 2023 passed by the Division Bench of the Punjab and [2024] 11 S.C.R. 957Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar & Anr. v. Monika & ors.
Haryana High Court at Chandigarh 1 in LPA No. 562/2022 (O&M), affirming the decision of the Single Judge whereby the first respondent was directed to be considered and offered appointment in the first appellant-Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University 2 on the post of Clerk.
The Question
2. The short question arising for decision in the appeal is, whether the Single Judge and then the Division Bench of the High Court were in error in treating the first respondent as qualified for consideration and consequent appointment.
Resume of facts
3. The relevant facts essential to decide the present appeal are as follows:
I. In 1970, the University was established upon enactment of the Haryana and Punjab Agricultural Universities Act, 1970. II. In 2009, the second respondent-State of Haryana 3 vide Circular No. 43/5/2001-IGSI introduced an outsourcing policy relating to engagement of persons on contract basis through service providers. 4 This circular was adopted by the University vide memo dated 24.02.2010.
III. In 2014, the SoH issued a further Circular bearing No. 43/5/2001-3GSII relating to issuance of experience certificates to persons engaged under the aforementioned outsourcing policy. This circular too was adopted by the University on 25.06.2014. 5 IV. In 2017, the University invited tenders for the purpose of providing manpower relating to office/hospitality and lab/ technical under Part I of the Outsourcing Policy. Vide Office Order dated 29.03.2017, the contract was awarded to two 1 High Court, hereafter 2 University, hereafter 3 SoH, hereafter 4 Outsourcing Policy, hereafter 5 Circular dated 25.06.2014, hereafter 958 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports service agencies by the University. The first respondent was engaged by one of the service agencies, namely, M/s Lavnya Enterprises, 6 to work as a clerk-cum-typist as outsourced manpower for the time period between 05.05.2017 and 31.03.2018 in the University.
V. A certificate of experience was awarded to the first respondent by Lavnya dated 01.04.2018. This certificate was countersigned by the Professor and Head of the Department of Soil Science of the University.
VI. Vide an advertisement, 7 the University invited applications for direct recruitment to various Group-C (non-teaching) posts. Under the criteria for selection, the advertisement prescribed a maximum of five (5) out of hundred (100) marks for ‘Experience’. It specified that half a mark (0.5) would be given for experience in the same or higher post in any department / board / corporation / company / statutory body / commission / authority of the Government of Haryana, for each year or part thereof which exceeds six months but limited to a maximum of ten (10) years.
VII. In pursuance of the advertisement, the first respondent had applied and offered her candidature. Admittedly, the first respondent scored 75 marks in the written test and was, accordingly, placed in Sl. No 103 and ranked Gen-92 in the merit list, and fell short of selection.
VIII. Aggrieved, the first respondent invoked the writ jurisdiction of the High Court by filing WPC No. 4402/2020 (O&M) 8 impleading the University, the SoH and two selected candidates as the first, second, third and fourth respondents, respectively.
IX. A Single Judge of the High Court by his judgment and order dated 24.05.2022 ruled that the first respondent was eligible for 0.5 mark for the service rendered by her between 05.05.2017 and 31.03.2018. As noted above, this decision was affirmed by the Division Bench.
6 Lavnya, hereafter 7 Advertisement, hereafter 8 Writ Petition, hereafter [2024] 11 S.C.R. 959Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar & Anr. v. Monika & ors.
Impugned Judgments
4. Since the first respondent had admittedly worked in the University for a period exceeding six months, her Writ Petition was allowed by the Single Judge directing allotment of 0.5 mark to the first respondent. The University was directed to consider her for appointment as well as to offer appointment, without disturbing any selected candidate. Aggrieved, the University carried the judgment and order allowing the Writ Petition in a Letters Patent Appeal. The Division Bench dismissed the appeal presented by the University on the ground that the order of the learned Single Judge does not suffer from any illegality, thereby leaving the University still aggrieved.
5. Having perused the judgment and order of the Single Judge, since affirmed by the Division Bench, we have found the judgment and order of both the writ court as well as the appellate court to be rather cryptic. Exception cannot be taken to any judgment merely on the ground of its brevity but if the judgment is cryptic and conclusions are reached without proper analysis of facts and materials on record, the party aggrieved would be justified in seeking setting aside of such judgment. It is, perhaps, for such reason notice had been issued by a coordinate Bench pursuant whereto the first respondent appeared; and, thereafter, the parties argued their cases fully. However, since focused consideration, due application of judicial mind and clarity of reasoning are the imperatives of a proper judicial decision, we have thought it fit to reflect on the issue arising for decision with the seriousness the same deserves.
Contentions
6. The impugned judgment has been assailed by the University on the grounds that:
I. Paragraph 1 of Part I of the Outsourcing Policy stipulates that services may be outsourced as and when required partly or completely by the departments where posts have not been sanctioned. Part II deals with engagement of persons on contract basis where the regular posts exist. In the instant case, the first respondent was deputed in one of the universities through a service provider under Part I of the Outsourcing Policy. II. Since the first respondent was engaged in the University by the service provider, Lavnya, under the Outsourcing Policy 960 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports for the requirements of office work and not appointed on any regular or sanctioned post of clerk, the experience acquired by her cannot be equated with the experience of working on a sanctioned post of clerk.
III. Considering that the post was not a regular or sanctioned post, the first respondent cannot be deemed to have gained experience of working in the same or higher post, as required by the Advertisement.
IV. Experience Certificate was not issued by the University but rather by Lavnya. Merely because it was countersigned by the Head of the Department does not make it a certificate issued by the University. Attention was drawn to the Circular dated 25.06.2014, which prohibits issuance of an experience certificate by any authority where persons are engaged through a service provider, i.e., under Part I of the Outsourcing Policy. V. The High Court overlooked the fact that the first respondent’s application described her engagement for the concerned time period as contractual employment and that her employer was the University, which is incorrect as the first respondent was neither appointed by the University nor ever worked with the University on any temporary or permanent post.
VI. The first respondent has not submitted the valid experience certificate issued by the department / board / corporation / company / statutory body / commission / authority of the Government of Haryana; therefore, the scrutiny committee has not considered the so-called experience of the first respondent and allotted her marks which is justified on facts and in the circumstances.
VII. The last candidate who was selected (securing 75 marks) is still 8 ranks higher than the first respondent. If the relief granted by the High Court is upheld, then the seniority of the appointed candidates will have to be disturbed. Moreover, the select list having been exhausted, the appointment cannot be given to the first respondent.
7. Based on these grounds, interference with the impugned judgment and order of the Division Bench was claimed by the University. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 961Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar & Anr. v. Monika & ors.
8. Representing the first respondent, her learned counsel contended that the judgment and order of the Single Judge is well-considered and well-reasoned; hence, it is unexceptionable and no interference is warranted.
9. It was further contended that:
I. The first respondent though had rendered services to the University on contract, she had done the work like other similarly situated persons working under either the outsourcing policy or on regular basis.
II. As per the Policy, the essential requirement of experience is that the candidate must be working in any department of the Government of Haryana irrespective of the mode of recruitment because government institutes can hire manpower in any of the two modes and in both the cases, work is done in the government department.
III. The University did not disclose the fact that the post of Clerkcum-Typist is a sanctioned post.
IV. Denying marks of experience to the first respondent is unreasonable, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14, 15, 16, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
V. The last candidate selected in the general category secured 76 marks and if the mark (0.5) for experience is granted to the first respondent, she would enter the zone of selection for appointment on the post of clerk.
VI. There are 13 posts lying vacant and the selection list is valid for one year.
VII. That in the case of Sachivalaya Dainik Vetan Bhogi Karamchari Union v. State of Rajasthan & Ors., 9 this Court upheld the policy of the State of Rajasthan for giving weightage to the services rendered by the employees, where services were used by the State either temporarily or on ad-hoc basis.
9 (2017) 11 SCC 421.
962 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports VIII. The University has also issued 2 nd Appointment List wherein, two candidates who have secured 75 marks have been selected and appointed for the said post, i.e., the third and the fourth respondent.
10. Learned counsel concluded by submitting that the University read words in the Advertisement to exclude the first respondent from the zone of consideration, which was rightly interdicted by the Single Judge and the Division Bench in its concurrent findings. As a sequel thereto, the appeal deserves outright dismissal.
Analysis And Reasons
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.