Ravikumar Dhansukhlal Maheta & Anr. v. High Court of Gujarat and Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 532; [2023] 5 S.C.R. 416
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.R. Shah
- Decided
- 12 May 2023
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 432/2023
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 416 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.[2023] 5 S.C.R. 416
RAVIKUMAR DHANSUKHLAL MAHETA & ANR.
v.
HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AND ORS.
(Writ Petition (C) No. 432 of 2023)
MAY 12, 2023
[M. R. SHAH AND C. T. RAVIKUMAR, JJ.] Judiciary: Higher judiciary – District judges – Appointment – Promotion of Senior Civil Judges to the cadre of District Judge – Rules 2005 prescribed 65% posts in the cadre of District Judge to be filled by promotion amongst Senior Civil Judges on the basis of principle of merit cum seniority and passing of a suitability test – Issuance of select list by the High Court for promotion of Senior Civil Judges to the cadre of District Judge (65% quota) – Petitioners not recommended for promotion even though having higher marks than the ones promoted – Writ petition by the petitioners challenging the select list as being violative of Art. 14 and r. 5 of the 2005 Rules – Issuance of Notice – However, despite being served with the copy of the petition, the State Government vide notification dated 18.04.2023 notified the appointment of 68 candidates, subject to the ultimate outcome of the writ petition – Held: High Court considered the merit only for the purpose of achieving the benchmark and thereafter switched to the seniority-cum-merit and thereby gave a go-by to the principle of merit-cum-seniority – Method adopted by the High Court contrary to the observations made by this Court in All India Judges’ Association’s case and also contrary to the 2005 Rules and the Recruitment Notice – High Court adopted a wrong method – Thus, the impugned Selection List issued by the High Court and the subsequent Notification issued by the State Government granting promotion to the cadre of District Judge illegal and contrary to the relevant Rules and Regulations and even to the decision of this Court in the case of All India Judges’ Association and Ors.’s case, thus, not sustainable – State Government could have waited till the next date of hearing by this Court – At present the respective promotees have not assumed their posting on the promotional post, they have been sent for training, thus, the further implementation and operation of the Select List issued by the High Court and the subsequent Notification issued by the State A B C D E F G H Government is stayed – Constitution of India – Arts. 14, 32 – Gujarat State Judicial Services Rules, 2005.
All India Judges’ Association and Ors. vs. Union of India and Ors. (2002) 4 SCC 247 : [2002] 2 SCR 712 – relied upon.
B.V. Sivaiah and Ors. vs. K. Addanki Babu and Ors.
(1998) 6 SCC 720 : [1998] 3 SCR 782; State of Kerala and Anr. vs. N. M. Thomas and Ors. (1976) 2 SCC 310 : [1976] 1 SCR 906; Shriram Tomar and Anr. vs.
Praveen Kumar Jaggi and Ors. (2019) 5 SCC 736 :
[2019] 6 SCR 590; Manoj Parihar and Others vs. State of Jammu & Kashmir and Ors. SLP (C) No. 11039 of 2022 decided on June 27, 2022; C.P. Kalra vs Air India (1994) Supp. 1 SCC 454; Hemani Malhotra Vs. High Court of Delhi (2008) 7 SCC 11 : [2008] 5 SCR 1066;
V.K. Srivastava and Ors. vs. Government of Uttar Pradesh and Anr. (2008) 9 SCC 77 : [2008] 13 SCR 24; Rajendra Kumar Srivastava and Ors. vs. Samyut Kshetriya Gramin Bank and Ors. (2010) 1 SCC 335 :
[2009] 15 SCR 936 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1998] 3 SCR 782 referred to Para 4.2 [1976] 1 SCR 906 referred to Para 4.2 [2019] 6 SCR 590 referred to Para 4.2 (1994) Supp. 1 SCC 454 referred to Para 4.4 [2008] 5 SCR 1066 referred to Para 4.9 [2008] 13 SCR 24 referred to Para 7 (ii)
[2009] 15 SCR 936 referred to Para 8.8 [2002] 2 SCR 712 relied on Para 8.2, 8.3, 8.4, 8.5, 9, 10 CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (C) No. 432 of 2023.
(UNDER ARTICLE 32 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA)
RAVIKUMAR DHANSUKHLAL MAHETA & ANR. v. HIGH
COURT OF GUJARAT AND ORS.
A B C D E F G H 418 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
Basant R., Sr. Adv., Purvish Jitendra Malkan, Ms. Dharita Purvish Malkan, Alok Kumar, Deepak Mani Tripathi, Nayan Gupta, Ms. Deepa Gorasia, Ajit Rao, Saudagar Singh, Ms. Rumii Chanda, Advs. for the Petitioners.
Dushyant Dave, S.V. Raju, Ms. Meenakshi Arora, Sr. Advs., Sandeep Kumar Jha, Aakshat Malpani, Nikhil Goel, Naveen Goel, Aditya Koshy Roy, Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, Vyom Raghuvanshi, Tushar Arora, Ms. VP Singh, Ms. Akanksha Rathore, Aditya Choksi, Arpit Gupta, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
M. R. SHAH, J.
1. By way of this writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India, the writ petitioners have prayed for an appropriate writ, direction or order to declare the Select List dated 10.03.2023 issued by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad for the promotion of Senior Civil Judges to the Cadre of District Judge (65% quota) as being violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India as well as Rule 5 of the Gujarat State Judicial Service Rules, 2005 (hereinafter referred to as “Rules, 2005”) as well as the Recruitment Notice – District Judge (65%) dated 12.04.2022.
2. The facts leading to the present writ petition in nutshell are as under:- 2.1 That this Court in the case of All India Judges’ Association and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors., (2002) 4 SCC 247, had directed that the recruitment to the Higher Judicial Services, i.e., the cadre of District Judges will be on the basis of principle of “merit-cumseniority” and passing a suitability test. This Court also further directed that the appropriate Rules shall be framed as above by the respective High Courts.
2.2 In pursuance to the above directions, the High Court of Gujarat has framed the Gujarat State Judicial Service Rules, 2005, in which, 50 percent of the promotion from amongst the Senior Civil Judges (Senior Division) has been enhanced to 65 percent by way of amendment in the Rules, 2005 on 23.06.2011. Rule 5(1)(i) of the Rules, 2005 requires that 65 percent of the posts in the cadre of District Judges shall be filled in by way of promotion from amongst the Senior Civil Judges on the basis of “principle of merit-cum-seniority and passing a suitability test”. A B C D E F G H 2.3 The High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad issued an advertisement by way of Recruitment Notice – District Judge (65%) dated 12.04.2022 for the promotion to the cadre of District Judges from amongst the Senior Civil Judges on the basis of the principle of meritcum-seniority and passing a suitability test to fill up 65 percent of the vacancies. The said Notification was issued alongwith list of 205 judicial officers in the cadre of Senior Civil Judges falling under the zone of consideration.
2.4 At this stage, it is required to be noted that in the Recruitment Notice itself, it was specifically mentioned that “promotion to the cadre of District Judge (65%) from amongst the Senior Civil Judges will be on the basis of principle of merit-cum-seniority and on passing a suitability test. In the Recruitment notice also, there was a reference to the suitability test, which comprised of four components for assessing the suitability of a judicial officer for promotion, which reads as under:- 2.5 Written test was conducted by the High Court on 16.10.2022. The High Court declared a list on 17.11.2022 of 175 judicial officers, who appeared in the written test and qualified the written test. The petitioners were also declared qualified in the written test. 2.6 The High Court on 18.11.2022 called upon the month-wise list of judgments disposed of, civil and criminal cases, of the candidates, who have been declared qualified vide list dated 17.11.2022. The High Court declared on 10.03.2023, the Select List of Senior Civil Judges. The marks of the selected candidates were ranging between 148.50 to 100.50 marks. The petitioner No. 1 secured 135.50 out of 200 marks RAVIKUMAR DHANSUKHLAL MAHETA & ANR. v. HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AND ORS. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 420 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
and the petitioner No. 2 secured 148.50 marks out of 200 and as though having higher marks, they were not appointed and/or their names were not recommended for promotion to the cadre of District Judge, the petitioners filed the present writ petition on 27.03.2023. 2.7 This Court issued the notice in the present writ petition on 13.04.2023 and passed a detailed speaking order, which reads as under:- “It is the case on behalf of the petitioner(s) that as per the Recruitment Rules, the post of District Judge is to be filled in by keeping 65% reservation on the basis of the principle of meritcum-seniority and passing a suitability test. It is submitted that despite the above while making the appointments vide Notification dated 10.03.2023, the merit-cum-seniority principle has been given go-by and the appointments are made on the basis of the senioritycum-merit. It is submitted that so far as petitioner no.1 is concerned, he has secured 135.5 marks out of 200 and petitioner no.2 has secured even the highest marks, i.e., 148.5 out of 200 and despite the above, the candidates who are having lower marks have been appointed.
Issue notice returnable on 28.04.2023.
Dasti service, in addition, is permitted.
It will be open for the petitioners to serve copy of the petition on the standing counsel for respondent nos. 1 and 2.”
2.8 Despite having been served with the copy of the present writ petition and though notice was made returnable on 28.04.2023 and pending the present writ petition, the State Government hurriedly issued the Notification dated 18.04.2023 notifying the appointment of 68 candidates, who were selected by Select List dated 10.03.2023, however, mentioned in the Notification that the appointments / promotions shall be subject to the outcome of the present writ petition.
3. Shri R. Basant, learned Senior Advocate has appeared with Shri Purvish Jitendra Malkan, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the writ petitioners. Shri S.V. Raju, learned ASG has appeared on behalf of the State and Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, learned counsel has also appeared on behalf of the State. Shri Dushyant Dave, Ms. Meenakshi Arora, learned Senior Advocates/ counsel have appeared on behalf of the respective promotees.
A B C D E F G H
4. Shri R. Basant, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the respective petitioners has vehemently submitted that the impugned selection / promotion to the post of District Judge (65%) vide selection list dated 10.03.2023 and the further promotion order dated 18.04.2023 issued by the Government of Gujarat is absolutely illegal and contrary to Rule 5(1)(i) of the Rules, 2005 as amended in 2011 as well as the Recruitment Notice – District Judge (65%) dated 12.04.2022. 4.1 It is submitted that as per the relevant Recruitment Rules and the Recruitment Notice, 65 percent of the posts in the cadre of District Judge shall have to be filled in by way of promotion from amongst the Senior Civil Judges on the basis of principle of merit-cum-seniority and passing a suitability test. It is submitted that despite the above, the High Court as well as the State Government have given the promotion by applying the principle of seniority-cum-merit and the principle of meritcum-seniority has been given a go-by. It is submitted that the petitioner No. 1 has secured 135.5 marks out of 200 marks and the petitioner No.2 has secured even the highest marks, i.e., 148.5 out of 200 marks and despite the above, the candidates who are having lower marks have been promoted.
4.2 On the principle of “merit-cum-seniority” and “seniority-cummerit”, the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioners has heavily relied upon the following decisions:-
(i) B.V. Sivaiah and Ors. Vs. K. Addanki Babu and Ors., (1998) 6 SCC 720;
(ii) State of Kerala and Anr. Vs. N. M. Thomas and Ors., (1976) 2 SCC 310;
(iii) Shriram Tomar and Anr. Vs. Praveen Kumar Jaggi and Ors., (2019) 5 SCC 736; and
(iv) Decision of this Court in the case of Manoj Parihar and Others Vs. State of Jammu & Kashmir and Ors., SLP (C) No. 11039 of 2022 decided on June 27, 2022.
4.3 It is further submitted by Shri Basant, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the respective petitioners that the method adopted by the High Court in preparing the Select List for promotion to the post of District Judge is absolutely illegal and just contrary to the Rules, 2005 RAVIKUMAR DHANSUKHLAL MAHETA & ANR. v. HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AND ORS. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 422 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
further amended in the year 2011. It is submitted that as per the High Court and so stated in the counter affidavit, explaining the procedure adopted for the selection of 68 candidates vide selection list dated 10.03.2023, it is stated as under:- “9. The suitability of candidate had for components which were duly reflected in the Recruitment Notice. The “Merit” eligibility required a Candidate to secure minimum 40% marks in each component with 50% marks aggregate. Upon achieving this, the final selection would be based on seniority. Accordingly, a select list of 68 candidates was prepared.”
4.4 It is submitted that by adopting the above method, the High Court has adopted the principle of “seniority-cum-merit”. It is submitted that the High Court by following the standard method of seniority-cummerit is to subject all the eligible candidates in the feeder grade (possessing the prescribed educational qualification and period of service) to a process of assessment of a specified minimum necessary merit and then promote the candidates who are found to possess the minimum necessary merit strictly in the order of seniority. It is submitted that though the High Court uses the nomenclature of above method as merit-cum-seniority, but actually has followed the principle of seniority-cum-merit. In support of his above submission, the learned Senior Advocate has heavily relied upon the decision of this Court in the case of N.M. Thomas and Ors. (supra) as well as in the case of C.P. Kalra Vs Air India (1994) Supp. 1 SCC 454. It is submitted that in the case of C.P. Kalra (supra), this Court has ruled that though the Rules in the said case mention meritcum-seniority, however, rules elaborately lay down method of senioritycum-merit.
4.5 It is further submitted by the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioners that as per the settled position of law, when promotion is to be based on “merit-cum-seniority” only, the basic qualified seniority has to be seen for eligible candidates and thereafter the selection for promotion has to be done on the basis of merit only. It is submitted that, however, the process adopted by the High Court and the State is in complete departure of the same. It is submitted that in the present case, the High Court has considered the seniority to be the least identified criteria for promotion, which cannot be sustained, if the principle of “meritcum-seniority” as provided under the Rules, 2005 is to be followed. A B C D E F G H 4.6 It is submitted that in any case, in the present case, the appointment in the cadre of District Judge is governed by the Rules, 2005 as amended in the year 2011, which specifically provides for promotion to the post of District Judge on the basis of principle of meritcum-seniority and passing a suitability test.
4.7 It is submitted that the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi in 2019 while making appointment to the Superior Judicial Services has followed the principle of merit-cum-seniority, by the same method, which the petitioners are praying before this Hon’ble Court to direct High Court of Gujarat to follow. Reliance is placed on the decision of the High Court of Jharkhand in the case of Writ Petition (S) No. 3771 of 2019 dated 29.06.2022. It is further submitted that the High Court of Calcutta has also followed the principle of merit-cum-seniority, by the same method, as petitioners are praying for. Merit-wise result of normal promotion-2020 to the cadre of District Judge issued by Calcutta High Court would go to show that the first 17 officers, who are in the merit, are selected and recommended for appointment to the post of District Judge.
4.8 It is submitted that from the Merit List produced by the High Court in the Counter Affidavit, it will satisfy that the petitioners ought to have been included in the first 68 candidates. It is submitted that if the High Court would have followed the principle of “merit-cum-seniority”, in that case, the petitioners would have been promoted to the post of District Judge being more meritorious and having more marks than the promoted candidates.
4.9 It is further submitted that even otherwise once the criteria for eligibility have been mentioned in the recruitment notice, namely, “merit-cum-seniority” and “suitability test”, thereafter, it was not open for the High Court and the State to include the additional requirement / qualification of seniority either during the process or after the selection process. Reliance is placed on the decision of this Court in the case of Hemani Malhotra Vs. High Court of Delhi, (2008) 7 SCC 11.
4.10 Making above submissions and relying upon the above decisions, it is prayed to allow the present writ petition.
5. A counter affidavit is filed on behalf of the State. The learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the High Court has submitted as under:- RAVIKUMAR DHANSUKHLAL MAHETA & ANR. v. HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AND ORS. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 424 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
(i) That the present writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India may not be entertained and the petitioners may be relegatedto first approach the High Court.;
(ii) That in the present case, the Select List was published on 10.03.2023 and the State Government was moved on the very day to issue necessary appointment orders.;
(iii) That in the present case, a Selection Committee was constituted for the purpose of 2022 selection. A feeder cadre of 205 Senior Civil Judges was created with eligibility of those who have at-least two years of qualifying service.
The list was uploaded on 12.04.2022 and the petitioners were enlisted in the said list.;
(iv) That the suitability of a candidate had four components, which were duly reflected in the Recruitment Notice. The “Merit” eligibility required a candidate to secure minimum of 40% marks in each component with 50% marks aggregate. Upon achieving this, the final selection would be based on seniority. Accordingly, a Select List of 68 candidates was prepared, which was in consonance with the decision of this Court in the case of C.P. Kalra (supra).;
(v) That the Select List was placed before the Full Court meeting and upon approval, was published on the website of the High Court on 10.03.2023.;
(vi) That the methodology, which has been followed by the High Court is being followed since the year 2011.;
(vii) That the methodology pointed out by the writ petitioners only points out to selection based on merit. It is submitted that once the feeder cadre includes the candidates who have just two years of experience and the only Marks Criterion is to be seen, the same becomes a selection based only on Merits giving a complete go-by to the principle of seniority.;
(viii) That in the present case, for the selection, merit is given preference in as much as senior candidates pave way for meritorious candidates, if at the first instance, they fail to A B C D E F G H qualify the suitability test and thereafter the remaining candidates fail to secure minimum marks in each of the components and fail to secure aggregate 50% marks out of total 200 marks. It is submitted that, therefore, once merit is determined, seniority takes over. It is submitted that, therefore, the principle of “merit-cum-seniority” has been followed.;
(ix) That the petitioners were aware of this procedure and participated in it without any demur. It is submitted that therefore, the writ petitioners are estopped from making the present challenge.;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.