Bhasin Infotech and Infrastructure Private Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Anr.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 260; [2023] 4 S.C.R. 1053
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dinesh Maheshwari
- Decided
- 17 Mar 2023
- Case number
- TRANSFERRED CASE (CIVIL) No. 82/2022
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v.
STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND ANR.
(Transferred Case (Civil) No. 82 of 2022)
MARCH 17, 2023
[DINESH MAHESHWARI AND J. K. MAHESHWARI, JJ.] Lease: Conversion of land from leasehold to freehold in view of policy formulated by the State – Entitlement to – On facts, allotment of commercial plots to the petitioner company by the State Industrial Development Corporation-UPSIDC, land allotted on 90 years lease basis – Building plan for construction over allotted land sanctioned – Construction completed and issuance of partial completion certificate – Thereafter, policy formulated by the respondent no. 1 for growth of tourism by setting up theme/ amusements parks – Policy laid down conditions and incentives, available to theme parks – Thereafter, proposal by the petitioner for recognition of its project as a theme based mall – Petitioner then sought conversion of the subject land from leasehold to freehold – Non-acceptance of the proposal of the petitioner to convert subject land from leasehold to freehold as per the policy formulated and thereafter amended – Challenge to – Held: When the land had already been leased to the petitioner and the petitioner is also holding the same as lessee under the lease deeds executed for the purpose, no reason, justification, logic or rationale that such leasehold rights be converted into freehold rights – Amended policy relied upon by the petitioner came into existence only after second completion certificate had been issued to the petitioner and, the mall had been put into operation – No stipulation found in the original policy or its amendment that it could be applied with retrospective effect and to override the existing legal rights as also the existing legal obligations - Policy in question with its amendment is of no application whatsoever in relation to the subject land and the project – Thus, the claim of the petitioner for freehold rights in relation to the subject land cannot be accepted – Furthermore, the petitioner seems to have developed a mall on the subject land through private investment and there is no participation of the State [2023] 4 S.C.R. 1053 A B C D E F G H 1054 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
Government or any public sector undertaking or any instrumentality of the State therein – Thus, the claim of the petitioner to seek benefits flowing from the Office Memo is struck down.
Disposing of the matters, the Court HELD: 1.1 The entire case of the petitioner-company, asserting its right to get the subject land converted from leasehold to freehold, is premised on the policy formulated by the respondent No. 1 on 06.11.2013 and amended on 03.05.2016. The petitioner would assume that the said policy with its amendment is applicable to its project and to the subject land. This assumption is without any legal basis and the claim of the petitioner turns out to be hollow and baseless because neither the original policy formulated on 06.11.2013 nor its amendment on 03.05.2016 have any application to the subject land or to the project of the petitioner. [Para 15][1088-F-G]
1.2. The subject land was allotted to the petitioner on 05.08.2006 after acceptance of its offer of allotment of the said industrial plot by UPSIDC. Clause 14(a) of the allotment letter dated 05.08.2006 had been clear and unequivocal that land was allotted on 90 years lease basis. Further, it was provided in clause 10(b) of the allotment letter that tripartite lease deed of the builtup premises would be executed where the allottee of the developer shall be the lessee; UPSIDC shall be the lessor; and the developer (the petitioner) shall be a confirming party. The lease deed dated 23.08.2006 in relation to 37208 sq. mtrs. of the allotted land carried the covenants, inter alia, that the lessee (the petitioner) will not, without the consent of lessor (UPSIDC), transfer, sublet, relinquish, mortgage or assign its interest in the demised premises or in the buildings standing thereon with the other requirements [vide clause 3 (j)]. It was also stipulated that the allottee shall have to abide by the general terms and conditions of allotment of UPSIDC [vide clause 13]. It appears that in this lease deed dated 23.08.2006, the stipulation regarding tripartite lease deed did not as such occur but the said clause 13 made all the general conditions of allotment binding on the petitioner. Moreover, in the other lease deed dated 30.03.2009 in relation to the adjacent plot of land, this stipulation was also inserted in A B C D E F G H clause 3(j). The Court is not entering into the questions relating to tripartite lease deed in this matter but, this much is apparent on a comprehensive look at the terms of allotment and the covenants of lease deeds that the land was allotted to the petitioner on 90 years lease basis and further treatment of land and built-up portion thereupon were to abide by those terms and covenants. It is also clear that possession of the entire parcel of land comprising the aforesaid two lease deeds, i.e., 40505 sq. mtrs., was handed over to petitioner on 31.03.2009 and on 08.10.2009, the building plan for construction over the aforesaid allotted land was sanctioned by respondent No. 2 whereafter construction over an area of 179017.82 sq. mtrs. was completed by the petitioner for which, a partial completion certificate was issued by respondent No. 2 on 07.05.2011. Until all this time, there was nothing existing as regards the policy sought to be relied upon by the petitioner. [Para 15.1][1088-H; 1089-A-F]
1.3. The policy in question came up for the first time only on 06.11.2013 and it was formulated essentially for growth of tourism sector in the State of Uttar Pradesh by setting up theme parks/amusement parks. The said policy dated 06.11.2013 laid down conditions and incentives, including exemption from stamp duty, exemption from tax on construction goods/materials imported into the State etc., which were available to the theme parks/amusement parks with minimum area of 300 acres and minimum capital investment of Rs. 500 crores. Clause 3 of the said policy, of course, provided that a theme park/amusement park could be established and operated by private sector, publicprivate partnership or any authority by creating special purpose vehicle and in that situation all the decisions regarding assessment of the desired land, selection of the private investor and implementation of the project were to be taken by the concerned authority/government body/public undertaking under its own rules but the Court is unable to find any correlation whatsoever of this stipulation of the policy with the subject land that had been given on lease to the petitioner as also with the project of the petitioner which could never be termed as any theme park or amusement park. Viewed in this light, the letter dated 31.01.2015 as sent by the Managing Director of UPSIDC,
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH A B C D E F G H 1056 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
recommending the case of the petitioner to declare its multiplex, hotel and commercial construction as tourist destination, turns out to be rather baseless and its accompanying document, stating the demand of the petitioner to convert the land in question to freehold, also appears to be wanting in logic. The project of the petitioner cannot be correlated with this policy dated 06.11.2013, meant for theme park/amusement park and that too with involvement of a Government body or an instrumentality of the Government in selection of the private investor as also with participation by way of investment upto 20% of the cost of the land. [Para 15.2][1083-G-H; 1090-A-E]
1.4. On 16.04.2015, respondent No. 2 issued second completion certificate in respect of the project of the petitioner. Even until this point of time, there was no amendment to the policy in question. As regards the amendment of the policy in question by way of Office Memo dated 03.05.2016, of course, the policy to promote tourism was modified so as to grant certain other concessions and was also expanded to include theme-based mall but then, such broadening of the policy came with typical and peculiar stipulations. A Committee was put in place for giving recommendations for permissions in the matters related with theme-based mall. Significantly, clause 4 of the original policy was modified in the manner that for theme-based mall, the limit of partnership of public enterprise/company of the State Government was changed from 20% of the maximum cost of land to minimum 20% of cost of land; and it was provided that the working agency will provide freehold to the SPV after acquiring the land as per the rules, for which freehold charge will be payable. These stipulations occurring in the said Office Memo dated 03.05.2016 make it more than clear that as regards theme-based mall a minimum of 20% of the partnership of the State Government or its instrumentality was stipulated; and such instrumentality of the State Government was also referred to as the working agency, which was to provide freehold land to the SPV to be created for the purpose. The petitioner seems to have developed a mall on the subject land and, as per the suggestions made in the referred communications, seems to have provided certain facilities to make it attractive but fact of the matter remains that the project has A B C D E F G H been implemented by the petitioner through private investment and there is no participation of the State Government or any public sector undertaking or any instrumentality of the State therein. That being the position, claim of the petitioner to seek benefits flowing from the Office Memo dated 03.05.2016 falls flat and is knocked to the ground. [Para 15.3 & 15.4][1090-E-H; 1091-A- C]
1.5. No SPV has been created in relation to the project of the petitioner with involvement of the State Government or any of its agencies/instrumentalities. Which particular agency is, then, to be termed as “working agency” for the purpose of the Office Memo dated 03.05.2016 remains a question inexplicable. If the stretch of arguments of the petitioner seeking freehold land is taken into consideration, only UPSIDC could be termed as “working agency” for the present purpose but then, there is no partnership of UPSIDC in this project. [Para 15.4.1][1091-D-E]
1.6. The subject land was specifically leased to the petitioner for a period of 90 years in terms of the allotment letter dated 05.08.2006 and then lease deeds were executed on 23.08.2006 and 30.03.2009. The construction was undertaken by the petitioner over part of the land in question where partial completion certificate was issued on 07.05.2011 and second completion certificate was issued on 16.04.2015. Several significant consequences follow from this status of record. In the first place, when the land had already been leased to the petitioner and the petitioner is also holding the same as lessee under the lease deeds executed for the purpose, there does not appear any reason, justification, logic or rationale that such leasehold rights be converted into freehold rights. Secondly, the amended policy which is sought to be relied upon by the petitioner came into existence only after second completion certificate had been issued to the petitioner and, as per the petitioner’s own assertions, the mall had been put into operation. No stipulation is found in the original policy or its amendment that it could be applied with retrospective effect and to override the existing legal rights as also the existing legal obligations. [Para 15.5][1091-F-H; 1092- A]
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH A B C D E F G H 1058 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
1.7 Viewed from any angle, even on direct construction of the relevant clauses vis-à-vis the subject-matter of the present petition, it remains beyond a shadow of doubt that the policy in question with its amendment is of no application whatsoever in relation to the project in question. Therefore, the claim of the petitioner has rightly been rejected. [Para 15.6][1092-B-C]
1.8. In relation to the relied upon letter dated 31.01.2015 sent by the Managing Director of UPSIDC, recommending the case of the petitioner to declare its multiplex, hotel and commercial construction as tourist destination, the same had been wholly baseless and rather unwarranted. Its accompanying document carrying the demands of the petitioner for various grants and exemptions as also for converting the subject land to freehold was also without any legal basis. At the relevant point of time, the policy in question only related to theme parks/ amusement parks and it is difficult to see even a logic that the said Managing Director chose to forward the proposition of the petitioner for consideration of the State Cabinet. In any case, the said letter dated 31.01.2015 was only recommendatory in nature; and even the recommendation had only been to declare the places as tourist destination and to give exemption. The Managing Director of UPSIDC could neither have recommended for converting the land to freehold nor did he do so. The said letter is of no relevance whatsoever. [Para 16][1092-C-F]
1.9. The letter/communication dated 16.09.2016, which had been a communication received by the petitioner from the Director General Tourism. The petitioner has described this letter as one of “approval” and has framed the relief in the writ petition on that basis. During the course of submissions too, substantial reliance has been placed on this letter/communication dated 16.09.2016 and the same has been termed as a letter of “approval/ qualification.” As would appear from the record, the petitioner addressed various communications on 12.12.2016, 30.05.2017 and 19.02.2018 to UPSIDC while asserting that the mall in question had already been declared as theme-based mall and the petitioner-company is entitled to get the subject land converted from leasehold to freehold. [Para 17][1092-F-H] A B C D E F G H
1.10. Whatsoever had been the composition of the Committee, it could have only made recommendation for final decision by the competent authority. Merely for presence of the Principal Secretaries of the Departments concerned in the Committee, it cannot be held that its recommendation itself would become a binding decision. Moreover, a close look at the said communication dated 16.09.2016 makes it evident that even the recommendation had only been to approve the proposal ‘as a theme-based mall.’ It is too far-stretched to read this communication as if the Committee had recommended for grant of freehold rights. Providing freehold land for the purpose of setting up a theme-based mall had entirely different requirements and had been of entirely different connotations under the amendment Memo dated 03.05.2016. In composition of the said Committee, there was no representative of the agency/ instrumentality directly concerned with the subject land i.e., UPSIDC. Any suggestion or recommendation in relation to the subject land as also the lease deeds already executed between the petitioner-company and UPSIDC could not have been made without taking into account the stand of UPSIDC. After passing of orders dated 20.10.2021 and 13.12.2021 by this Court in W.P. (Crl.) 242 of 2019, the matter was indeed examined by the Industrial Development Section-4 of the Government of Uttar Pradesh where the director of the petitioner-company was afforded the opportunity of personal hearing on 19.01.2022 through video conferencing and his further representation sent through email on 21.01.2022 was also taken into consideration while passing the impugned order dated 24.01.2022. [Para 17.1 & 17.2][1093-C-G]
1.11. Viewed from any angle, even on direct construction of the relevant clauses vis-à-vis the subject-matter of the present petition, it remains beyond a shadow of doubt that the policy in question with its amendment is of no application whatsoever in relation to the project in question. Therefore, the claim of the petitioner has rightly been rejected. The policy in question cannot be applied in relation to the subject land. Therefore, there is no necessity to delve further into the other issues raised on behalf of the respondent No. 2 that it has no policy to grant freehold
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH A B C D E F G H 1060 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
rights in its allotments. Suffice it would be to say for the present purpose that the claim of the petitioner for freehold rights in relation to the subject land cannot be accepted. [Para 15.6 and 18][1092-B-C; 1093-H; 1094-A-B] 1.12 The writ petition filed by the petitioner-company in the High Court is dismissed; and the first prayer in Crl. M.P. as regards directions for converting the subject land from leasehold to freehold, is also rejected. [Para 20][1094-D] CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Transferred Case (Civil)
No. 82 of 2022.
Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition No.3790 of 2022 in the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad.
Shyam Divan, Sr. Adv., Vishal Gosain, Viresh B. Saharya, Akshat Agarwal, Ms. Rudrani Tyagi, P. Sharma, Manoj K. Mishra, Mareesh Pravir Sahay, Advs. for the Petitioner.
K. M. Nataraj, ASG, Vinod Diwakar, AAG, A N S Nadkarni, Ravi Mehrotra, Ms. Meenakshi Arora, Devdutt Kamath, Sr. Advs., Chirag M. Shroff, Apoorv Srivastava, Ms. Ruchira Gupta, Ms. N. Shah, Ms. Deepti Arya, Ms. Harshita Sharma, Jogy Scaria, Garvesh Kabra, B. N. Dubey, Dhawan Uniyal, Ms. Ranjana Narayana, Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Mohammed Akhil, Shailesh Madhiyal, Sughosh Subramanyam, Nakul Chengappa K. K., Arvind Kumar Sharma, Suryajyoti Singh Paul, Rohit Singh, Gopal Jha, Gopal Prasad, Parijat Kishore, Guntur Pramod Kumar, Prem Prakash, Arjun Nanda, Sumeer Sodhi, Ravinder Kumar Yadav, Ms. Shuchi Singh, Krishna Kant Dubey, Vivek Kumar Pandey, Rakesh Kumar Tewari, Sanjay Kumar Dubey, Binod Kumar Singh, Aman Kumar, Ms. Nidhi, Sarthak Arora, Mohit Girdhar, Shree Pal Singh, Ms. Basuri Swaraj, Amit Sharma, Varun Chopra, Sriram Parakkat, Vishnu Sankar, Ms. Athira Nair, Aditya Santhosh, M/s Lawfic, Gaurav Sharma, Avinash Sharma, Abhinav Jain, Ms. Preeja Nair, Prakash Chandra Sharma, Rajeev Singh, Manoj K. Mishra, M/s. V. Maheshwari & Co., Sanjay Kumar Tyagi, Hitesh Kumar Sharma, S. K. Rajora, Akhileshwar Jha, Ms. Kavya S. Lokande, Ms. Niharika Dewivedi, Narendra Pal Sharma, C. M. Jha, Ms. Manju Jetley, Mrs. Swarupama Chaturvedi, Varun K. Chopra, M/s. Vkc Law Offices, Dr. Monika Gusain, S. K. Verma, Vishal Prasad, Shree Prakash Sinha, Rakesh Mishra, Ms. Mohua Sinha, A B C D E F G H Nawalendra Kumar, Rishabh Gupta, Shekhar Kumar, Himanshu Bhushan, J. B. Pathak, Kumar Mihir, Ms. Garima Bajaj, Raghavendra Mohan Bajaj, Vivek Narayan Sharma, Mohit D. Ram, Anish R. Shah, Krishnamohan K., Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.
1. In this transferred case, registered on withdrawal of a writ petition filed by the petitioner in the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Writ Petition No. 3790 of 2022) to this Court, the petitioner-company has challenged the order dated 24.01.2022 issued by respondent No. 1 in not accepting its proposal to convert the subject land from leasehold to freehold as per the policy formulated on 06.11.2013 and amended on 03.05.2016.
2. In the writ petition so filed in the High Court and transferred to this Court, the petitioner has sought the reliefs in the following terms: - “a. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari quashing the impugned order dated 24.01.2022 passed by Respondent No.1 (Annexure-11) to the writ petition and directing the Respondent No.2 to grant freehold plot no. SH-3, Surajpur Site-IV in the light of approval dated 16.09.2016 extending benefits of Government Orders dated 06.11.2013 and 03.05.2016.
b. To pass such other and further order, which this Hon’ble court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the present case. c. Award the cost of the present petition to the Petitioner.”
3. The relevant background and factual aspects leading to this writ petition and its transfer to this Court could be taken into comprehension as follows1:
3.1. On 05.08.2006, the petitioner-company’s offer (bid) for allotment of commercial Plot No. SH-3 in Industrial Area Site-IV, Surajpur, District Gautam Budh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh with approximate 1 The extractions herein are essentially taken from IA No. 15392 of 2022 and IA No. 156279 of 2022 filed by the petitioner for placing on record the English translation of the documents sought to be referred, as also from the documents filed with the writ petition.
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH A B C D E F G H 1062 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
area 37500 sq. mtrs. came to be accepted by the Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation2-3 and, accordingly, the allotment letter was issued in favour of the petitioner stating the terms and conditions of this allotment, including that the land was being allotted on 90 years lease basis. A few relevant stipulations in this allotment letter dated 05.08.2006 read as under: - “ **** **** ****
9. The Possession of Land will be handed over/delivered to you after payment of 25% of total amount (as per bid) and after Execution of Lease Deed with the Corporation. The allottee/ Developer will have to take possession after execution of lease deed within three months from the date of allotment letter failing which plot is liable to cancelled.
10. a. The allottee shall have the right to sell of the built up portion to any person for its choice for first such transfer no levy shall be charged by UPSIDC.
b. The triparite Lease Deed of the built-up premises shall be executed by UPSIDC Ltd., with the ultimate allottees of Developer on the request of the developer in writing.
In Triparite lease deed, the allottee of developer shall be the lessee, the UPSIDC Ltd., will be the lesser and the developer shall be a confirming party.
The UPSIDC will be transferring the proportionate undelivered interest in the land while the developer will be transferring the interest in the built-up space.
c. The Lease Deed of a built-up space will be executed only after the corporation has given completion certificate. For that built up space.
**** **** ****
14. (a) The land is allotted on 90 years lease basis which has to be specified to its tenants/Co./Owners 2 ‘UPSIDC’, for short.
3 This Corporation is now known as Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Authority (‘UPSIDA’, for short) and is impleaded as respondent No.2 as such. However, for continuity of discussion herein, respondent No. 2 is also referred to as ‘UPSIDC’. A B C D E F G H
(b) The Lease Deed will be executed by the corporation directly with the various persons on the recommendation made by you without any transfer charges. On the subsequent transfer of the premises/plot, levy as per the prevailing rules of the corporation at that time will be charged.
**** **** ****
3.2. It appears that the actual measurement of the land so allotted stood at 37208 sq. mtrs. and lease deed was executed in favour of the petitioner on 23.08.2006 with reference to this actual measurement. A few relevant clauses of this lease deed dated 23.08.2006 could be usefully reproduced as under: - “3. AND THE LESSEE DOTH HEREBY COVENANTS WITH
THE LESSOR AS UNDER:
…..
(j) That the Lessee will not without the previous consent in writing of the Lessor, transfer, sublet, relinquish mortgage or assign its interest in the demised premises or buildings standing thereon or both as a whole and every such-transfer, assignment, relinquishment mortgage or subletting or both shall be subject to and the transferees or assigns shall be bound by all the covenants and conditions herein contained and be answerable to the Lessor in all respects therefore, and the Lessee will in no case assign, relinquish, mortgage, sublet, transfer or part with the possession of any portion less than the whole of the demised premises or cause any sub-division thereof by metes and bound or otherwise.
Provided that the joint possession or transfer of possession of demised premises or any part thereof by the Lessee shall be deemed to be sub-letting for the purpose of this clause.
**** **** ****
8. (a) The Allottee shall have to get building approved from UPSIDC Ltd. and development works have to be undertaking as per approved plan.
(b) The FAR and ground coverage shall be allowed as per the rules and bye-laws of the UPSIDC Ltd.
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1064 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
whose prior sanction on Building Plan shall be sought by allottee at its own cost before making any construction.
(c) The land shall be allotted on “as it where it is”
UPSIDC will not responsible for carrying out any development at any stage except existing development like Roads and Strom water drainage.
(d) All works shall be completed in 05 years from the date of allotment. Any further extension shall be as per terms decided by MD, UPSIDC.
(e) The allottee will have to pay Lease Rent from the date of Allotment.
9. The allottee shall have to right to sell of the built portion to any person for its choice for first such transfer no levy shall be charged by UPSIDC.
10. In case of any dispute between Corporation and Allottee/ Developer, the decision of Managing Director, UPSIDC Ltd., shall be final and binding on both the parties.
11. The Corporation will have no objection on the request made by Bidder Company for allowing them 1.8 FAR with 60% ground coverage subject to the approval of the same by UPSIDC Ltd.
12. The allottee shall obtain completion certificate from UPSIDC.
13. Allottee will have to abide by general terms and conditions of Allotment of UPSIDC and also to observe the laws & other rules and regulation carry out any specific activity from appropriate Govt. bodies before undertaking such activities. Failure to do so may result in Cancellation of allotment of the whole plot or part thereof as UPSIDC deems fit. .……”
3.3. In addition to the aforesaid allotted parcel of land, another adjacent plot admeasuring 3297 sq. mtrs. was also allotted in favour of the petitioner, and another lease deed for this additional parcel of land was executed on 30.03.2009. The relevant clause of the said lease deed reads as under: - A B C D E F G H “3. AND THE LESSEE DOTH THEREBY COVENANTS
WITH THE LESSOR AS UNDER:
**** **** ****
(j) (a) The allottee shall have the right to sell of the builtup portion to any person for its choice for first such transfer no levy shall be charged by UPSIDC.
(b) The triparite lease deed of the built-up premises shall be executed by the UPSIDC LTD., with the ultimate allottees of Developer on the request of the developer in writing.
In triparite lease deed, the allottee of developer shall be the lessee, the UPSIDC Ltd., will be lessor and the developer shall be a confirming party. The UPSIDC will be transferring the proportionate undelivered interest in the land while the developer will be transferring the interest in the built-up space.
(c) The Lease Deed of the built-up space will be executed only after the corporation has given completion certificate. For that built up space.
……”
3.4. Thereafter, possession of the entire parcel of land comprising the aforesaid two lease deeds, i.e., 40505 sq. mtrs., was handed over to petitioner on 31.03.2009. Then, on 08.10.2009, respondent No. 2 sanctioned the building plan for construction over the aforesaid allotted land and pursuant thereto, construction over an area of 179017.82 sq. mtrs. in respect of Basement -1, Basement -2, Ground Floor, First Floor and Second Floor was completed for which, a partial completion certificate was issued by respondent No. 2 on 07.05.2011.
3.5. In the chronology of relevant events, it so happened that in the year 2013, respondent No. 1 formulated a policy for growth of tourism sector in the State of Uttar Pradesh by setting up theme parks/amusement parks. The aforesaid policy dated 06.11.2013 laid down conditions and incentives, including exemption from stamp duty, exemption from tax on construction goods/materials imported into the State etc., which were available to the theme parks/amusement parks with minimum area of 300 acres and minimum capital investment of Rs. 500 crores. The said
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1066 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
policy of the respondent No. 1, essentially to promote tourism in the State, as spelt out in the communication dated 06.11.2013 from the Secretary concerned to all the Principal Secretaries and other officers of the Government of Uttar Pradesh, reads as under: - “Subject: To promote tourism in the state To decide the policy for setting up theme park/amusement park etc.
Sir, tourism industry is not covered by the State’s Establishment and Industrial Investment Policy-2012. In this sequence, I have been directed to say that in view of the need to set up an amusement park in the state for the purpose of Encourage the Tourism, a policy has been laid down for the establishment of theme park/ amusement park etc. after dueconsideration, It has been decided. The above policy is as follows:
1. Theme Park I Amusement Park etc. will be set up under the Uttar Pradesh Town Planning and Development Act, 1973 and various planning Acts in accordance with the prescribed procedure for agricultural land use. For this, necessary provisionsIamendments will be made in the Zoning Regulations for the establishment of theme parks I amusement parks in the proposed agricultural land use in the master plans of the notified areas under various planning acts.
2. Large projects like theme parks/amusement parks have high initial capital investment and become profitable only after a long period of time and a large number of local people are employed in such projects, so incentives are given to encourage such projects, decision has been taken. In the light of the above, the following incentives are allowed in respect of large projects of theme park /amusement park etc.:
(1) Purchase or lease of land for the project from the StateI Central Government or its owned corporation, council, company, institution 100% exemption in stamp duty will be given on taking it.
(2) For the construction period or 10 years (whichever is less) for the establishment of the project, 100% exemption will be given in the tax on the construction goods/materials imported into the state.
(3) From the date of operation of the project, 100% exemption in entertainment tax will be provided for 10 years.
A B C D E F G H
(4) For the year from the date of operation of the project, 100% exemption will be given in the pleasure tax.
The above incentives will be admissible to only those theme park/ amusement park projects, whose minimum area is 300 acres and in which the minimum capital investment is Rs. 500.00 crores.
3. Theme Park/Amusement Park can be established and operated by private sector, PPP or any authority by creating an S.P.V. In such a situation, all the decisions regarding the assessment of the desired land, the selection of the private investor and the implementation of the project after the selection will be taken by the concerned authority/government body/public undertaking under its own rules.
4. Participation in such a scheme can be done by any public undertaking of the state government/S.P.V. or company. This participation will be limited to a maximum of 20 percent of the cost of the land required for the project of Theme Park/ Amusement Park, which will continue till the completion of the project. The concerned government body/establishment/ public undertaking will spend its share capital (20 percent) as a partner of SPV, first on land acquisition, so that the investor can be assured of the availability of land. Only after that Capital investment will be decided. After the completion of the project, the disinvestment will be done as per the pre-determined agreement.
5. Under the proposed theme parkIamusement park, all the development, display, buildings and activities, etc. will be based on a central theme or theme, and depending on the theme, there should be different types of theme parks at different places. Theme ParkIAmusement Park will have a minimum area of 300 acres and can be established at such sites, where there is a facility of access from major roads (such as national highways, expressways, etc.) and water supply, drainage, ‘solid waste disposal’ for the selected site. And proper arrangement of power supply should be available.
(a) Under the theme parkIamusement park, in addition to the basic works related to the theme park, other activities such as convention center, hotel, shopping complex, restaurant, film studio, multiplex, senior shop, workshop, accommodation
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1068 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
for employees etc. will be included. The permission for theme parkIamusement park will be normally payable in the proposed agricultural land use in the master plans of the notified areas under various planning acts in the state, for which necessary provisionI amendment will be made in the master plan, zoning regulations of urban areas and industrial areas. Theme ParkIAmusement Park can also be established in the agricultural area outside the Master PlanNotified Area, for which there will be UPSIDC Regulatory Authority.
(b) Under Theme ParkIAmusement Park, activities related to theme parkIentertainment will be allowed in minimum 75 percent area, while mixed use (such as residential, commercial, institutional, community and public facilities, etc.) will be allowed on maximum 25 percent part. The average FAR for the theme park is 0.5 over the entire plan area. And 20 percent ground coverage will be admissible.
(c) DPR of Theme ParkIAmusement Park. And the integrated layout plan will be approved by the concerned government agency. The internal and external development work of the project will be done by the developer himself. In view of the above, development fee will not be payable by the developer to the government agency.
6. In the event of the implementation of the theme park project being done through the process of PPP/SPV, application for approval of the layout of the theme park project and building plan etc. For the construction and operation of the theme park, S.P.V. or P.P.P. will be done with the prior permission of the government partner.
7. The said policy of theme park will be applicable in the entire state. Development Authorities have been established under the Uttar Pradesh Town Planning and Development Act-1973 and Uttar Pradesh Industrial Area Development Act-1976. Therefore, instructions will be issued to the subordinate development authorities and public undertakings by the Housing and Urban Planning Department and the Department of Infrastructure and Industrial Development to implement the policy of the above theme parkIamusement park.
A B C D E F G H
8. Hon’ble Chief Minister has been authorized to take necessary decisions to implement the above proposed policy.”
3.6. In view of the aforesaid policy dated 06.11.2013, petitioner made a request to respondent No. 2 to recognise the project land as tourist destination whereupon, the Managing Director of UPSIDC wrote a letter dated 31.01.2015 to Principal Secretary (Tourism), Government of Uttar Pradesh, recommending that the said project of the petitioner be declared as tourist destination and be provided with necessary exemption. It was further stated that probably, the final decision on the subject shall be taken by the State Cabinet and hence, the necessary material for its consideration was also enclosed. The said letter dated 31.01.2015 reads as follows: - “Investment of about Rs. 800 crores by Bhasin Infotech & Infrastructure Pvt Ltd on Plot No. SH-2 of Surajpur Site-4 Greater Noida, Industrial Area of Corporation while doing the construction of a multiplex commercial and hotel in the name of Grand Venice, which has been greatly appreciated by the tourism point of view. On the request of the developer company, investment of more than Rs. 500 crores and employment availability and for the purpose of promoting tourism and in order to make their project run smoothly, it is recommended to declare the place as a tourist destination, to give exemption to them. Possibly the level of the above decision will be of the State Cabinet, so the necessary material is being enclosed for the cabinet note.
Therefore, it is kindly requested to take necessary action on the above.”
3.6.1. We may also take note of a document placed on record with IA No. 156279 of 2022, said to be the part of material sent with the aforesaid letter dated 31.01.2015. It seems to be the justification in making the recommendations aforesaid and reads as under: - “IN CONNECTION WITH DECLARING THE GRAND
VENICE (GREATER NOIDA, GAUTAM BUDDHA
NAGAR) AS A TOURIST DESTINATION,
A commercial plot allotted by Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation to M/s Bhasin Infotech & Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Multiplex, Commercial and Hotel has been constructed
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1070 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
by investing about Rs. 800.00 crores, which will provide employment to about 5000 people. The Grand Venice is a very timely and convenient place from the point of view of tourism. The Grand Venice has been developed by the developer to attract international and domestic tourists in such a way that its unique architecture, entertainment and geography and community will be the only place to visit. It is conveniently located near Greater Noida Express Way and due to its special location, it will also become a suitable destination for tourists going from Delhi to Agra. In this project, special care has been taken for educational tourism while presenting something to the tourists of all age groups and preferences. An attempt has been made by the developer to embellish the grandeur and elegance of the famous Italian city of Venice in The Grand Venice. This Venetian themed remoteness hub will prove to be a center of special attraction with stunning structures and sculptures. A ride on the Gondola in the water canals built inside Mall will provide a real experience of doing the traditional Gondola fanciers walking along the beautiful waterways of the city of Venice. Similarly, through Magic Sky, an attempt has been made to provide the experience of walking under the virtual sky giving a glimpse of the environment and weather and the unique environment. In The Grand Venice, the famous unique feature of Venice is the Fountain de Trevi, Julius Caesar’s Statue, Light House, Pisa’s Tower and other art forms of ltaly have been presented. Along with this, the Indian Sea world has also been displayed in an area of about 100000 square feet and for the convenience of the tourists, the five-star deluxe Sheraton Hotel with 270 rooms has also been included in this complex. Places have been identified for setting up ·of outlets to display the heritage and handicrafts of Uttar Pradesh, along with the above features, the project like promotion of tourism and providing employment to 5000 people along with capital investment of more than 500 crore rupees. Special benefits such as tax exemption, grant, establishment of electric friendly metro station, freehold without fee and suggestions for setting up of outlets for displaying the heritage and handicrafts of Uttar Pradesh and declaring tourist places by the developer to operate as demand is being made. Under which A B C D E F G H Freehold: The plot has been allotted on lease by the corporation. The developer has demanded convert this land to freehold without any charges.
TAX Exemption: The developer of the Mall demanded exemption from entertainment tax and GST in this project which is applicable to Hotel, Aquarium, Retail etc.
Grant The developer has invested more than Rs. 500.00 crore in the tourism sector in this project, so a demand for a grant of 5 percent interest has been made.
Electricity: The developer has demanded to provide the additional power required in the project without any load. Metro Station: There has been a demand to extend the proposed Pari Chowk metro station to the project site by the developer, whose distance is only 1.5 km.
Time Extension Fee: The developer has demanded to waive off the time extension fee charged by UPSIDC due to delay in the project. It is recommended to accept the demands being made by the developer due to the project being Ideal for benefits like regional development, promotion of tourism and providing more number of jobs. As above, the proposal is placed before the Cabinet Committee for perusal and approval.”
3.7. Subsequently, on 16.04.2015, respondent No. 2 issued second completion certificate in respect of the project of the petitioner.
3.8. Later, respondent No. 1 issued one Office Memo dated 03.05.2016, making a few alterations in the aforesaid policy dated 06.11.2013, including that theme-based mall was also included in the extensive scheme and UPSIDC was appointed as the nodal agency for implementation of the policy in the State. However, various other stipulations were also provided, which were significantly different than the stipulations in the original policy. The relevant contents of the said Office Memo dated 03.05.2016, useful for the present purpose, are as follows: - “OFFICE MEMO That with regard to promote the tourism, to increase the investment of funds and in view of importance of the extensive schemes
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1072 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
related with the establishment of theme park/amusement park, the policy has been proclaimed for establishment of theme park/ amusement park vide Office Memo No.3150/41-2013-37 Y0/2012 dated 06.11.2013. For implementation of the abovesaid policy, for implementation of theme park in Agra, UPSIDC has been nominated as Nodal Agency.
2. That the following amendments are being made in Para No.2 of the abovesaid extensive policy in view of relevant amendments for successful implementation of the policy and proposed amendments vide Letter No.5257 /P.S.M.S./JAIN/2015 dated 20.05.2015 of the Hotel and Restaurants Owners Association, Agra and vide Letter No.318-319, SIDC dated 02.12.2015 of the Nodal Agency UPSIDC for further proceedings in the Theme Park in Agra:
A(1) That hundred percent concession in stamp duty shall be kept as it is in respect of transfer of land related with the project either purchased or taken on lease from State/Central Government or from the Corporation, Council, Company under their ownership.
(2) That hundred percent concession will be provided for building material/items imported in the state for 10 years or the construction period (whichever is less) to be used for construction and establishment of the project.
(3) That hundred percent concession will be granted in entertainment tax for implementation of the project for 15 years from the date of operation of the project.
(4) That hundred percent concession will be provided in the facilities for 15 years from the date of operation of the project.
(5) Theme based Mall is also included in the extensive scheme and relaxation is given in respect of limitation of 300 Acres of minimum land as mentioned in Para No.2 for the matter related with the theme-based Mall. For giving recommendations to the permissions in the matter related with the theme-based Mall, a Committee will be formed as follows in the leadership of the Principal Secretary, Tourism.
1. Principal Secretary/Secretary Tourism Department, President.
A B C D E F G H
2. Principal Secretary/Secretary, Cultural Department, Member.
3. Principal Secretary, Secretary, Housing and Town Planning Department, Member.
4. Director General, Tourism, U.P., Member, Convener.
5. Managing Director, U.P.S. Tourism Development Corporation Limited, Member.
B. That in Para No.4 of the extensive policy for above mentioned project, the limit of partnership of public enterprise/SPB or company of the State Government is changed from 20 percent of the maximum cost of land to minimum 20 percent of cost of land which is relevant for the project.
C. That the working agency will impose amount of 1 percent charge on the entire expenses (alongwith cost of land) while doing assessment of cost of the land for establishment of theme park. D. The working agency will provide freehold land to the S.P.V. after acquiring the land as per the rules, for which the freehold charge will be payable as per the rules.
E. That if the abovesaid project is implemented by any such public enterprise which is covered under some other Act, then in that event the related terms and conditions mentioned in the said Act will apply to the said project.
3. That the Official Order No.3150/41-2013-37 /Y0/2012, dated 06.11.2013 issued for the establishment of theme park/amusement park shall be assumed amended till the abovesaid limits. The terms and conditions and contract mentioned in the above Official Order shall remain as it is.”
3.9. It appears that the petitioner, after taking note of the amendments so brought about to the original policy, put forward a proposal for recognition of its project as a theme-based mall, and for benefits, under the said policy. The proposal so made by the petitioner was duly considered by the Committee constituted in terms of the said amendment Memo dated 03.05.2016 and recommendations were made for approval of the petitioner’s proposal. Accordingly, a letter dated 16.09.2016 was sent by the Director General Tourism, Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow informing
BHASIN INFOTECH AND INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD.
v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1074 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
the recommendation of the Committee. This letter/communication dated 16.09.2016 reads as under: - “This is to inform you about the above subject that in relation to construction of Theme Based Mall, the committee constituted for grant of permission under the policy promulgated by the Government of Uttar Pradesh, Tourism Division, Government Order No- 56/2016/ 691/41- 2016 -337 Sa/15 dt 03-5-2016, a proposal was considered by the committee in their meeting convened on 23.08.2016 under the chairmanship of Principal Secretary Tourism, Government of Uttar Pradesh.
In the recommendation meeting, a recommendation has been made by the committee to approve your proposal as a themebased mall as per the policy promulgated.
Sent for information and necessary action.”
4. Acting on and relying upon the letter aforesaid, the petitioner appears to have addressed various communications on 12.12.2016, 30.05.2017 and 19.02.2018 to UPSIDC for conversion of the subject land from leasehold to freehold but, all these communications were of no avail.
5. In the backdrop of events as aforesaid, it shall now be apposite to refer to the other writ petition pending in this Court, which has been filed by the director of petitioner-company, Satinder Singh Bhasin, being W.P. (Crl.) 242 of 2019, and wherein the order came to be passed for transfer of the present writ petition to this Court.
5.1. Shorn of unnecessary details, it appears that various persons were allotted commercial spaces in the mall and the commercial tower by the petitioner-company and its directors but, in due course of time, several FIRs were registered against them, alleging fraud, failure to give assured returns, non-completion of project on time, and siphoning of money and using it for advertising and procuring other projects. The allegations in those FIRs and refutation thereof are not of much relevance for the present purpose and do not require dilation herein.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.