Orbit Electricals Private Limited v. Deepak Kishan Chhabria & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 967; [2023] 15 S.C.R. 1022
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice It Went On to Deliver the Judgment Ignoring the Direction Therein. Said Order, Justice If Was in Willful Defi Ance of the Supreme Court’s Order. Contempt –
- Decided
- 30 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CONTEMPT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 1195/2023
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 15 S.C.R. 1022 : 2023 INSC 967
CASE DETAILS
ORBIT ELECTRICALS PRIVATE LIMITED
v.
DEEPAK KISHAN CHHABRIA & ORS.
(Contempt Petition (Civil) No 1195 of 2023)
In (Civil Appeal No. 6108 of 2023)
OCTOBER 30, 2023
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI, J. B. PARDIWALA AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Order dtd.13.10.23 was passed by the Supreme Court directing NCLAT to pronounce judgment in the pending appeal only after the results of the Annual General Meeting of Finolex Cables Limited were declared. Despite the fact that NCLAT’s attention was drawn to the order of the Supreme Court, it went on to deliver the judgment ignoring the direction therein. Said order, if was in willful defiance of the Supreme Court’s order.
Contempt – Interim direction passed by the NCLAT at the stage of reserving orders, restoring the status quo ante as available prior to EOGM dtd.03.05.19 was vacated by Supreme Court – While vacating the order, it was noted that the Annual General Meeting (AGM) of Finolex Cables Limited was to take place on 29.09.23 and directed that any action taken on the appointment of the Executive Chairperson shall be subject to the outcome of the appeal pending before NCLAT – Proceedings mentioned in the Contempt Petition, apprising the Supreme Court that the declaration of the result of the AGM was deferred till the declaration of the judgment by NCLAT – Vide Order dtd.13.10.23, Scrutinizer was directed to declare the result of the AGM and NCLAT was directed to declare its judgment in the pending appeal after it was duly apprised of the fact that the result of the AGM was declared – Grievance of the Petitioners that the NCLAT was though apprised of the said order, it proceeded to deliver the judgment ignoring the direction therein– Chairperson of the NCLAT directed to verify the position and submit report– Report submitted – Affidavits filed by the two members who constituted the Bench of the NCLAT and by the Scrutiniser:
Held: From the CCTV footage as well as from the transcript, it is evident beyond doubt that though the NCLAT was duly apprised of the fact that this Court had in the morning session on 13.10.23 passed an order to the effect that the judgment shall be pronounced only after the results by the Scrutiniser were declared, the Bench of the NCLAT declined to pay heed to the order of this Court – The Bench of the NCLAT acted in willful defiance of the order despite the fact that its attention was drawn to the order of this Court – Unconditional apology tendered by the Member (Technical) accepted – As regards the Member (Judicial), what was stated by him was contrary to the record – This was compounded by what had been stated in the affidavit filed – The conduct of the Member (Judicial) is censured – Further, on facts, there is no doubt that the the Scrutiniser acted in concert with ‘DKC’, the then acting Chairman-cum-Managing Director to delay the declaration of the result of the AGM, in breach of the directions issued by this Court – ‘DKC’ to pay Rs.1 crore and the Scrutiniser to pay Rs.10 lakhs to the Prime Minister’s Relief Fund – Directions issued in the earlier order of this Court setting aside the judgment delivered by the Bench of the NCLAT on 13.10.23, reiterated – Contempt proceedings disposed of. [Paras 19, 21-24, 26, 28, 31 and 33]
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
INHERENT JURISDICTION: Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 1195 of 2023 in Civil Appeal No. 6108 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 21.09.2023 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, Principal Bench at New Delhi in Company Appeal (AT) No.64 of 2020.
Appearances:
Mukul Rohatgi, Ranjeet Kumar, Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Sr. Advs., Kunal Mehta, Shikhil Suri, Abhinav Agrawal, Advs. for the Petitioner. ORBIT ELECTRICALS PRIVATE LIMITED v.
DEEPAK KISHAN CHHABRIA & ORS.
1024 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
Tushar Mehta, SG, Shyam Divan, Maninder Singh, Darius Khambata, Dr. A.M. Singhvi, Krishnendu Dutta, P.S. Patwalia, Prashanto Sen, Sr. Advs., Amit Jajoo, Malak Manish Bhatt, Ms. Vatsala Pant, Mandeep Singh, Somasekhar Sundaresan, Ravi Gadagkar, Nitin Saluja, Saahil Mongia, Ms. Ishita Soni, Ms. Simran Khurana, Ms. Pranya Madan, Ankur Saigal, E.C. Agrawala, Shashwat Singh, Ms. Geetika Sharma, Amit Pawan, Suchit Singh Rawat, Ms. Shivangi, Anand Nandan, Aakarsh, Hassan Zubair Waris, Kanu Agrawal, Madhav Sinhal, Bhuvan Kapoor, Deepak Khosla, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
ORDER
1 The order of this Court of 26 September 2023 sets out the background. Rather than replicate the background, we set it out below : “1 The National Company Law Tribunal1 dismissed the application filed by the first respondent for the grant of interim relief by an order dated 31 December 2019. The first respondent is in appeal before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal2. Admittedly, no interim relief operated in favour of the first respondent during the pendency of the appeal.
2 The appeal has been heard and orders were reserved by the NCLAT on 21 September 2023. However, while reserving orders, the NCLAT has directed the parties “to maintain status quo as was available prior to EOGM dated 03.05.2019” till the judgement is delivered. No reasons have been indicated by the NCLAT even prima facie for issuing the interim order, particularly in the context of the fact that there was no interim relief operating since the dismissal of the application for interim relief on 31 December 2019. It is admitted that no relief was obtained by the first respondent in the proceedings before the Bombay High Court, as well.
1 “NCLT”
2 “NCLAT”
3 In the circumstances, we vacate the interim direction as noted above. The Annual General Meeting (AGM) of the company, Finolex Cables Limited is to take place on 29 September 2023. Any action which is taken on proposed resolution No 4 pertaining to the appointment of the Executive Chairperson shall be subject to the outcome of the appeal which is pending before the NCLAT.
4 Subject to the aforesaid modifications, the appeals are allowed and the impugned order is set aside to the aforesaid extent. 5 Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.”
2 By the above order of this Court, the interim direction which was passed by the NCLAT on 21 September 2023 at the stage of reserving orders, restoring the status quo ante “as was available prior to EOGM dated 3 May 2019” was vacated bearing in mind that :
(i) No reasons at all were indicated;
(ii) No interim relief had operated since the dismissal of the application for interim relief on 31 December 2019; and
(iii) No relief was obtained by the first respondent in proceedings before the Bombay High Court.
3 While vacating the interim order, this Court noted that the Annual General Meeting of Finolex Cables Limited was to take place on 29 September 2023 and specifically directed that “any action which is taken place on proposed resolution No 4 pertaining to the appointment of the Executive Chairperson shall be subject to the outcome of the appeal which is pending before the NCLAT.”
4 Subsequently on 13 October 2023, the proceedings were mentioned before this Court in the morning session in Contempt Petition No 1195 of 2023, when the Court was apprised of the fact that the declaration of the result of the AGM was being deferred till the declaration of the judgment by the NCLAT. Taking note of the submission, this court observed : “We are prima facie of the view that the mandate of the order cannot be defeated by deferring the declaration of the result till a judgment is rendered by NCLAT.”
ORBIT ELECTRICALS PRIVATE LIMITED v.
DEEPAK KISHAN CHHABRIA & ORS.
1026 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
5 This Court specifically issued the following directions : “5 The scrutinizer shall, in compliance with the order of this Court proceed to declare the result of the Annual General Meeting which was held on 29 September 2023 forthwith;
6 The NCLAT shall proceed to declare its judgment in the pending appeal after it is duly apprised of the fact that the result of the Annual General Meeting has been declared.”
6 The above directions of this Court were in two parts. The first part which applied to the Scrutiniser contained a specific direction to the effect that in compliance with the previous order, the Scrutiniser shall proceed to declare the result of the AGM which was held on 29 September 2023. The second part, which was a direction to the NCLAT, was specifically to the effect that the NCLAT shall proceed to declare its judgment in the pending appeal after it is duly apprised of the fact that the result of the AGM has been declared.
7 In the afternoon session on 13 October 2023, a grievance was made before this Court on behalf of the petitioners that though the NCLAT was apprised of the order of this Court with a request that the judgment should not be delivered until the report of the Scrutiniser is made available, the Bench of the NCLAT had proceeded to deliver the order.
8 Consequently, this Court took note of the submission and required the Chairperson of the NCLAT to duly verify the position and report back to the Court. Paragraphs 3 to 9 of the order are set out below : “3 Mr Neeraj Kishan Kaul and Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, senior counsel and Mr Shikhil Suri, counsel joined in stating that counsel, Mr Ankur Saigal (who is personally present before this Court) produced the order of this Court before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at 2 pm with a request that the judgment should not be delivered until report of the scrutinizer is made available.
4 The Court has been apprised of the fact that the Bench of the NCLAT consisting of Mr Rakesh Kumar and Dr Alok Srivastava proceeded to deliver the order. If what is stated is correct, this will clearly constitute the defiance of the order of this Court by the NCLAT.
5 At this stage we are not commenting on the merits of the submissions which have been made.
6 The Court is apprised that the scrutinizer report was uploaded at 2.40 pm.
7 We direct that an enquiry shall be conducted on the above allegations by the Chairperson of the NCLAT. A report shall be submitted before this Court by 5 pm on 16 October 2023 after specifically verifying the facts from the Judges who constituted the Bench of the NCLAT.
8 The Chairperson of the NCLAT shall specifically verify:
(i) That the order of this Court dated 13 October 2023 passed in the morning session was drawn to the attention of the two Judges;
(ii) If that is so, the circumstances in which the Judges proceeded to pronounce the judgment despite the clear mandate of the order of this Court which was passed in the morning session.
9 We are passing this order in extraordinary circumstances, upon an urgent mentioning being made in that regard.”
9 In compliance with the order of this Court, the Chairperson of the NCLAT submitted a report before this Court which was taken note of in the order of this Court dated 18 October 2023. The relevant part of the order of this court reads thus :
“7 Pursuant to the order of this Court, Justice Ashok Bhushan, the learned Chairperson of the NCLAT has upon due verification from the Judges submitted a report to this Court. The report alludes to two separate statements which have been made before the Chairperson. The statement by Mr Rakesh Kumar, Member (Judicial) is recorded in paragraph 3 of the report in the following terms:
ORBIT ELECTRICALS PRIVATE LIMITED v.
DEEPAK KISHAN CHHABRIA & ORS.
1028 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
“Justice Rakesh Kumar, Member (Judicial) has given a response vide his letter dated 16.10.2023 which was received by me during lunch hours of 16.10.2023. In the response, the Member (Judicial) has stated “I may inform that on Friday in the Supplementary Cause List dated 13.10.2023 at 2 PM Company Appeal (AT) No 64/2020 (Deepak Chhabaria and Another) was listed under the caption “For Judgment” for its pronouncement. The said supplementary cause list was uploaded and published on one day earlier i.e. Thursday, 12.10.2023. My Lord is aware that normal procedure which is being followed in Bench of this Tribunal is that mentioning is entertained after the pronouncement of Judgment(s)/Order(s). I am not holding a constitutional post and as such I am required to follow the procedure. Accordingly as per procedure established here Judgment was pronounced on Friday i.e.13.10.2023.”
8 The statement by Dr Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) to the Chairperson is in the following terms:
“On 13.10.2023, when the Presiding Judge and I entered the Court Room No II in the post-lunch session, it was jam-packed with lawyers and there was unusually high noise in the court room.
A total 26 cases in the Supplementary Cause List and 18 cases in the Daily Cause List were listed under the categories “For Judgment/For Admission (Fresh Cases)/For Admission (After Notice)/For Orders/for Hearing” which had to be taken up in the post-lunch session.
The practice adopted in NCLAT is to have “mentionings” after pronouncement of judgment(s) listed in the cause list.
As the proceedings for the post-lunch session commenced, and the “For Judgment” case CA(AT) No.64 of 2020 was called out (as is the practice to take up “For Judgment” cases in the beginning), some lawyers started to intervene on which the Presiding Judge commented that whatever you want to file, please bring it on record.
Thereafter, the pronouncement of the said judgment was completed.
It may be pointed out that no lawyer conveyed the judgment orally to me during the lunch hour when I was available in my office chamber, nor copy of the said order was provided to the Court Master. If this would have been done, the unfortunate situation may not have arisen.
I respectfully submit that I hold the Hon’ble Supreme Court in highest regard and esteem and there has been no intention to disobey the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
I deeply regret that such a situation arose in the matter and offer sincere apology for the same.”
9 The Member (Technical) has adverted to the events which transpired before the NCLAT in the appeal on 13 October 2023. Paragraph 5 of the report reads as follows:
“I have taken the response given by the Judicial Member as well as the Technical Member. Company Appeal (AT) No.64 of 2020 was listed for pronouncement in Court No.II before the Bench constituted of Judicial Member and Technical Member. After the Court assembled, Learned Counsel for the parties who were present in the Court sought to intervene to make a request to the Bench, however, the Bench proceeded to pronounce the judgment not permitting the mentioning by the Learned Counsels. Copy of the order dated 13.10.2023 was not given either to the Court Officer or to the Bench. The Bench did not accept the request made on behalf of the Counsel and proceeded to pronounce the judgment. The judgment was pronounced in ignorance of the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 13.10.2023.”
10 The report of the Chairperson has also adverted to an order dated 16 October 2023 passed by the Bench of the NCLAT subsequently, in the following terms:
ORBIT ELECTRICALS PRIVATE LIMITED v.
DEEPAK KISHAN CHHABRIA & ORS.
1030 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
“16.10.2023: In aforesaid appeal on 13.10.2023, Judgment was pronounced. In the evening, the Registry brought to the notice an e-mail dated 13.10.2023 issued at 05.35 PM addressed to Registrar NCLAT enclosing therewith an order dated 13.10.2023, passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Contempt Petition (C) No.1195/2023 in C.A. No.6108/2023. After the order was produced we perused the same and we noticed that Hon’ble Supreme Court in its order in paragraph 1 sub- paragraph 6 had directed that Judgment in pending appeal shall be delivered by the NCLAT after it is duly apprised of the fact that the result of Annual General Meeting has been declared.
In view of the order of Hon’ble Supreme Court it is imperative for us to pass an order for Suspending the Judgment of this court dated 13.10.2023 till this appellate Tribunal is duly apprised of the fact that the result of the Annual General Meeting has been declared or subject to order/direction passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.”
11 There are two affidavits before the Court at the present stage:
(i) A “limited affidavit” which has been filed on behalf of the first respondent; and
(ii) An affidavit in rejoinder on behalf of the petitioner. 12 We have heard Mr Mukul Rohatgi, Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Mr Ranjeet Kumar, senior counsel on behalf of the petitioner and Mr Shyam Divan and Mr Ramji Srinivasan, senior counsel on behalf of the contesting respondents. Mr Darius Khambata, senior counsel has appeared on behalf of the scrutinizer. 13 Mr Mukul Rohatgi, senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner reiterates, as was submitted before this Court when it passed its order dated 13 October 2023 in the second session that Mr Ankur Saigal, counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner had produced the order of this Court before the NCLAT at 2 pm with a request that the judgment should not be delivered until the report of the scrutinizer is made available. This was specifically recorded in paragraph 3 of the order dated 13 October 2023. 14 Mr Ramji Srinivasan, senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant before the NCLAT has fairly stated before this Court that the order of this Court which was passed on 13 October 2023 was duly communicated to the contesting parties. Moreover, Mr Ramji Srinivasan also stated that at about 2.15 pm when the Bench of the NCLAT assembled, he personally sought to tender a copy of the order passed by this Court on 13 October 2023 in the morning session to the Bench of the NCLAT and apprised the Bench of the fact that this Court had specifically directed that the judgment of the NCLAT shall be delivered only after the Court was apprised of the results of the AGM. However, as things stand, the Bench of the NCLAT proceeded to declare the judgment. Mr Ramji Srinivasan further states that he apprised the Bench that the representative of the petitioner herein had already voted against the resolution at the AGM.
15 Apart from the statements which have been made by the senior counsel before this Court, the affidavit which has been filed by the first respondent contains the following averments:
“On 13.10.2023, the Contempt Petition was preliminary heard by this Hon’ble Court around 12.20 pm. On 13.10.2023, passed its first order on that date, which became available at around 1.55 pm (“First Order”). This Hon’ble Court directed Respondent No.2 to declare the result of the AGM which was held on 29.09.2023 forthwith. This Hon’ble Court directed that the Learned NCLAT shall proceed to declare its judgment in the pending appeal after it is duly apprised of the fact that the result of the AGM has been declared.
The directions as dictated in open court by this Hon’ble Court in the First Order were communicated to Respondent No.1 through his Advocates at around 12.30 pm. Respondent No.1 immediately called the Company Secretary of FCL, to convey the directions to Respondent No.2.”
16 The affidavit further states that on 13 October 2023, the report of the scrutinizer was prepared and was sought to be uploaded on ORBIT ELECTRICALS PRIVATE LIMITED v.
DEEPAK KISHAN CHHABRIA & ORS.
1032 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
the website of the Stock Exchanges in compliance of the order of this Court, but as the official servers of BSE Limited and National Stock Exchange of India Limited took time to respond, the report was uploaded at 2.41 pm and 2.44 pm respectively. The first respondent has disclosed what transpired before the NCLAT after the order of this Court dated 13 October in the following terms:
“At around 02.15 pm, when the NCLAT Appeal was called out ‘for judgment’, the Ld. Senior Counsel representing me informed the Learned NCLAT about the First Order and the directions contained therein. It was also informed to NCLAT that petitioner had voted against resolution No.4. It was also informed that the Consolidated Scruitinzer’s Report was being uploaded. The Learned NCLAT proceeded to pronounce the operative part of the Judgment dated 13.10.2023 (“NCLAT Judgment”), which occurred at around 2:15 pm. The NCLAT Judgment was only made available on the official website of the Learned NCLAT, at 4.30 pm and it was only after that time that it was even made public.” (emphasis supplied)
17 We will first deal with the report which has been submitted before this Court by the Chairperson of the NCLAT. The Presiding Judge, Mr Rakesh Kumar, Member (Judicial) states that the appeal was listed for pronouncement of judgment in the supplementary cause list which was uploaded on 12 October 2023. He states that the normal procedure which is followed in the tribunal is that mentioning is entertained after the pronouncement of judgments/ orders and since he is “not holding a constitutional post” as such he is “required to follow the procedure”. The Member (Judicial) has therefore stated that “as per the procedure established here” the judgment was pronounced on 13 October 2023.
18 The Member (Technical) on the other hand states that when the proceedings were called out in the post-lunch session in the case which was listed for judgment, “some lawyers started to intervene on which the Presiding Judge commented that whatever you want to file, please bring it on record”, after which, the pronouncement of the judgment was made. The Member (Technical) has tendered an unconditional apology to this Court. These facts are conspicuously absent in the statement of the Member (Judicial). 19 Neither the statement of the Member (Judicial) nor the statement which has been tendered by the Member (Technical) refer to the fact that the order dated 13 October 2023 passed by this Court in the morning session was communicated to the Bench of the NCLAT together with the directions which were contained therein. In paragraph 3 of the order dated 13 October 2023 passed in the afternoon session, the statement of senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner that the Bench of the NCLAT was apprised of the order of this Court in the afternoon session was recorded. This is also the clear case of the first respondent on affidavit since he has stated that around 2.15 pm when the NCLAT appeal was called out for judgment, the senior counsel representing him informed the Bench of the NCLAT of the order which was passed by this Court earlier and the directions which were contained therein. Neither the statement of the Member (Judicial) nor the statement of the Member (Technical) reveals this to the Chairperson of the NCLAT. In fact, the statement of the Member (Judicial) would seem to indicate that no mentioning is permitted at all before the declaration of judgment as a consequence of which the judgment was delivered without hearing any counsel on the order passed by this Court. Likewise, the statement of the Member (Technical) indicates that while some lawyers had attempted to intervene, the Presiding Officer had not permitted such an intervention and had proceeded to pass the judgment. The matter does not rest there.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.